City Council Meeting - January 12, 2016
January 12, 2016 at 11:00 AM
- 4 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On January 12, 2016, the Asheville City Council held a regular meeting to address financial reports, housing initiatives, and a major downtown redevelopment proposal. The agenda included the approval of a consent agenda, the review of the city’s 2015 annual audit, and a public hearing regarding the redevelopment of the BB&T Tower at One West Pack Square.
Key Decisions
The Council approved the consent agenda, with two items considered separately. The Council voted unanimously to approve a resolution waiving 50% of Transportation Access Program (TAP) fees for the Asheville Housing Authority’s redevelopment of the Lee Walker Heights public housing project. This waiver serves as a precursor to a state tax credit application. Additionally, the Council unanimously passed a resolution establishing the second Monday in October as Indigenous Peoples’ Day.
The Council also voted unanimously to recommend approval of a conditional use permit for the Givens Estate, which involves the demolition of three existing multi-family buildings and the construction of two new 24-unit buildings. The written decision for this item is scheduled for final approval at the next council meeting.
The most significant vote of the evening concerned the Level 3 Conditional Zoning request for the One West Pack Square redevelopment (BB&T Tower). The project includes a 140-room hotel, 39 condominiums, commercial space, and a parking structure. The motion to approve the zoning request passed with a 5-2 vote.
The Council also voted to approve various appointments and interviews for city boards and commissions, including the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, Board of Adjustment, Downtown Commission, and Tree Commission. All appointments passed with no recorded opposition. Finally, the Council voted to enter a closed session to consult with the city attorney regarding privileged and confidential matters.
Discussion Highlights
Staff provided a high-level update on the city’s strategic operating plan, noting progress in economic growth, community planning, and affordability. Finance staff reported that the external auditor issued a "clean" (unmodified) opinion on the city’s 2015 financial statements. The Mayor stated, "In no uncertain terms, this is a clean audit... It is notable that this is a clean audit, and accommodations do go out to all of our program and department managers who follow the checks and balances." Staff noted that the city’s fund balance is at 17.6%, which is above the 15% policy minimum and supports the city’s AAA credit rating.
Regarding the One West Pack Square redevelopment, presenters detailed plans that include $750,000 in private investment for public realm improvements and a commitment to pay a living wage to full-time employees. John McKibben, a developer representative, stated, "I want you to know that we will pay the living wage for our full-time employees at this project... I’m committing $250,000 to the Asheville Affordable Housing Trust... We are not going to have any national chains in this building."
During the debate, one Council Member voting in favor remarked, "I think this is an opportunity to set a new bar... I think that’s the message that we have the opportunity to send tonight to other hotel owners who are going to come before us is, you know, we have a new base that we expect you to meet if you are going to do business in this town." Another Council Member voting against the project stated, "The majority opinion I have received from my constituents on the issue urges me to vote against it on the grounds of its contribution to the unnecessary growth of the hotel industry at a time when downtown already seems overrun. I promised my constituents that I would listen to them, and on this issue I want to honor that promise by voting no." John Cook, representing the applicant, responded by highlighting the rarity of a private-sector redevelopment of a landmark building with no public funds involved, stating, "What you have before you tonight is a rare opportunity... There's no plausible reason to deny this project and to deny the citizens the opportunity to have a different looking BB&T building that is going to be a mixed-use development that is a 21st century activity center."
Community Input
During the public comment period for the Lee Walker Heights redevelopment, residents spoke in support of the project, citing improved safety, better emergency vehicle access, and the right to return to the property after redevelopment. A Council Member responded by stating they were inclined to move forward with the fee waiver to allow the Housing Authority to complete its application, noting that concerns about resident inclusion would need greater clarity when the Housing Authority returns to Council for substantive financial commitments.
For the One West Pack Square project, public comment was divided. Supporters, including a community planner, a downtown business owner, and a Downtown Commission member, praised the project’s commitment to the public realm, living wages, and the renovation of the building’s single-pane glass. One musician and one resident expressed support but requested that part-time workers also receive a living wage. Opponents, including two residents, argued that the city is growing its tourist industry too fast, that hotels drive up rents, and that the November election results indicated a lack of desire for more hotels. One opponent requested a moratorium on new hotels and an audit of the hotel tax.
Regarding the Collier Avenue Wood Preservation, a representative of the Ravenscroft Reserve Initiative presented a proposal to preserve the urban forest at 11 Collier Avenue via a land swap with the City. A resident supported the proposal, emphasizing the ecological significance of the trees. The Mayor stated, "I don’t want to allocate time to it unless we see something a little more clear... I’m not a hundred percent convinced that there’s a path to go forward... I’m uncomfortable with agreeing to be the first one in... giving up swapping property before I actually see the fundraising." The Chair concluded that the Council had "no direction to staff to continue working on it" and that no vote was taken on the preservation proposal.
Follow-ups
Staff from the Housing Authority agreed to share the letter sent to residents detailing relocation requirements and the right to return with the Council. Staff will proceed with the approved zoning for the One West Pack Square project. Staff will conduct interviews for the Affordable Housing Advisory Committee, Downtown Commission, and Hub Community Economic Development Alliance, and will advertise for Multimodal Transportation Commission openings. Additionally, the Finance Director and the City Manager stated they would meet with the Council between now and the Council Retreat to discuss the five-year forecast and capital projects in greater detail.
Impact
The approval of the One West Pack Square redevelopment marks a significant change to the downtown landscape, introducing a mixed-use building that includes a hotel and condominiums. The Council noted that the developer’s commitments to living wages, local hiring, and affordable housing contributions may set a "McKibben standard" for future hotel applications. The unanimous approval of the Lee Walker Heights fee waiver allows the Housing Authority to move forward with its state tax credit application for the public housing redevelopment. The "clean" audit and strong fund balance reported by staff indicate that the city’s financial health remains stable, supporting its credit rating.
Meeting Video & Transcript