Affordable Housing Advisory Committee
January 13, 2021 at 9:00 AM
- 53 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview On January 13, 2021, the City of Asheville’s Affordable Housing Advisory Committee (AHAC) held a virtual special meeting to discuss the Down Payment Assistance (DPA) Program. The primary focus of the session was the selection of a third-party administrator and the program’s policy structure, specifically regarding loan forgiveness and funding sustainability.
Key Decisions The committee voted to approve recommended changes to the DPA Program proposed by Mountain Housing, the selected third-party provider. Chair Barry Bialik moved to approve these changes and to strongly suggest that staff continue negotiations to move the program toward the contract phase. Scott Adams seconded the motion. The vote was taken by roll call and passed unanimously (5-0). The Chair noted that the committee was technically shy of a quorum, as five members were present versus the six required, but proceeded with the vote to provide clear direction to staff.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the discussion centered on a conflict between the original policy design and the recommendations from Mountain Housing. The original policy included partial loan forgiveness after 20 years and full forgiveness after 30 years; however, Mountain Housing recommended that the loan not be forgivable even after 30 years. Staff explained that City Management had removed the item from the upcoming Housing and Community Development (HCD) agenda due to internal disagreement over this forgiveness clause, noting that the item was expected to return to the HCD agenda in February.
Chair Barry Bialik presented data showing that current low interest rates (approximately 2.7%–3%) create a critical window for home affordability. He argued that increasing the DPA amount for the 60% Area Median Income (AMI) tier from $40,000 to $50,000 would help eliminate the Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI) requirement, making loans feasible for lower-income households. Bialik expressed a strong desire to keep the program moving forward, stating, "We as a committee have the voice to keep things moving... despite there might be hesitance from some, we are the people. So we have the right to keep this moving." Member Paul Heathman acknowledged the uncertainty of the economic environment, remarking, "If I knew that answer [about interest rates], I’d be quite valuable, wouldn’t I? ... If we’ve learned anything this last year is that we have no idea."
The committee also discussed the need for the DPA fund to operate as a "revolving" or "living" fund. Staff noted that Mountain Housing’s model allows funds to be recycled as loans are repaid or properties are sold, which reduces the need for future bond measures. Member Margie Bukowski supported this approach, stating, "I think that’s the right thing to do is to keep it revolving because the opportunity for the city to go on another big bond is perhaps not something in the near future." Additionally, the group discussed the impact of Homeowners Association (HOA) fees on affordability, noting that townhome structures often have lower HOA fees than condos and that developers are designing projects to keep these costs minimal.
Community Input Two written public comments were read aloud by the Chair. A public commenter suggested that Asheville should change its code to allow for tiny house construction on small lots to help low-income individuals own homes. In response, the Chair noted that state building codes are currently being adjusted to accommodate such provisions, but current zoning codes do not allow structures not on attached foundations. He stated this is a significant discussion that the committee will likely hear more about in the future.
A second public commenter asked what the committee could do to address housing needs for teens aging out of foster care. In response, Scott Adams suggested looking at the city’s Unified Development Ordinance regarding current policies on Single Room Occupancies (SROs) or boarding houses.
Follow-Ups Staff agreed to add the AHAC’s recommendation to accept Mountain Housing’s changes to the February AHAC agenda and to include a section in the staff report for the HCD meeting in February. Staff also agreed to work with the Chair to adjust the February agenda to allow time for further discussion on the DPA amounts, specifically the proposal to increase the 60% AMI tier to $50,000. Additionally, staff will continue to work on making the city’s "Appendix 2" home ownership calculator available as a live tool on the website and will remind the public to sign up for the community development listserv for meeting updates.
Impact This meeting provided clear direction to staff regarding the administration of the Down Payment Assistance Program, a tool designed to help residents purchase homes. By approving the third-party administrator's recommended changes and emphasizing the need for a revolving fund, the committee aimed to ensure the program's financial sustainability without relying on new bond measures. The discussion highlighted the urgency of utilizing current low interest rates to assist households at 60% and 80% of the Area Median Income in qualifying for loans.
Meeting Video & Transcript