City Council Meeting – July 23, 2019
July 23, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 21 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: July 23, 2019
The City of Asheville City Council held its regular meeting on July 23, 2019. Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler presided over the session in the absence of Mayor Esther Manheimer. The agenda included routine approvals, public hearings on zoning requests, housing trust fund applications, board appointments, and open public comment.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council voted to accept the consent agenda, which included contracts for the Richmond Hill bathrooms/picnic shelter, Wood Avenue sidewalks, and the Art Station reconstruction. The Council also voted to recommend approval of a conditional zoning request for the Givens Estate Friendship Park project, which involves rezoning a 4.3-acre parcel to demolish 11 buildings (86 units) and construct two new buildings (80 units) for seniors. A motion to continue the public hearing for the One South Tunnel Road mixed-use development to the August 27 council meeting was also passed.
Regarding housing, the Council voted to approve three Housing Trust Fund applications: a $530,000 loan to Homeward Bound for permanent supportive housing at Short Michigan; an additional $650,000 loan (totaling $1.3 million) to Swannanoa Bend LLC for a loan modification; and an additional $600,000 loan (totaling $1.2 million) to Workforce Homestead Incorporated for the Amaranth Apartments tax credit development. For board appointments, the Council voted to recommend Robin Cape for the ABC Board and Jan Davis as ABC Board Chair. The Multimodal Transportation Committee recommended postponing its appointment until the August meeting. Finally, the Council voted to enter a closed session to consult with the City Attorney regarding an administrative procedure and potential lawsuit concerning city council election districts.
Discussion Highlights During the public hearing for the Givens Estate Friendship Park, John Cowan, Executive Director at Givens Estates, stated, "We are replacing 86 existing residences and 11 buildings within the two buildings on this site... We're not displacing anyone." In the housing segment, Meredith Schweitzer, Executive Director at Homeward Bound, remarked, "This is really going to be our first foray into affordable housing, and we are incredibly excited about the impact of that." Council Member Sheneika Smith highlighted the consent agenda items, noting, "There's lots of things on this consent agenda that are about progress... So just wanted to point out that things do get done." She also addressed private developer Kirk Booth, stating, "Kirk you are a private developer... We would love to be working with more private developers so if you are a private housing developer do not think that you cannot make this work because you can because Kirk does and Over and over again." Smith further emphasized the need for additional funding, stating, "The point I think that we've been making at HCD is we need more money. I know everybody thinks we approved a $25 million housing bond, and we're great, and we're all set. But we're not."
Community Input During open public comment, a resident from East Asheville discussed the use of tiny houses on wheels as an affordable housing solution, noting that campground use was removed from the Highway Business District code without explicit notice. Council Member Smith responded by stating that the Council is having a work session on affordable housing on September 6th and that staff have been asked to help understand the current regulatory framework around tiny houses. A representative for the Council of Independent Business Owners criticized the city’s infrastructure maintenance, citing transit inefficiencies, aging water lines, and poor street conditions, urging the Council to refocus capital budget resources on repairs; members did not respond. Multiple public commenters asked for a timeline on whether the City will pursue a charter amendment for at-large elections or legal action against current districting; members did not respond directly during the comment period, though the Council subsequently moved to closed session to consult with the City Attorney on the potential lawsuit. A resident reported a recurring drainage issue at a local grocery store, asking who makes the final decision on the engineering plan; members did not respond. Finally, a public commenter asked for guidance on hotel construction and tourism; Council Member Smith stated that the Planning, Environment, and Development (PED) committee will receive an initial briefing on a hotel moratorium at their August 29th meeting and suggested a moratorium could be in place before the end of the year.
Follow-ups Council Member Smith explicitly stated that the Council will hold a work session on affordable housing on September 6th, where staff will help the Council understand the regulatory framework for tiny houses. She also stated that the PED committee will receive an initial briefing on a hotel moratorium at their August 29th meeting. Staff member Paul D’Angelo reported that after the approvals made that night, the Housing Trust Fund will have approximately $3.5 million remaining. Council Member Smith noted that this amount is likely insufficient for future needs and suggested looking at general obligation bonds for affordable housing.
Impact These decisions advance specific housing projects and infrastructure contracts while highlighting ongoing debates regarding affordable housing funding and regulatory frameworks. The approval of the Givens Estate zoning request facilitates senior housing development, and the Housing Trust Fund loans support various affordable housing initiatives, though staff noted the remaining fund balance may be limited. The Council’s move to closed session regarding election districts indicates active legal consultation on a contentious local issue, while the scheduled briefings on tiny houses and hotel moratoriums signal upcoming policy discussions on housing and tourism impacts.
Meeting Video & Transcript