City Council Meeting - September 12, 2017
September 12, 2017 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 42 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: September 12, 2017
The Asheville City Council convened on September 12, 2017, to address a wide-ranging agenda that included storm recovery efforts, zoning changes, bond financing, and board appointments. The meeting opened with the Mayor acknowledging the absence of Council member Julie Mayfield due to a family emergency and thanking staff and residents for their work in clearing debris and restoring power following a recent storm. The Council also read a proclamation designating September 15 through October 15, 2017, as Hispanic Heritage Month in Asheville.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council took several actions during the meeting. A motion was made to approve the consent agenda, excluding Item F (Urban Design RFQ), and it was seconded; however, no vote is recorded in the transcript summary for this specific motion. Separately, a motion was made to approve Item F, the Request for Qualifications for urban design services, and it was seconded; again, no vote is recorded for this item in the provided summary. In contrast, the Council did record unanimous votes for several other items. The Council unanimously voted to recommend approval of the conditional zoning request for Mountain Housing Opportunities, Inc. on Triad Street. The Council also unanimously approved an ordinance amendment allowing temporary gravel parking lots in the Central Business District (CBD) and unanimously approved the assignment of Highway Business zoning to a 1.26-acre property at 421 Airport Road. Regarding board appointments, the Council unanimously confirmed six candidates for interviews for the Planning and Zoning Commission and unanimously appointed Jeff Luttrell to the Recreation Board. For the Tourism Development Authority, the Council voted among three candidates, with Andrew Selwyn receiving the most votes and being appointed. The Council also reappointed Randall Barnett and appointed Leslie Hennessy to the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee. Finally, the Council unanimously voted to proceed with the bond financing process, though final approval is scheduled for a future meeting.
Discussion Highlights A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to a public hearing on proposed limited obligation bonds (LOBs) and special obligation bonds (SOBs). Chief Financial Officer Barbara Whitehorn presented a plan to issue an estimated $45 million in bonds ($26.8M LOBs and $18.2M SOBs) to refinance $33 million in short-term debt issued in 2016 and $12 million in 2012 LOBs into long-term debt to save on interest. This issuance is separate from the 2016 General Obligation bond referendum. The Council voted to proceed with the process, with a final approval vote scheduled for October 3, 2017. During the discussion on the consent agenda, City Traffic Engineer Jeff Moore explained that changing speed limits to 25 mph on residential streets requires an engineering study for each individual road under North Carolina state statute, making a citywide default change legally difficult without legislative changes. Additionally, Urban Design Director Tyler Kuczynski clarified that the urban design RFQ seeks qualifications only, not design proposals, to ensure the process is clear.
Community Input Public comment was received on several items. Regarding the temporary gravel lots in the CBD, multiple business owners and residents spoke in strong support, citing a severe parking crisis that affects customers and employees. One public commenter from Public Interest Projects presented data comparing Asheville’s parking spaces to other cities, arguing that the city has a "parking crisis" rather than a problem, and criticized the City for using taxpayer-provided parking for its own staff. Another public commenter supported the gravel lots as a short-term measure but urged the Council to look at using all city properties for parking. In response, the Mayor stated, "I don't sense that it's terribly controversial."
On the bond financing, public commenters expressed concern. One commenter accused the Council and City Manager of "bankrupting" the city and criticized spending on the river flood project. Another expressed concern about the total debt load and the sustainability of General Obligation bonds backed by property taxes during a boom era. A third commenter expressed confusion about a $6 million line item for a radio infrastructure project near White Fawn Park. In response, the Mayor clarified that the $6 million item was part of the 911 infrastructure project and offered to provide information to the commenter. A Council member defended the debt, stating that past councils were unwilling to take on debt to fix streets, leaving the city on a 70-year repaving cycle versus the standard 30-year cycle.
During general public comment, a resident spoke about HB 142, a state law acting as a moratorium on local non-discrimination ordinances, and asked the City to condemn the law. Another resident supported this, urging the Council to pass a local non-discrimination ordinance. A third resident raised concerns about the City’s ADA Title II policy and compliance data, asking the Mayor to suspend the committee process to discuss a resolution regarding ADA data transparency. The Mayor stated, "If you've got any written comments that you weren't able to finish, you can pass them to Sarah."
Follow-ups Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Jeff Moore, City Traffic Engineer, agreed to provide an answer regarding how many miles of streets currently have a 25 mph or lower speed limit. Staff, including Tyler Kuczynski, agreed to review the wording of the urban design RFQ to ensure it is clear that design options are not required in the initial qualification submittal. The Mayor asked staff to follow up with the County to determine if spaces in the new Cox Avenue parking deck will be available to the public on nights and weekends. The Mayor also offered to provide information to a public commenter regarding the $6 million 911 infrastructure project. Additionally, a Council member asked the City Manager’s office to follow up on the status of Spanish language translation and multicultural communication plans, and staff agreed to provide additional information or pursue specific strategies.
Impact These decisions and discussions have direct implications for residents. The approval of temporary gravel lots in the CBD aims to alleviate parking shortages in the downtown area, a significant concern for local businesses and residents. The zoning change for 421 Airport Road facilitates the development of a high-turnover restaurant, potentially adding to the local dining options. The conditional zoning for the Triad Street project allows for the construction of 20 single-family homes with a dedicated open space lot, which the applicant stated will reduce average lot costs by 20% and increase affordable homeownership opportunities. The bond financing process, if approved in October, will refinance existing short-term debt into long-term debt, which the City argues will save on interest costs and support the capital improvement program. The discussions on speed limits and ADA compliance highlight ongoing efforts to balance traffic safety and accessibility, while the board appointments ensure continued representation on key advisory bodies.
Meeting Video & Transcript