Skip to main content

Affordable Housing Advisory Committee

March 4, 2021 at 9:30 AM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Feb 4 meetingNext: May 6 meeting
  • 2 h 6 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview The City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) held a virtual meeting on March 4, 2021. The primary focus of the session was the Down Payment Assistance (DPA) Program, which is funded by the city’s affordable housing bond. The committee reviewed a proposal from Mountain Housing Opportunities (MHO) to administer the $1 million fund using a "Shared Appreciation Mortgage" model rather than the originally approved forgivable loan model.

Key Decisions The committee voted unanimously to accept the minutes from the previous meeting. Regarding the DPA Program, the committee did not vote to approve MHO as the administrator or to finalize the specific policy changes at this time. Instead, a motion was made and passed unanimously to ask staff to update the Down Payment Assistance policy based on the discussions held during the meeting and MHO’s proposal. Staff were directed to bring a draft policy back to the committee for review at the April 1 meeting.

Discussion Highlights The discussion centered on the structural changes proposed by MHO, which would convert the DPA from a forgivable loan—forgiven after 20 to 30 years—to a non-forgivable, revolving shared appreciation loan. Under this model, the loan is repaid upon the sale of the home, with the repayment amount including a share of the home’s appreciation. Mike Vance of Mountain Housing Opportunities explained that the biggest difference is that the fund would be revolving rather than forgivable, noting, "We are not taking or sharing any equity, just the appreciation. And if there is no appreciation, the borrower borrowed the money at 0%." Vance also noted that using a non-forgivable model allows the city to apply for federal matching funds (CDFI) to expand the program’s reach, while staff confirmed that the bond funds must be spent by October 2023.

Members debated the balance between creating wealth for homeowners and ensuring access for low-income residents. Some members expressed concern that removing forgiveness creates an "intergenerational debt" burden for families who inherit homes. Dawana, a committee member, stated, "I'm thinking about the intergenerational debt that's applied to the families... to apply the debt with unforgiveness and inheritance of debt. It's just like it's uncomfortable." Other members argued the model is similar to a Community Land Trust and necessary to keep the fund revolving in a high-appreciation market. Several members emphasized that the committee had not seen a formal written policy reflecting the proposed changes, specifically the removal of forgiveness and adjustments to loan limits. Chair Barry Bialik stated, "We need to really spend the bulk of the meeting talking about our down payment assistance... to see if we can come to a consensus and agree to move it along, or if we think we need to take a deeper dive into this."

Community Input One written public comment was read by the Chair. The commenter, a resident of Buncombe County, expressed concern about the lack of payment forgiveness in the proposal, stating that the process felt "rushed." They argued that any contract attached to affordable housing should not require those experiencing poverty to repay the down payment, and that low-income individuals should have input on this decision. Members did not respond directly to the specific content of this written comment during the meeting.

Follow-ups Paul D’Angelo, Community Development Program Director, agreed to draft an updated Down Payment Assistance policy that incorporates the changes discussed, such as the shared appreciation model and potential adjustments to loan limits. He stated he would aim to have the draft ready by the Friday before the next meeting, or at the latest by 5:00 PM on Monday, March 29, 2021. The committee will review the draft policy at their April 1, 2021 meeting, with staff recommending that the majority of that meeting be dedicated to this topic.

Impact This discussion is significant for residents because it determines the long-term financial obligations associated with the city’s $1 million Down Payment Assistance Program. The shift from a forgivable loan to a shared appreciation model changes how homeowners repay the assistance, potentially affecting families who may inherit the property or sell it in a high-appreciation market. The decision to draft a formal policy before final approval ensures that the specific terms, including loan limits and repayment structures, are clearly defined before the program is implemented.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches