City Council Meeting – September 25, 2018
September 25, 2018 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 24 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: September 25, 2018
The Asheville City Council convened on September 25, 2018, to address public safety, transportation planning, and community development. The meeting opened with the Pledge of Allegiance and the issuance of three proclamations: Energy Efficiency Day for October 5, Fire Prevention Week for October 7–13, and a proclamation against gun violence issued in response to recent local deaths. The Council unanimously adopted the Consent Agenda before moving to substantive discussions on police reform, neighborhood planning, and corridor studies.
Key Decisions The Council took four formal votes during the meeting, all of which passed unanimously with no recorded nays. First, the Council approved the Consent Agenda. Second, the Council voted to recommend the adoption of the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan, a mitigation plan associated with the I-26 Connector project. Third, the Council authorized the City Manager to select the South Tunnel Road corridor for a study and directed staff to conduct a review focused on enhancing safety, multimodal transportation, and recommending zoning changes. Finally, the Council voted to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding the lawsuit James Robert West v. City of Asheville and to consider the qualifications of a public officer for the City Manager selection.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the 21st Century Policing Solutions (21CP) Report. Chief Tammy Hooper provided a status update on police department recommendations, noting that an assessment by policy experts highlighted gaps and blind spots in existing policies. She stated, "having an assessment by policy experts to show us not really just how we did in regard to responding to this incident, but where our gaps and blind spots were in our policies that enabled it to occur to begin with is where I think we have the most room to improve how we do things." Dawa Hitch, Director of Communications & Public Engagement, discussed city-wide communication and crisis response recommendations. A Council member responded to the crisis communication discussion by thanking Chief Hooper for her progress and urging the Council to be efficient in using lessons learned from earlier in the year to fix the process.
Regarding the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan, a Council member thanked neighborhood leaders for raising concerns that were addressed in the final draft and encouraged them to continue advocating for the city to move in the direction they want. On the South Tunnel Road Corridor Study, a Council member noted that East Asheville is anxious for the city to take a good look at the area, wondering if there are opportunities to redevelop the traffic pattern from the tunnel to the highway in a way that is more urban, walkable, and accessible to bikes and pedestrians.
Community Input Public comment was received on both the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan and the South Tunnel Road Corridor Study. Regarding the Burton Street plan, a public commenter expressed hope that adoption would lead to immediate resources rather than waiting another 10 years, noting that previous plans had "sat on a shelf." Another public commenter thanked NCDOT and the City for "giving something back" to the community after years of being "inundated by highways," urging the Council not to "take a hundred years" to implement the plan. A third public commenter, speaking on behalf of three elderly women, asked for "big changes" before the women "leave this side," noting that the community’s tax base is high and services should match it. In response to these comments, a Council member suggested that the neighborhood association prioritize the 12 city-responsible strategies in the plan, identifying the top three they want done in the next year to provide guidance to the City.
For the South Tunnel Road Corridor Study, a public commenter raised concerns about emergency situations, such as power outages causing traffic chaos, and suggested considering one-way side streets or other adaptations for future resilience. Another public commenter echoed these concerns, noting the danger of driving without lights and asking if solar power backup for traffic lights was being considered. Members did not respond to these specific technical questions regarding emergency power or one-way streets during the recorded portion of the meeting.
During general public comment on non-agenda items, a public commenter read a letter requesting that the Council hire a City Manager with expertise in sustainability to oversee the transition to clean energy. Another public commenter thanked the Council for detailed budget information and requested that the budget process include more details on contracted services, grants, and opportunities for employing workers in the "U6" unemployment category. A third public commenter presented data on gentrification and the lack of diversity in local leadership, urging the Council to consider diversity in the City Manager selection. Members did not respond to these general public comments before the Council moved to the closed session motion.
Follow-ups Staff members outlined several next steps during the meeting. Chief Tammy Hooper reported that the Police Department has completed revisions to the Field Training Officer selection process and lowered the thresholds for the Early Intervention System triggers from six incidents to three within a year, adding body-worn camera review to the protocol. The department is working to implement peer intervention training, aiming to train internal trainers by the end of the year or early next year, and is working with the City Attorney’s Office and the District Attorney to finalize a policy for reviewing excessive force complaints. Dawa Hitch stated that staff will conduct a SWOT analysis to develop a crisis communication policy and standard operating procedures, and the City is considering retaining a firm for crisis response services in the upcoming 2019-2020 budget process. Planning Department staff indicated they will proceed with the Request for Proposal for the South Tunnel Road corridor study and coordinate with Buncombe County staff regarding the Hendersonville Road corridor study. Additionally, staff is working with legal to differentiate between changes that require legislative action and those that can be made in-house regarding the Civil Service Board, with the Board intending to address rule adoption at its October meeting.
Impact These decisions and discussions reflect the Council's focus on improving public safety accountability, addressing infrastructure needs in rapidly changing neighborhoods, and preparing for future leadership. The adoption of the Burton Street Neighborhood Plan and the authorization of the South Tunnel Road study provide a framework for managing growth and transportation in these areas. The detailed updates on police reform and crisis communication signal ongoing efforts to address systemic issues and improve how the city responds to emergencies.
Meeting Video & Transcript