City Council Meeting – March 26, 2019
March 26, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 40 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: March 26, 2019
The City of Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on March 26, 2019, addressing a variety of routine and special business items. The agenda included proclamations for Arbor Day and the recognition of a local appointment to the North Carolina Financial Literacy Council, a consent agenda, three public hearings regarding zoning and development, unfinished business concerning a housing grant, and new business regarding Board of Education appointments. The meeting concluded with general public comment and a move to closed session.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council took several formal votes during the meeting. The consent agenda, which included a resolution regarding physician services at the employee health center, passed unanimously. A motion to continue the conditional zoning hearing for property at 3 Avon Road to April 9, 2019, to coordinate with a lease date, also passed unanimously. The most significant decision of the evening was the approval of a rezoning for a 56-room hotel and mixed-use development at 155, 137, 129, and 123 Biltmore Avenue. This motion to approve the rezoning from the Central Business District to the Central Business District Expansion Conditional Zone passed with a split vote of 5 in favor and 2 opposed. In favor were Mayor Esther Manheimer, Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler, Councilmember Sheneika Smith, Councilmember Vijay Kapoor, and Councilmember Julie Mayfield. Opposed were Councilmember Brian Haynes and Councilmember Keith Young. Additionally, the Council unanimously approved wording amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Articles 5, 9, and 15, which require Historic Resources Commission review for subdivisions in historic overlay districts. The Council also unanimously authorized the City Manager to negotiate a $4.2 million grant agreement with the Housing Authority for the redevelopment of Lee Walker Heights and to approve a budget amendment. Regarding the Asheville City Board of Education, the Council unanimously reappointed Martha Geithner and Shonda Sanford to four-year terms. For a two-year term filling the remainder of Mr. Lee’s term, the Council voted 5-2 to appoint James Carter. Finally, the Council unanimously moved to closed session to consult with an attorney regarding potential lawsuits involving Estate of Jalativ Savage Williams v. Sgt. Tyler Kelly Radford and City of Asheville v. Bird Rides.
Discussion Highlights The Biltmore Avenue hotel project generated the most debate among Council members. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated, "I will try to consider each one of these on a case-by-case basis... as long as we're continuing that conversation [with the Tourism Development Authority] in a positive direction and it results in a concrete plan." Councilmember Julie Mayfield expressed support, saying, "I see that in this developer and I want to encourage that continued investment in our community... I am going to be supporting this." Councilmember Keith Young noted, "I'm not a yes hotel guy. I'm going to say yes tonight... But as we move forward, the message to everyone else who's coming in front of city council is, in my opinion, you got to do more." Councilmember Brian Haynes opposed the project, stating, "Anytime we add another luxury hotel in our downtown, all we're doing is making the affordability of this city just continue to rise... I will not be supporting this." Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler also voted against the project, explaining, "I applaud the applicants interest in uh preserving those homes... but not at the expense of building another hotel... I have to vote down on this."
Community Input During the public hearing for the Biltmore Avenue hotel, a certified city planner and historic preservationist supported the project, citing benefits to the corridor and historic preservation. A downtown resident asked about noise from the proposed event space; after the hearing closed, staff and the applicant addressed this, with the developer stating, "We're not going to be a beer venue. We're a family lodge... It will be a low key event." A local general contractor supported the project, noting that 80-90% of construction spending would go to local firms. A resident opposed the project, arguing that adding another luxury hotel increases affordability issues. A developer responded to feasibility questions, stating the hotel was the "best alternative" to support the repair of the three historic houses on the site. During the consent agenda, a former city physician expressed concern about the resolution for physician services from Fletcher Hospital, arguing that Fletcher physicians lacked the specialized occupational medicine training required for the city role. No specific member replied to the substance of this comment before the vote. During general public comment, a member of the LGBTQ community urged the Council to fight against gerrymandering and maintain at-large election districts. A resident suggested the City sign off on new district maps to allow for legal review. Mayor Esther Manheimer clarified that the maps were drawn by the legislature and sent to the City, which then forwarded them to the Buncombe County Board of Elections, stating, "I don't know that any city action is required at all." Staff member Alex Smith added, "It's all taken care of."
Follow-ups Staff member Sasha confirmed that an 18th condition was added to the Biltmore Avenue motion, specifying that the 18 parking spaces on South Lexington Avenue would be publicly available, a condition the applicant agreed to. Regarding Lee Walker Heights, staff member Paul D'Angelo noted that preliminary conversations have already begun regarding the next phase of the project.
Impact These decisions impact the downtown landscape and housing stability in Asheville. The approval of the Biltmore Avenue development adds a 56-room hotel and mixed-use space to a historic corridor, with conditions ensuring public access to specific parking spaces. The UDO amendments strengthen historic preservation protections by mandating commission review for subdivisions in overlay districts. The $4.2 million grant agreement moves the redevelopment of Lee Walker Heights forward, with the Housing Authority confirming that the relocation process for residents was completed successfully.
Meeting Video & Transcript