City Council Budget Work Session – September 25, 2018
September 25, 2018 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 42 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Budget Work Session Recap: September 25, 2018
The City Council held its second of five scheduled budget work sessions for the fall on September 25, 2018. The session focused on reviewing detailed budget presentations from five departments: Fire, Communications & Public Engagement, Parks & Recreation, Human Resources, and Planning & Urban Design. The discussions centered on departmental challenges, service delivery models, and key budget drivers. Due to time constraints, the Planning & Urban Design presentation was moved to the next public works session. No formal public comments were recorded; the "public input" section consisted of questions and dialogue between Council members and department directors.
Fire Department Interim Fire Chief Chris Baczynski presented an overview of the department’s $25.4 million budget, which supports over 260 Full-Time Equivalent (FTE) employees, with 88% of the budget allocated to staffing. The department handles approximately 20,000 calls annually, split evenly between fire suppression and emergency medical services (EMS). The Fire Chief noted that the department responds only to life-threatening medical emergencies, a practice managed by the Emergency Medical Dispatch (EMD) program for approximately 10 years. Key budget drivers include rising costs for Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), specifically turnout gear, for which the Council previously approved $780,000 for a second set. Fleet maintenance costs decreased by approximately $100,000 this year due to the addition of three new apparatus, and the department came in at budget for overtime for the first time in years. During Q&A, a Council member asked about the cost of maintaining specialized teams (Swift Water, Hazmat) versus purchasing services on an as-needed basis. The Fire Chief explained that Asheville’s remote location prevents reliance on nearby cities for rapid response, though state and federal reimbursements help offset some costs. The Council member suggested the Finance and HR committees look into a formal cost-benefit analysis, and the Fire Chief agreed to present something to that committee. Additionally, a Council member inquired about the fire service contract with the Biltmore Estate, to which the Fire Chief stated the city receives approximately $206,000–$250,000 annually.
Communications & Public Engagement Director Dawa Hitch presented the department’s focus on community engagement, media relations, and internal communications, noting the department has seven FTE staff. Core services include managing the city website, social media, and public engagement tools like Open City Hall. The Director highlighted challenges such as community fatigue, as the department works to coordinate engagement efforts to avoid asking residents to attend multiple separate meetings for similar topics. The department is currently at capacity for streaming committee meetings, with one staff member handling graphic design, video production, and TV broadcasting. A request for additional resources was made last year but was not funded due to competing priorities. Goals for the department include implementing real-time streaming of all council committee meetings by the end of the year, providing interpretive services at citywide-sponsored community meetings, and developing a plan for childcare options. During Q&A, a Council member mentioned a community-led program called "Democracy is Boring" that offers civics workshops and suggested the city partner with them rather than creating a new city-run citizen academy. The Communications Director acknowledged the idea and expressed interest in collaborating.
Parks & Recreation Director Roderick presented the department’s $10 million budget and 94 employees, identifying it as the city’s largest department by headcount and budget, excluding Police, Fire, and Water. The department manages 73 facilities, including 5 community centers, 3 pools, and 54 parks. Salaries and benefits are the largest cost, while contractor services account for 73% of maintenance costs. The department is studying how to bring some contracted maintenance services in-house to save money. Challenges include maintaining existing infrastructure, funding equity-focused programs, and managing upcoming maintenance costs for new facilities like Rad Tip. The department received the most "yes" votes on bond measures and is committed to completing these projects on time and budget. During Q&A, a Council member asked why the city maintains the portion of PAC Square Park owned by Buncombe County. The Parks Director explained that the original partnership agreement dissolved, and while the county verbally agreed to help with maintenance, they have not provided funding in recent years. The Mayor noted that the city stepped in to maintain the park to avoid closing it off, acknowledging the complexity of cross-ownership agreements. Another Council member asked how much of the general fund is used to operate Riverside Cemetery. The Parks Director stated it is currently included in overall park operations and not broken out separately, but agreed to provide a breakdown to the Finance Committee. The Mayor also recalled a past effort to create an independent Parks & Rec authority with the county, which failed due to legislative issues, emphasizing the importance of funding Parks & Rec as a quality-of-life service.
Human Resources Interim HR Director Jamie Joyner presented the department’s budget, where salaries are 61%, benefits 26%, and operating costs 13%. The city is self-insured, allowing for control over plan design. Healthcare cost growth has been lower than national averages, attributed to the Employee Health Center and the "Asheville Project" (chronic disease management). The city recently conducted an RFP for Pharmacy Benefit Management (PBM) services, resulting in significant cost savings with minimal disruption to employees. The Employee Health Center costs approximately $800,000 annually but provides cost avoidance through reduced absenteeism, increased productivity, and lower claims. Challenges include retaining employees in a low-unemployment market, diversifying the workforce, and modernizing personnel records. Goals include rolling out a new performance management tool ("Employee Check-ins") citywide and increasing awareness of wellness programs. During Q&A, a Council member asked how the city controls healthcare costs. The HR Director cited the Employee Health Center, the Asheville Project, and the recent PBM RFP as key factors. The Council member praised the city’s healthcare practices as a model for other municipalities.
Planning & Urban Design The presentation for the Planning & Urban Design department was moved to the next public works session due to time constraints.
Follow-ups The Fire Chief agreed to present a cost-benefit analysis regarding specialized teams to the Finance and HR committees. The Parks Director agreed to provide a breakdown of general fund usage for Riverside Cemetery to the Finance Committee.
Meeting Video & Transcript