Skip to main content

City Council School Board Interviews – March 23, 2021

March 23, 2021 at 8:55 AM

  • 2 h 32 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On March 23, 2021, the Asheville City Council held a session to interview seven candidates for three vacant seats on the Asheville City School Board. The interviews focused on the candidates’ professional backgrounds, their views on the racial achievement gap, financial sustainability, and their approaches to current controversies, including the potential closure of Asheville Primary School and the status of the desegregation order. No motions were made or votes taken during this interview session. The Chair confirmed that the City Council would vote on the appointments for the three vacancies at a meeting later that evening.

Candidate Discussions and Key Topics The candidates presented diverse perspectives on how to address systemic issues within the school district. Peyton O’Connor, a Recreation Services Director for Buncombe County, expressed concern about selling the Asheville Primary School building to cover short-term deficits, arguing it lacks long-term financial sustainability. She advocated for a transparent decision-making framework comparing repair costs against the loss of a centralized land asset. O’Connor also emphasized the need for a coherent, five-year strategic plan to guide the system, noting that equity requires broader community support in areas such as food access and transportation.

A former educator and business owner, who is also a former board chair of the Asheville City Schools Foundation, proposed strategies to close the achievement gap by acknowledging historical support for privileged families. He suggested creating spaces for marginalized voices, specifically supporting Black and Brown educators, and utilizing the "pod" system from the pandemic as a tool for educational transformation. He described his leadership style as a "non-anxious presence" and coalition builder, emphasizing the importance of listening and providing space for others.

Pat Griffin, an incumbent candidate with 47 years of experience in Asheville City Schools, argued that the board needs consistency to sustain changes regarding equity. She highlighted a significant disparity in kindergarten readiness, noting that 55% of white students were ready to read while a similar percentage of minority students were not. Griffin advocated for revising the preschool curriculum to teach prerequisite skills and emphasized the need for extended-day learning and parent engagement programs to help families advocate for their students.

Jackie McCarg, Dean of Students at UNC Asheville, emphasized the importance of addressing implicit bias and community trauma, citing her daughter’s PTSD symptoms following a school lockdown as an example of the need to consider historical context in decision-making. She argued that comprehensive training and accountability are necessary to address educators with disproportionate discipline records for students of color. McCarg also expressed interest in analyzing data intersectionalities and directly asking students experiencing opportunity gaps what they need.

Michelle Delange, an educator with 27 years of experience, addressed the perception that the system "feeds" white girls while "burying" Black boys. She shared an anecdote from a summer pod where a Black boy stated, "This is all a trick," arguing that if students perceive education as a test rather than a supportive environment, engagement suffers. Delange cited a national Teacher of the Year who stated that former teachers of color avoid returning because the institution remains traumatic. She expressed urgency to move beyond talking about equity, offering a drafted sample tool for assessing the superintendent and a vision for a new city webpage to invite system-wide reflection.

Another incumbent candidate, a lifelong Asheville resident currently serving on the board, acknowledged criticism of the board and superintendent, noting that COVID-19 prevented the realization of many initial plans. He stated that while the volume of negative feedback made him question whether to continue, he decided to seek reappointment because he believes he can endure the criticism if he is doing what is best for the system. He identified the "opportunity gap" as the primary area needing work, emphasizing the need to start at the Pre-K level and to build trust between the school and families.

James Lee, an incumbent candidate, discussed the need for improved communication and transparency, arguing that information should be released earlier to help residents digest changes. He expressed a personal preference for removing the desegregation order to allow parents full choice in school selection, stating he would vote to remove it if given the choice. Lee also discussed the challenge of retaining teachers of color due to high housing costs in Asheville, suggesting the need to work with the City Council and Buncombe County to help teachers afford housing and to reinstate the state’s teaching fellowship program.

Joyce Brown, an incumbent candidate and mother of two daughters who attended Asheville City Schools, stated she is seeking reappointment because she feels her work to improve the district is not finished. She identified expanding Pre-K, addressing disparities in discipline data, and expanding after-school care as key initiatives. Brown acknowledged that in her previous term, she did not proactively seek input from the community and committed to a more active communication strategy. She proposed a "360-degree evaluation" where the board evaluates itself using feedback from the community, teachers, and staff.

Decisions and Votes No motions were made, seconds, or votes taken during this interview session. The Chair confirmed that the City Council will vote on the appointments for the three vacant school board seats at the meeting later on March 23, 2021.

Follow-ups Several candidates outlined specific actions they would take if appointed. Peyton O’Connor stated she would make a distinction in her role regarding conflicts of interest. The former educator and business owner stated he would learn more about the cause of the budget reserve dip. Pat Griffin stated she would focus on preschool curriculum and after-school programs. Jackie McCarg stated she would look into data intersectionalities and student voices. Michelle Delange stated she had sent a draft assessment tool and webpage vision to the committee for their review. The incumbent candidate serving the remainder of James Lee’s term stated he would continue to work on the opportunity gap and Pre-K readiness. James Lee stated he would like to work with the City Council and Buncombe County to find ways to help teachers of color afford housing in Asheville and requested that Council members "push to get our teaching fellow program back" at the state level. Joyce Brown stated that if reappointed, she will reach out to as many community members as possible to gather input and proposed that the Board of Education implement a 360-degree evaluation process to assess its own performance based on community and staff feedback.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches