City Council Meeting - April 12, 2016
April 12, 2016 at 11:00 AM
- 4 hlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: April 12, 2016
The Asheville City Council convened on April 12, 2016, to address a range of administrative, legislative, and infrastructure matters. The agenda included employee recognitions, a resolution regarding North Carolina House Bill 2 (HB2), technical amendments to the subdivision code, and a detailed review of the Bowcatcher Greenway project. The meeting also covered the city’s legislative agenda for the upcoming state session and various board appointments.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council adopted the consent agenda, which included a resolution affirming the dignity of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people and calling for the repeal of HB2. The vote was recorded with ayes and no nays or abstentions. The Council also approved revised wording amendments to Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Sections 725, 758, and 715.1, which reorganize subdivision standards and add a requirement for developers to hold a neighborhood meeting prior to submittal; this motion also passed with ayes and no recorded nays or abstentions. Additionally, the Council approved the city’s legislative agenda for the state session, including an amendment to focus on coal ash cleanup. The Mayor was recused from the discussion of the Bowcatcher Greenway project. Regarding the Bowcatcher Greenway, the Council indicated approval through a show of hands, authorizing staff to issue a Request for Proposals (RFP) for construction. The Council also decided to re-advertise the position for three at-large members of the Haywood Street Advisory Team due to a lack of diversity in the current applicant pool. Appointments were made for the Public Art and Cultural Commission and the Recreation Board, though formal vote tallies were not recorded.
Discussion Highlights Staff and consultants from Stuart Engineering presented the history, design, and costs of the Bowcatcher Greenway, a 1.2-mile trail project. Staff noted that current greenway costs are approximately $2.3 million per mile due to contracted design and construction, compared to earlier in-house projects. The total estimate for the Bowcatcher Greenway is approximately $3.2 million, with $310,000 already spent on design. Design modifications, such as making a section of Beaumont Street one-way and using stairs to preserve a red oak, resulted in approximately $500,000 in savings. A consultant stated, "The changes that are presented to you tonight do reflect about a half a million dollars in savings to the project." Staff explained that the project will be bid as a single package but will include "alternates" for specific design choices to allow the Council to compare costs. One Council Member emphasized the need for momentum, stating, "It is time that we came together To get this thing done... once that momentum is created we gotta go we got to do it we got to get it done and now's the time."
Community Input Public comment was held on the HB2 resolution, Subdivision Code amendments, and the Bowcatcher Greenway. Regarding HB2, numerous commenters supported the repeal, citing personal safety, religious duty, and equality, while one resident opposed it, stating, "Sodomy is still sin." Council Member Keith Stone expressed personal conviction against the legislation, and Vice Mayor Gwen Whistler urged voters to make their voices heard at the ballot box. On the Subdivision Code, a public commenter suggested modifying notice language to include residents rather than just property owners; staff explained that state law requires notice to property owners via tax records. Council Member Julie Mayfield suggested a one-year review of the new meeting requirement. For the Bowcatcher Greenway, residents of the Sky Club expressed concerns regarding safety, visual impact, and geological instability, while representatives from transportation and greenway advocacy groups supported the project, citing health benefits and equity. Staff clarified that trail grades match existing roadways and confirmed that bid documents will include alternates.
Follow-ups Council Member Cecil Bothwell requested a process to follow up on suggestions from public commenters regarding additional legal actions related to HB2; staff indicated they were checking for existing memos on the topic. Staff agreed to issue the RFP for the Bowcatcher Greenway construction, including design alternates, and will bring the resulting bids and a potential budget amendment to the Council for final approval and contract authorization. Staff also agreed to re-advertise the Haywood Street Advisory Team positions to secure a more diverse pool of applicants.
Impact These decisions advance the city’s infrastructure and legislative priorities. The approval of the Bowcatcher Greenway RFP moves the project toward construction, with the inclusion of design alternates allowing the Council to evaluate cost-effective options for the final contract. The subdivision code amendments streamline the review process by returning final review of major subdivisions to the Technical Review Committee and ensuring community engagement through required neighborhood meetings. The resolution on HB2 and the legislative agenda reflect the Council’s stance on state-level policies affecting local residents and environmental cleanup.
Meeting Video & Transcript