Skip to main content

City Council Meeting – January 22, 2019

January 22, 2019 at 11:00 AM

  • 2 h 58 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: January 22, 2019

The Asheville City Council convened on January 22, 2019, to address a range of municipal issues, including budget planning, zoning, public safety, and election law. The meeting opened with three proclamations: the Mayor designated the day as National Day of Racial Healing, introduced the newly staffed Equity and Inclusion team, and proclaimed the week of February 4–10, 2019, as Celebrate Tennis Week in anticipation of the Fed Cup’s return. Additionally, the city received the 2018 Duke Energy Power Partner Award for Innovation and Sustainability, recognizing the city’s efforts to delay a forecasted natural gas peaker plant and exceed its solar and battery storage targets.

The Council unanimously approved the Consent Agenda. Following this, Chief Financial Officer Barbara Whitehorn presented on budget priorities, noting that public safety and environmental protection were the top concerns in recent citizen surveys. She outlined plans for more inclusive outreach in the 2021 budget process, including targeted engagement with underrepresented groups and additional meeting locations.

In zoning matters, the Council held a public hearing on a request to build a gas-insulated electric utility substation at 252 Patton Avenue and 28 Knoxville Place. The applicant presented a single-story design resulting from community collaboration. With no public comments recorded during the hearing, the Council unanimously voted to approve the conditional zoning request for the 5,200-square-foot facility.

Regarding the Haywood Page redevelopment, the Council unanimously adopted a resolution authorizing the City Manager to identify a multi-year funding strategy to complete the site design implementation plan. This decision supports the hiring of the Nelson Byrd-Wolz team for the project.

The Council did not approve a proposed revision to the city’s noise ordinance. A motion was made to adopt the changes, which would have classified noise violations as infractions rather than civil penalties and disbanded the Noise Ordinance Appeals Board. However, the motion was withdrawn after Council members and the public raised concerns about the lack of prior public engagement, equity implications, and the shift toward criminal court administration. Staff clarified that this was intended as a "first step," with a more comprehensive review of noise regulations, including commercial noise and specific decibel standards, planned for later in the year.

Finally, the Council discussed the legal implications of a recent state bill (Senate Bill 813) that imposes district-based elections on Asheville and shifts city elections to even-numbered years. No formal vote was taken on this item. The Mayor stated that the Council has asked the interim city attorney to solicit legal advice from experts in election law to determine the best course of action, such as litigation or a referendum.

Community Input Public comment was recorded for the Haywood Page redevelopment and the noise ordinance. For the Haywood Page item, numerous residents and representatives spoke in favor of funding the design team, citing the site’s importance for civic engagement, the impact of the Elder and Sage Community Garden, and the need for inclusive public space. The Mayor acknowledged the "rare synergy" of stakeholders reaching near-unanimity through a collaborative process.

For the noise ordinance, public commenters expressed significant concern. One commenter argued the ordinance lacked sufficient public input, while another urged the Council to address continuous commercial noise from large institutions. Others raised equity and criminal justice concerns, noting that moving violations to the criminal system could disproportionately affect minority and low-income residents, and that adding noise enforcement to police duties is not sensible given stretched resources. In response, the Mayor stated that the Council has been eager to act due to high complaint volumes but would be comfortable waiting for a comprehensive rewrite if the community felt it was necessary. She also noted the city’s limited staff resources for scientific noise analysis.

Follow-ups Staff explicitly stated they are working on planning for the 2021 budget with more inclusive outreach strategies. The City Manager’s office indicated an interest in launching a next phase of community engagement for a comprehensive noise regulation review, possibly by the end of 2019. Additionally, the interim city attorney has been asked to solicit legal advice from state experts regarding the districting bill to assess the viability of a legal claim or referendum.

Impact These decisions reflect the Council’s focus on balancing community development with public safety and equity. The approval of the substation and the Haywood Page funding strategy moves long-term infrastructure and public space projects forward. The withdrawal of the noise ordinance highlights ongoing tensions between addressing resident complaints and ensuring equitable, thoroughly vetted policy changes. The discussion on election districting signals a potential legal challenge to state-imposed changes in how local elections are conducted.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches