City Council Meeting - November 14, 2017
November 14, 2017 at 11:00 AM
- 3 h 16 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: November 14, 2017
The City Council of Asheville convened on November 14, 2017, to address a range of community issues, including homelessness, housing development, and urban planning. The meeting opened with a proclamation for National Hunger and Homelessness Awareness Week, during which the Mayor highlighted that the Asheville metro area is ranked the ninth hungriest city in the nation and that 500 to 600 individuals experience homelessness at any given time. Representatives from the Beloved Asheville Homeless Voice group accepted the proclamation, emphasizing their efforts to create solutions such as community gardens and a "Streetmatic" team to prevent deaths from exposure.
The Council reviewed and passed the Consent Agenda, which included an update on the firefighter retirement plan. Staff explained that shifting from a 401(a) to a 457(b) plan allows for more flexible contributions of 2–4%, moving away from an "all-or-nothing" approach to better balance retirement benefits for firefighters who are not covered by Social Security. Additionally, the Council approved a revised timeline for the Blue Ribbon Committee on the Human Relations Commission, extending their deadline to January 31, 2017, to finalize a draft mission and vision statement focused on racial equity, diversity, and inclusion.
Significant time was devoted to public hearings on three zoning items. The Council voted to approve the conditional zoning for a Pizza Hut at 12 Miami Circle, allowing a drive-thru window for online and phone orders only, with one recorded "Nay." For 175 Lyman Street, the Council approved the conditional zoning for the Stone Yard Apartments, a 133-unit residential development featuring a parking structure and artist studios in a historic building, also with one recorded "Nay." The most contentious item was the River Arts District (RAD) Form-Based Code. A motion to approve the code as originally presented on July 25, 2017, failed for lack of a second. However, a subsequent motion to approve the code including a restriction on whole-house short-term rentals—removing lodging as a use by right—passed, with one council member voting against it on the grounds that such restrictions should be handled city-wide. The Council also passed the map amendment to rezone specific properties in the RAD. A separate motion to remove the RAD parking reduction area from the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) failed, meaning the existing parking reduction area remains in place alongside the new code.
Public comment on the Stone Yard Apartments project focused heavily on the $50,000 contribution to the affordable housing fund, with several residents describing the amount as "minuscule" or "paltry" given the lack of affordable units in the development. In response, one council member proposed increasing the contribution to $175,000 based on the density bonus, while another expressed support based on the project’s public parking benefit, valued at approximately $1.5 million, and the adaptive reuse of the historic building. Regarding the River Arts District Form-Based Code, public commenters raised concerns that applying the code to the Ralph Street area would accelerate gentrification and displace long-term residents, citing historical redlining and a lack of community engagement. Council members responded by noting that increased density tends to lead to more affordability and clarifying that the code is about design and form, not necessarily driving gentrification. Staff also clarified that the code overlay does not affect the land trust status of city-owned land.
On the issue of Short-Term Rentals (STRs), several business owners and residents expressed frustration that the Council was introducing new restrictions at a late stage, arguing it violated the two-year community input process. One council member apologized for stepping out of the usual process but argued that the city must address the housing crisis, clarifying that the proposal is not a ban but a removal of lodging as a "use by right," which would require a conditional use permit. Another member supported this action, stating that the urgency of the housing crisis necessitates it. During general public comment, a resident from Chesa Hills urged the Council to continue analyzing the impact of STRs on housing availability, and a representative from Renew AVL spoke about the need for a policy for 100% renewable energy production. One council member responded to the renewable energy comment by stating that the Sustainability Advisory Committee is committed to looking at the city’s existing carbon goals.
The Council also addressed appointments to Boards and Commissions. John Menkes was unanimously reappointed to the ABC Board, and Raymond Tweed was unanimously appointed to the Fireman’s Relief Fund. The Council delayed a decision on appointments to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee to allow the committee time to review applications and make recommendations. Staff agreed to meet with the Blue Ribbon Committee, the City Manager, and the Equity Manager to discuss the mechanics of the Human Relations Commission’s work. Additionally, the Planning Director stated that once the Comprehensive Plan is adopted, expected early next year, the "Plan on a Page" documents will be used as a tool for development review. A developer for the Stone Yard project agreed to add a condition prohibiting short-term rentals to the project. Staff also agreed to send over guidance regarding parking models, and the Council noted that if problems arise with the current parking configuration, they can update the Council. One council member stated that the incoming council will need to come up with more rational rules for STRs, as the current approach is piecemeal.
Meeting Video & Transcript