Skip to main content
  • 1 h 31 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Downtown Commission Meeting Recap: March 12, 2021

The City of Asheville’s Downtown Commission met on March 12, 2021, to address procedural updates, design review changes, and various city reports. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, a legal briefing on new state conflict of interest standards, and an overview of the newly consolidated Design Review Committee. The meeting concluded with updates from the Downtown Association, the Parking and Transportation Working Group, and the Transportation Department regarding budget matters, outdoor dining, and the Vance Monument.

Key Decisions The Commission voted to accept the minutes from the February meeting as revised. Regarding the adoption of changes to the Rules of Procedure to comply with North Carolina General Statute 160D, an amendment to include "working groups" in the definition of hearing types failed with 5 ayes and 4 nays. The original motion to adopt the 160D-related changes, which covered conflict of interest, agenda, and hearing types, subsequently passed with 9 ayes and 1 nay. The Commission also voted unanimously (10 ayes) to request that staff review language regarding working groups and make recommendations to clarify their legal use. Finally, the Commission unanimously (10 ayes) accepted the new Design Review Committee structure, which specifies that City Council shall appoint four members of the Downtown Commission to serve on the City’s Design Review Committee.

Discussion Highlights Deputy City Attorney Jannice Ashley presented on the updated conflict of interest standards under General Statute 160D. She explained that boards and commissions must not vote on matters where they have a "direct substantial and readily identifiable financial impact." Ashley noted that this standard has been expanded to include zoning-related matters, where members must also avoid having a "close familial business or other associational relationship with the applicant or the property owner."

Shannon Tuck, Division Manager for Development and Design Review, presented on the new standing Design Review Committee, which consolidates subcommittees from the Downtown and Riverfront Commissions. Tuck stated that the three main goals were "improving design in the built environment... prioritizing updates to the design guidelines, and then strengthening, formalizing, and streamlining the design review process." Addressing potential workload concerns, Tuck added, "If we discover that the workload is too much, or we can't fill the seats for whatever reason, then we have already committed to a six-month review and evaluation of these new changes. And if we need to reconsider something at that time, we certainly will."

During the updates, Megan Rogers, a representative for the Downtown Association, expressed concern about parking rate revisions, stating, "My gut feeling is that this would be a negative reaction from our downtown business owners who just feel like parking is consistently made more difficult and more expensive." In response, Sage Turner, a Council Representative, provided data on parking availability, noting, "We had a 600 person waitlist for these parking decks for a long time... We now have 200 open spaces and everybody on the waitlist has been called. We have never had this problem." Additionally, Dana Berger, a staff member, reported on outdoor dining, stating, "We are continuing all of those temporary initiatives for the foreseeable future... We had about 90 businesses already participating."

Follow-ups Staff and legal counsel agreed to work on language for working groups and bring recommendations to the Commission to clarify their proper legal use and requirements. Staff also suggested that the City Clerk’s office attend the next meeting to discuss details regarding working groups and the transition back to live meetings. Regarding the Vance Monument, staff will provide information to City Council on March 23 regarding its removal; the Commission may request specific design process information from staff if questions arise after that date. The Commission also noted for future agenda items that they would like the Transportation Department to speak regarding revisions to parking rates and parking equipment.

Impact These decisions establish the legal framework for the Commission’s operations under new state laws, specifically tightening conflict of interest rules for zoning and planning votes. The consolidation of the Design Review Committee aims to streamline how design is evaluated in the built environment, with a built-in six-month review to assess the workload and effectiveness of the new structure. The discussion on parking and outdoor dining highlights the ongoing balance between supporting downtown businesses and managing city resources during the current public health landscape.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches