Skip to main content
  • 4 h 43 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: August 28, 2018

The City Council of Asheville held a regular meeting on August 28, 2018, addressing a wide range of municipal issues including public safety, transportation, zoning, and historic preservation. The session began with a proclamation designating September 2018 as Certified Community Wildlife Habitat Month and the adoption of the consent agenda, which included a $40 million bond for North Forks Dam spillway repairs. The council also reviewed a police use-of-force assessment, provided updates on the transit system, and held public hearings on several zoning and landmark designation requests.

Key Decisions and Votes The council adopted the consent agenda unanimously, with the exception of Item B (Franchise Agreement), which was continued to the Multimodal Commission for review. The council unanimously continued public hearings for the Brevard Road rezoning to September 11, 2018, and other items to October 9, 2018. The council unanimously adopted an ordinance designating the Princess Anne Hotel as a local historic landmark. Zoning map and future land use map amendments for parcels at 402 Hendersonville Road and 349 Reed Street were approved unanimously.

The council approved a conditional zoning request for 999 North Bear Creek Road as modified, with one "Nay" vote recorded. Conditions include providing a 10-foot wide easement for future sidewalk construction (approximately 280 feet) and contributing $18,484 to the city’s capital sidewalk fund prior to the certificate of occupancy. A conditional use permit for a 95-foot stealth monopole telecommunications tower at 1256 Hendersonville Road was approved with no "Nay" votes recorded, as it met the seven conditional use standards. A conditional zoning amendment for 430 McDowell Street was approved with one member voting opposed, allowing a medical office, small professional office, or one residential apartment unit and rezoning the parcel from "Traditional Neighborhood" to "Traditional Corridor." The council unanimously adopted proposed amendments to the towing ordinance (City Code Chapter 11, Section 18, and Appendix B). Finally, the council unanimously voted to enter a closed session regarding a potential lawsuit involving Hardee’s and John Robert West, and personnel matters. The council also made several board and commission appointments, all of which passed with no opposed votes recorded.

Discussion Highlights The council heard a presentation from 21st Century Policing Solutions regarding the assessment of an August 2017 use-of-force incident. Sean Smoot of 21st Century Policing Solutions stated, "We felt it was important to point up that they [APD] did in fact respond in a very timely manner... The investigation... was very thorough... We believe it was a comprehensive investigation." He added, "Clearly mistakes were made... But on the whole, this is a very good police department, one you should be proud of."

Staff provided an update on the transit system, highlighting fleet maintenance issues and staffing constraints. Ely Mathis, Transit Planning Manager, stated, "I firmly believe that this new management model is far superior to what we've had previously." Regarding service interruptions, he noted, "The primary factors causing those issues is the overall age of the fleet and the lack of pass bus purchases." Roderick Simmons, Director of Parks and Recreation, discussed capacity at Stevens Lee Recreation Center, stating, "It's a combination of both. The facilities are well used... But it's a combination of both. It just depends on the time of day." He clarified staffing limits by noting, "With only having two full-time staff at the facility and 25 kids per staff, it's kind of hard to increase those numbers without additional staff."

During the discussion on the 999 North Bear Creek Road sidewalk requirement, one council member stated, "I don't want to just start saying well you know every time there's not already a sidewalk there we're gonna waive it... I think it's a pretty dangerous road." Another council member emphasized, "My view is we need to require people to build the sidewalks when they do their own redevelopment rather than put that burden on the city." Regarding the 430 McDowell Street project, a council member expressed concern about the cost of a sidewalk on the steep embankment, stating, "If you were to build a sidewalk here... it might possibly be the most expensive sidewalk ever... my concern is that if we insist on a sidewalk that nobody will ever use this piece of property, and it will just sit there forever because nobody's going to spend $265,000 on a sidewalk." Another council member called for consistency, stating, "I'm perplexed... We just got to have some sort of uniform... if it doesn't cost a lot, we're going to require somebody to do it. If it would cost too much, we're not going to require somebody to do it. I just figure we need some sort of uniformity about these floating sidewalks that are out there."

Regarding the telecommunications tower at 1256 Hendersonville Road, a council member noted, "So my feeling is none of us actually like this project... I don't see a basis to disapprove it." The Mayor discussed the limits of local authority over towing, stating, "This is such an odd area because there's actually a North Carolina Supreme Court opinion on local government efforts to try to regulate towing practices... cities are limited... we've tried to craft this ordinance in such a way that we're pushing right up against the limits of what we can do to really more as a consumer protection measure."

Community Input Public comment was received on several agenda items. Regarding the 999 North Bear Creek Road project, the applicant argued that building a disconnected sidewalk was impractical and cost-prohibitive. Residents expressed mixed views; one called the requirement "asinine" given the lack of connectivity, while another requested that fee-in-lieu funds be specifically earmarked for this sidewalk. For the 1256 Hendersonville Road telecommunications tower, opponents raised concerns about inadequate notification, visual impact, and health risks. A public commenter criticized the photo simulations as misleading, and another objected to the applicant's objection to his testimony. An individual claimed expertise in railroad setbacks, arguing non-compliance with safety criteria. For the 430 McDowell Street zoning amendment, a public commenter supported sidewalk connectivity and bus shelters, noting high school students currently cross dangerously, and requested TDA funding for bus support. Another public commenter agreed on the need for a bus shelter and crosswalk due to high traffic.

During general public comment, a resident used a theatrical presentation to argue for transit funding. A representative from Just Economics reported 539.5 hours of missed service in July and urged enforcement of liquidated damages. A bus operator and union president expressed concern over fleet condition. A public commenter requested speed humps for Oakland Road, noting it is a dangerous route to AB Tech/Asheville High. A council member confirmed the road is scheduled for resurfacing in 2018 but noted no new sidewalks are included. A public commenter asked about the timeline for enforcement against groups operating at Haywood Road, highlighting the critical services provided. A council member stated no rezoning is pending but the 30-day notice of violation may be extended. A public commenter requested a proclamation for 12-year-old Derek Lee Jr. The Mayor agreed to draft the proclamation.

Follow-ups Staff agreed to return quarterly to report on bus breakdowns to verify confidence levels. The union is reviewing documents requested on August 2nd. The council agreed to wait for a revised proposal regarding Stevens Lee; staff will review current uses with the requester, potentially involving the Parks and Rec Advisory Board and the broader community in subsequent phases. The Transportation Department will add the Multimodal Commission to the review process for future franchise agreements. The Director of Historic Resources may apply for a grant next year to match additional funds for the African American Heritage Research Survey. Staff confirmed the fee-in-lieu rate of $66 per linear foot for the North Bear Creek Road project. The council will review methods to better notify residents of apartment complexes and potentially extend the notification period beyond 10 days. Staff confirmed that the 10-mile towing distance limit remains unchanged and that no licensing/training requirements were added due to a 2014 NC Supreme Court ruling limiting local authority. Staff confirmed the 2018 resurfacing schedule for Oakland Road. The Mayor will work with the family of Derek Lee Jr. to draft the memorial proclamation.

Impact These decisions impact residents through changes to local infrastructure, public safety, and land use. The adoption of the towing ordinance aims to address predatory towing practices and expand liability to property owners, serving as a consumer protection measure within the limits of state law. The approval of the telecommunications tower and various zoning amendments will alter the visual and functional landscape of specific neighborhoods, with the council noting that while they may not personally favor certain projects, they are legally bound to approve them if statutory standards are met. The historic landmark designation for the Princess Anne Hotel preserves a significant local structure. The ongoing discussions regarding the transit system highlight concerns over service reliability and fleet age, which directly affect daily commuting for residents. The sidewalk funding and construction requirements for new developments aim to balance developer burden with the need for safe pedestrian infrastructure, though debates continue over the cost and practicality of these requirements.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches