Skip to main content

City Council Meeting - January 23, 2018

January 23, 2018 at 11:00 AM

  • 2 h 15 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On January 23, 2018, the Asheville City Council held a regular meeting to address routine administrative matters, review several zoning and land use requests, and discuss transportation infrastructure projects. The agenda included public hearings on five distinct development proposals, a review of a significant grant for the River Arts District, and a discussion regarding the North Carolina Department of Transportation’s (NCDOT) plans for Merriman Avenue.

Key Decisions

The Council approved the consent agenda unanimously by voice vote. Regarding land use and zoning, the Council approved the conditional zoning request for the Ingalls Market expansion by voice vote, with one member voting "Nay" and the remainder voting "aye." The rezoning request for 655 Brevard Road, which allows for a dental practice and a single-family home, passed unanimously by voice vote. Similarly, the zoning map amendment for 9999 Deaver Street, changing the designation from Residential Multifamily Medium Density to Haywood Road Traditional, passed unanimously by voice vote. The Council also unanimously approved the conditional zoning request for the Elf Auto Center expansion.

For the proposed 112-room extended-stay hotel at 390 Airport Road, the Council voted 5-2 to approve the conditional zoning request. Two members voted "Nay," citing concerns regarding comprehensive plan compliance, mixed-use development, and employee living wages. In the River Arts District, the Council unanimously adopted a resolution to accept a $4.6 million grant from the Buncombe County Tourism Development Authority (BCTDA) and unanimously authorized the City Manager to execute a corresponding contract amendment with Beverly Grant Barnhill to complete deferred infrastructure improvements, including Lyman Street reconstruction, a protected bike lane, and sidewalks.

Discussion Highlights

Transportation Department Director Ken Putnam presented an update on the I-26 Connector project, noting that the hired consultant team is focusing on urban design, surplus property redevelopment, and aesthetic betterments. Putnam stated, "I would like to stand up here and tell you that we got money for all of them [aesthetic betterments], but chances are we won't, so you'll have to pick and choose on that."

A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the NCDOT Merriman Avenue project. Council members expressed disappointment that NCDOT developed a detailed plan for intersections at WT Weaver and Edgewood without input from city staff or alignment with city plans such as Complete Streets and the Comprehensive Plan. One Council Member stated, "I would ask that we ask city staff to work closely with DOT to get this project consistent with all those various plans to open the whole process back up to include more input from residents... I would ask that they just need to really go back and back up and change their policies and procedures around this and really express our disappointment." Another Council Member noted that there are 19 urban road projects in the city that should not begin without city staff and volunteer citizen leaders at the table, emphasizing the need to get the working relationship right starting with Merriman Avenue. No vote was taken on this item; the chair stated the discussion was for planning purposes only.

Community Input

During the public hearing for the Ingalls Market expansion, a public commenter from West Asheville expressed support for the increased walking space and access across the green space, noting its value to residents without cars. For the 655 Brevard Road rezoning, a public commenter raised safety concerns regarding heavy traffic, potholes, and a dangerous curve near Laurel Wood, and expressed worry that a nearby forested parcel zoned commercial could lower property values.

Regarding the 9999 Deaver Street rezoning, a public commenter expressed concern about parking, traffic, and access for the larger Beecham’s Curve project, noting that Deaver and Howard are narrow streets without sidewalks. An Urban Planner clarified that main access points are on Haywood Road and that discussions with the Transportation Department are ongoing regarding a potential exit on Deaver Street. For the Elf Auto Center, public commenters, including a Planning and Zoning Commission member and a resident/architect, urged approval, citing the site's underutilization and the proposal's superior buffers. A civil engineer explained technical constraints, including an 8-foot slope and storm drains, that necessitated the building's location and alley access for tow trucks.

In the general public comment period, a public commenter from West Asheville shared a personal story about hosting a friend for a short period in exchange for a small fee or work trade, expressing concern that this informal arrangement could be classified as an illegal short-term rental with a potential fine of $500 per night. The chair encouraged the commenter to contact city staff or visit the website for information on how the regulations work. Another public commenter, a former city employee, addressed the council regarding alleged unprofessional conduct by a supervisor and disproportionate overtime usage. The chair interrupted, stating, "Please direct your comments to us," and later said, "What message are you- Thank you. You can submit your comments to the clerk and she'll pass around if you wish."

Follow-ups

Ken Putnam stated he would have a conference call later in the week to get a better update on the design conversations between the I-26 consultant and NCDOT. Staff indicated that upon authorization, work on the added River Arts District infrastructure would begin relatively quickly to avoid repeated disruptions. The chair asked staff to draft a resolution to formally communicate the council’s disappointment with NCDOT’s process on Merriman Avenue and to request that NCDOT change its policies to include more citizen and city staff input; this resolution was set for the first meeting in February. Putnam also stated that the city would go to the Multimodal Transportation Commission the following day to share the NCDOT plan and gather input. Staff confirmed that the public comment deadline for the NCDOT Merriman Avenue project is January 29, 2018, and that NCDOT will accept a City Council resolution passed at a later date.

Impact

These decisions directly affect the physical development and infrastructure of Asheville. The approval of the Ingalls Market expansion and the hotel at 390 Airport Road adds new commercial and lodging capacity to the city, while the rezoning of 655 Brevard Road and 9999 Deaver Street modifies land use designations to allow for specific residential and mixed-use developments. The acceptance of the $4.6 million grant and contract amendment ensures the completion of long-deferred infrastructure improvements in the River Arts District, including a protected bike lane and sidewalks on Lyman Street. The discussion on Merriman Avenue highlights ongoing tensions between the city and NCDOT regarding community engagement and planning alignment, which may influence how future state transportation projects are handled in the city.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches