Public Safety Committee
February 23, 2021 at 10:59 AM
- 47 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On February 23, 2021, the City of Asheville Public Safety Committee held a virtual meeting chaired by Vice Mayor Shanika Smith. The agenda consisted primarily of informational activity reports from the Fire Department and the Police Department, along with the approval of previous meeting minutes. No formal policy decisions or new initiatives were adopted during this session.
Key Decisions The only formal action taken at the meeting was the approval of the minutes. A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes, followed by a roll call vote in which Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore, Councilwoman Kim Roney, and Vice Mayor Shanika Smith all voted "Aye." Consequently, the minutes were approved unanimously. No other motions, votes, or formal decisions were recorded.
Fire Department Updates Fire Chief Scott Burnett presented an activity report highlighting a steady increase in fires investigated over the last four years, with a specific upward trend in intentionally set (incendiary) fires. In response, the Fire Marshal division was restructured to merge education and investigation functions. The department reported receiving a $42,000 FEMA grant for fire investigation equipment and is implementing a software application called "Streamline" to digitize building risk data. Chief Burnett noted that while in-person training decreased due to pandemic restrictions, virtual outreach reached over 100,000 people. He emphasized a strategic shift from a reactive model to a proactive one, aiming for firefighters to be present at community events to build relationships. Additionally, the department is preparing to promote the free PulsePoint app, which alerts nearby users to cardiac arrest 911 calls and shows the location of publicly accessible AEDs.
Police Department Updates Police Chief David Zak reported on the status of the Community Engagement Division, which started in November 2020 with 15 officers. Since inception, the division has handled 87 complaints, closing 21 and leaving 66 pending. A significant portion of the discussion focused on the department's staffing crisis; the department was budgeted for 238 sworn officers in January 2020 but has lost 69 officers since then, operating at 65–69% of its sworn staff capacity on any given day. This shortage has led to operational adjustments, including reassigning detectives to patrol work, reducing School Resource Officers from 5 to 3, and eliminating all bike and foot patrols citywide. Chief Zak warned that response times for Priority 1 calls have increased by 27% (roughly two minutes longer) compared to May 2020 baselines, stating, "When you're in trouble and when your life's in jeopardy, that's a lot. Two minutes seems like a lifetime." He also noted that violent crime is holding steady compared to 2020 levels, though gun discharge calls remain high.
Member Discussion and Requests During the discussion, Councilwoman Kim Roney expressed concern that the department might be "overstating the harm" given lower homicide and rape statistics, noting that the current data may not provide a full picture. She requested a data analysis regarding 2018 resolutions on written consent to search and deprioritizing low-level stops, stating this should be a future agenda item for the committee. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore suggested creating a map to identify concentrations of issues to better direct education and efforts in collaboration with other agencies. Chief Zak responded that the department is in a mode where they must "triage and make sure that we're getting to those emergency calls first."
Follow-ups Chief Burnett stated that the Fire Department will work with community and public engagement staff to promote the PulsePoint app as widely as possible and requested Council’s assistance in promoting it to their connections. Chief Zak stated that the Police Department will continue to promote the online reporting tool for minor issues to free up officers for higher-priority calls. He also confirmed that the Vistalar de-escalation and crisis management training will roll out in March 2021 and will be mandatory for all sworn officers.
Community Input The chair opened the floor for public comment at both the beginning and the end of the meeting. Staff confirmed there was no one in the speaker queue, and no public comments were made.
Meeting Video & Transcript