City Council Meeting - August 25, 2015
August 25, 2015 at 11:00 AM
- 4 h 23 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: August 25, 2015
The Asheville City Council convened on August 25, 2015, to address routine business, zoning changes, and significant regulatory updates regarding short-term lodging. The meeting began with the unanimous approval of the consent agenda, which included a grant for the Asheville Area Arts Council and a contract for downtown cleaning. The council also recognized the 75th Anniversary of the Asheville Housing Authority and the 2015 Asheville-Buncombe Time Capsule Day. In a gesture of respect, the council unanimously voted to name the U.S. Cellular Center lobby the "Jan Davis Lobby," with Council Member Jan Davis recusing himself from the vote.
A major portion of the meeting was dedicated to the proposed Homestay Ordinance, which seeks to define and regulate short-term lodging in residential homes. The council held public hearings on amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO), focusing on contentious issues such as the definition of a "full-time resident," host presence requirements, off-street parking, and separation distances. Despite extensive discussion, the council unanimously voted to defer consideration of the Homestay Ordinance. Staff noted that substantial amendments to the current draft would require a new public hearing before the Planning and Zoning Commission.
In contrast to the deferral of the broader homestay regulations, the council voted 5-2 to approve a specific amendment to UDO Section 7-18-2B. This amendment increases the daily civil penalty for illegal short-term rental violations from $100 to $500. One member dissented, citing the need to see how this fits with broader accessory dwelling unit discussions, while another supported the increase only if the 30-day cure period was strictly enforced. The council also approved a resolution opposing the state’s proposed sales tax redistribution legislation, which was sent to the state legislature.
Regarding land use, the council unanimously approved conditional zoning for properties at 960 and 966 Tunnel Road, changing their designation from RM6/Office CZ to Community Business 1 CZ. The approval limits uses to offices, instructional services, health/fitness, single-family/duplex residences, and low-impact artist studios. A separate zoning item was continued to November 10. Additionally, the council approved essay questions for Planning and Zoning Commission applicants and extended the application deadline by one month to allow for a more diverse pool of candidates.
Public comment on the Homestay Ordinance revealed deep divisions regarding the impact of short-term rentals on the local housing market. Residents opposed allowing non-owner operators, arguing it leads to neglect, while the Mayor clarified that a North Carolina Supreme Court opinion prohibits restricting homestays to owners only. Representatives from the Coalition of Asheville Neighborhoods and Five Points residents opposed the removal of off-street parking and spacing requirements, citing safety risks. Conversely, supporters, including a B&B owner and a filmmaker, argued that regulated homestays provide vital income and support local workers. On the fine increase, commenters were divided; some argued the current $100 fine is insufficient for deterrence, while others, including a resident who cited a local cleaner’s income, argued that aggressive enforcement of existing laws is the primary issue rather than higher fines.
Council members offered notable perspectives on the scale of the issue. Council Member Robin stated that Asheville has more short-term rentals than any other city in North Carolina, emphasizing that getting the regulation wrong could turn the city into a resort community rather than a living one. Council Member Chan expressed concern about predatory investors and multi-billion dollar corporations like Airbnb and VRBO gobbled up neighborhoods, pricing out residents. Mayor Esther Manheimer clarified that the city does not receive room tax revenue, which is a legislated item, and distinguished between illegal standalone short-term rentals and legal homestays.
Several follow-up actions were identified during the meeting. Council Member Mark directed staff to conduct further research to ensure the homestay ordinance meets the "casual and incidental" use test, including revisiting bedroom limits, nights per year, and host definitions. Council Member Chan stated they would investigate room tax revenue from Airbnb at the Tourism Development Authority. Staff confirmed they are recruiting for an authorized enforcement position and have tracked 28 cases in the last 6–9 months. The council also voted unanimously to enter a closed session to consult with the City Attorney.
Meeting Video & Transcript