Skip to main content
  • 1 h 33 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview On March 22, 2021, the City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held a virtual meeting. The primary agenda item was an evidentiary hearing regarding a request for a variance to the City’s Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) grading standards for the property at 424 Sunset Drive. The Board also voted to adopt the minutes from its January 2021 meeting.

Key Decisions The Board voted unanimously (5 Ayes) to adopt the minutes from the January 2021 meeting. Regarding the variance request for 424 Sunset Drive, the Board voted to deny the request. The motion to grant the variance failed with a tally of 0 Ayes and 5 Nays.

Discussion Highlights The petitioner, Steven Farrell, a licensed architect acting as agent for the property owners, requested a variance to allow an additional 1,750 square feet of grading/disturbed area. Staff explained that a previous variance was granted in 2016 for 7,350 square feet of additional grading to accommodate landslide remediation, but the current request involved new grading that occurred during the construction of a new home, exceeding the limits of the 2016 variance. Staff noted that the project was completed and the variance request was "after-the-fact," resulting from a Notice of Violation (NOV) issued in late November 2020.

Mr. Farrell argued that the excess area resulted from complex topography, severe weather, and the use of mulch, which he initially did not consider "disturbance." He stated that geotechnical engineers certified the work did not increase instability and proposed planting additional native trees and shrubs. Joseph Hummel, the homeowner, testified that the construction was challenging due to the steep slope and that the crew was cautious, but acknowledged they may have gone slightly over the lines.

During the discussion, Chair Pratik Bhakta stated, "I can see three out of the four [standards for a variance], but the number three, which is a hardship did not result from the actions taken by the applicant... I just can't see that because this was granted. This was done... So, you know, the petitioner would have to remedy that with their agents and/or the city. But as it stands, based on those rules, I would say number three does not fall within the yes category for me." Board Member Paul Wilczynski initially expressed interest in attaching conditions related to stormwater ditches and remediation to a grant, but withdrew these conditions before the final vote. Board Member Suzanne Vernon Godsey expressed concern about sending the matter to the Urban Forestry Commission, stating, "I just think it would be cleaner if we just either grant the variance... or deny it." Mr. Farrell stated, "I'm a licensed architect... I am and remain a full-throated advocate of the steep slope ordinance... We followed the rules. We got a little bit over the lines... I throw myself on the mercy of the board."

Community Input Four public commenters spoke during the hearing, all expressing concerns about the construction, stormwater management, and the propriety of granting an after-the-fact variance. No specific member responded directly to these comments during the recorded portion of the meeting.

One public commenter, identified as an Urban Forestry Commission member and landscape contractor, expressed concern about soil erosion and the lack of silt fencing during utility trenching. They noted that neighbors had reported excessive grading and recommended against planting blueberries due to deer consumption, suggesting replanting hardwoods instead. They stated that owners and contractors in Steep Slope Zone B should be "hypervigilant" about grading parameters.

Another public commenter, the President of the Grove Park Sunset Mountain Neighborhood Association, recalled the 2013 mudslide and noted that the neighborhood had previously supported building at the base of the lot, but the Board had allowed construction at the top. They cited issues with unpermitted street closures, uncovered dumpsters, and the filling of stormwater ditches with stone to prevent trucks from getting stuck. This commenter requested that the Board deny the variance and require the owners to mitigate the exceeded disturbance and restore the stormwater ditches.

A third public commenter, a neighbor, reported increased stormwater runoff onto their property since the removal of mature trees and additional clearing. They noted that the house built was larger than the footprint shown in the 2016 variance exhibit and requested that the variance be denied or, if approved, that conditions be attached requiring the owner to restore vegetation and contain stormwater runoff.

A fourth public commenter, another neighbor, stated that the project built was significantly larger (approx. 4,500 sq. ft. multi-story) than the 2,500 sq. ft. single-story home described in the 2016 variance application. They expressed frustration that the City did not respond to complaints filed in August and September 2020 via the Asheville app. They cited issues with trash disposal attracting wildlife and the contractor’s failure to properly permit or notify neighbors of street closures. This commenter requested that the variance be denied, arguing it was sought in "bad faith" and that the hardship resulted from the petitioners' actions rather than the property's topography.

Follow-ups Assistant City Attorney Eric Edgerton stated that if the variance is denied, the code enforcement process that resulted in the Notice of Violation (NOV) would continue. He noted that the property owner might be required to appear before the Urban Forestry Commission to develop an alternative landscaping plan. The Chair indicated that the Assistant City Attorney would inform the petitioner of their next steps offline.

Impact The denial of the variance means the property owners at 424 Sunset Drive did not receive the requested relief for the additional 1,750 square feet of grading that exceeded the 2016 variance limits. Because the variance was denied, the code enforcement process initiated by the Notice of Violation will proceed. This outcome affects the property owners' ability to finalize compliance with the City's grading standards and may require them to address the excess disturbance through the code enforcement channel, potentially including appearances before the Urban Forestry Commission for landscaping plans.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches