Skip to main content

African American Heritage Commission

March 11, 2021 at 11:29 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Next: Sep 9 meeting
  • 1 hlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview The City of Asheville’s African American Heritage Commission met on March 11, 2021. The meeting was held without a quorum, as five of the nine required members were not present. Consequently, the commission could not take any official votes or adopt formal decisions. The agenda included discussions on the commission’s work plan, street renaming strategies, terms of office, and the Vance Monument, as well as a period for public comment.

Key Discussions and Decisions Because no quorum was established, no binding actions were taken during the session. The Chair reviewed the commission’s mission, which includes establishing a community forum and prioritizing funding for African American communities, but no changes to the work plan were proposed. Regarding street renaming, the group generally favored using a "reservoir" of names for new streets rather than renaming existing ones, with the Chair noting that changing existing addresses would cause significant difficulty for small businesses. The Chair stated she intended to provide an official statement to the City regarding this stance.

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to discussing the recent recommendation by the Vance Monument Task Force to remove the monument. Council Member Sandra Kilgore argued for keeping the monument as a platform for education and storytelling about Black history in Asheville. Commission Member Brandon Oliver suggested a middle-ground approach, proposing the monument be left up but altered to show it has been "overcome," emphasizing that systemic issues are larger than a single structure. Commission Member Beverly Miller agreed with Council Member Kilgore that the monument should remain. The Chair expressed her personal hope that the City Council would honor the Task Force’s recommendation for removal, citing the extensive community input and the Vance family’s request.

The Board of Education presentation was tabled because the scheduled presenter was not on the call; it was noted that this item would likely move to the next meeting’s agenda. Additionally, the Chair announced that her term, along with those of members Catherine Mitchell and Marvin Chambers, is ending. She stated she intends to seek an additional term and will reach out to the other two members to determine their intentions.

Community Input Two members of the public provided comments during the meeting. One public commenter expressed frustration regarding his previous application to join the commission, stating he felt he had hit a "brick wall" and that the process was disingenuous. In response, the Chair explained that there are currently no vacancies and that she had not received an application from the individual for the recent vacancy. She committed to reaching out to the City’s appointment commission to check if the application was missing or incomplete and agreed to email the commenter to keep him informed of commission activities. Council Member Sandra Kilgore also responded, noting that she had seen the individual’s name on a list of applicants but acknowledged that the application did not come through on the county side.

A second public commenter asked what constitutes a quorum and expressed frustration that the lack of quorum stops progress, suggesting the body be restructured if quorum cannot be achieved after several meetings. He also emphasized the need for broader community involvement, suggesting the use of local newspaper corners to publicize meetings to reach residents who are not active on social media. The Chair explained that a quorum of five out of nine members is required by policy to prevent a small minority from making decisions for the whole body. She acknowledged the commenter’s point about progress but stated her hands were tied by the rules, while agreeing that the commission needs to improve accessibility. Council Member Sandra Kilgore agreed that the key issue is ensuring members are active and present, stating that the solution is to have members willing to commit the time.

Follow-ups The Chair agreed to reach out to the City’s appointment commission to investigate why the public commenter’s application was not received by the commission. She also agreed to email the public commenter to keep him informed of commission activities and to ensure his application is properly submitted for future vacancies. Commission Member Brandon Oliver agreed to send information about the "Champion Community" healing and storytelling sessions to the commission members. The Chair stated she would continue working with City staff, specifically the Deputy City Attorney, to find a workaround for broadcasting requirements so the commission can continue to meet monthly rather than quarterly.

Impact This meeting highlights the ongoing challenges the commission faces in maintaining consistent participation and quorum, which currently prevents the body from taking formal action on its agenda. The discussion on the Vance Monument reveals differing perspectives within the commission and with Council Member Kilgore regarding how to handle the site, ranging from removal to repurposing for educational purposes. The public comments underscore concerns about accessibility and the transparency of the appointment process, prompting the Chair to commit to investigating a specific application issue and improving communication with the community.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches