City Council Meeting, January 13, 2015
January 13, 2015 at 11:00 AM
- 2 h 3 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on January 13, 2015, addressing a range of administrative, development, and public safety issues. The agenda included the adoption of routine consent items, discussions on economic development incentives, zoning amendments, and appointments to various city boards and commissions. The council also held public hearings on specific development requests and received community input on local infrastructure and policy concerns.
Key Decisions
The council adopted the consent agenda, which included routine administrative items, though the resolution opposing hydraulic fracturing was pulled for separate public comment. The council continued the item regarding an agricultural lease for 11 acres of city-owned land at Azalea Park until the next meeting on January 27, 2015, to allow staff and the prospective tenant, Balsam Gardens, to negotiate terms.
In its public hearings, the council passed a resolution to permanently close an unopened alley off Broad Street. The council also approved a performance-based incentive grant for Linnemar Corporation’s $190 million expansion, with the grant amount not to exceed $3.5 million. Additionally, the council passed an amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (Section 778C3-3) clarifying that conditional zoning conditions may be more or less restrictive than general use standards. The council denied a request to rezone a residential property at 10 Madison Avenue and 202 East Chestnut Street for office use by the Siemens Law Offices.
Regarding board and commission appointments, the council appointed Philip Harden and Richard Ford as regular members and Pratik Bhatta and Christine Longoria as alternates to the Board of Adjustment, while reappointing Daniel Sumlin and Nelda Holder. Rachel Tankley Russell and Mike Hahn were reappointed to the Community Relations Council. Byron Griner, Michael McDonough, Jimmy Rentz, and Lael Gray were reappointed to the Downtown Commission. Barbara Whitehorn was appointed to the Fireman’s Relief Fund, Gwen Whistler to the Metropolitan Sewerage District Board, and Victor Farr to the Noise Ordinance Appeals Board. Five individuals—Leslie Ryder, Justin Price, Mark Williams, Carl Nyberg, and Stephen Hendricks—were appointed to the Tree Commission. The appointment of the Chair to the Civil Service Board was delayed for one month to allow for further processing and candidate interviews. The council moved to enter closed session to discuss privileged information, specific lawsuits, and real property acquisitions, though the final vote tally was not recorded in the transcript.
Discussion Highlights
New Director of General Services James Ayers presented on the recent water line break at City Hall, detailing recovery efforts and prevention measures. Ayers stated, "I am honored to be part of a team that both worked around the clock to get the city hall back into an occupiable state... I personally saw many wonderful examples of outstanding teamwork and something I like to call 'Asheville ingenuity.'"
Regarding the Linnemar Corporation grant, the Vice Mayor noted, "These incentives are sometimes controversial... I wish it weren't. I wish it were a level playing field in a different way where incentives weren't a big part of it. That is the way the game is played... At the end of the day it's a net win."
During the discussion on graffiti and murals, a council member explained that the city has struck deals with one or two artists to paint murals on city property, with the city purchasing the paint. The member emphasized, "we just don't want to be held liable for something like this that we can't, you know, we fix it, they come right back the next day or two and hit it again."
Community Input
Residents provided public comment on several topics. Regarding the fracking resolution, commenters thanked the city for opposing the practice, with one resident from Pennsylvania citing health impacts in his home state. On the Azalea Park lease, a 45-year organic gardener argued that a one-year lease is unfair to growers due to the significant investment required in land and labor.
Concerns were raised regarding the 10 Madison Avenue rezoning request. One commenter supported the project as adaptive reuse, while another argued the property is the "beginning of a residential neighborhood" and presented a petition to keep the street residential. Another commenter expressed concern about the "erosion" of the neighborhood due to commercial encroachment, and a fourth raised concerns about increased traffic speed and danger to children and pets. In response, the applicant stated the property is surrounded by office uses and parking lots, distinguishing it from adjacent residential properties, and emphasized his investment in exterior improvements.
On graffiti enforcement, a West Asheville business owner challenged the city’s ordinance, arguing the city penalizes victims of vandalism while failing to provide adequate police presence. Another commenter expressed concern about the city bearing the total cost of public art. A council member responded by acknowledging the difficulty of the issue and noting that timely removal is effective, highlighting efforts in the River Arts District to use murals and grants to deter tagging.
Other public comments included a request to increase awareness and development of solar and wind power, and a suggestion that the Civil Service Board be composed entirely of public-appointed members to avoid conflicts of interest. A senior resident argued that the city prioritizes cars over pedestrians and elders, citing a lack of safe infrastructure, benches, and green space.
Follow-ups
Staff agreed to work with the applicant, Balsam Gardens, over the next two weeks to sort out lease options and decision-making processes for the Azalea Park agricultural lease, which will return to the agenda on January 27, 2015. The Mayor stated she is meeting with the Firefighters Association president and is open to meeting with police stakeholders to find a "middle ground" or compromise regarding the Civil Service Board. The chair invited attendees to continue the conversation after the meeting regarding the graffiti and mural issue.
Impact
These decisions impact residents through changes in local land use, economic development, and public safety infrastructure. The approval of the Linnemar grant supports a major corporate expansion, while the denial of the 10 Madison Avenue rezoning preserves the residential character of that specific street. The amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance provides clearer guidelines for conditional zoning, which affects how future development projects are evaluated. The appointments to various boards ensure continuity in city oversight for issues ranging from noise and trees to civil service and sewerage. The delay in the Civil Service Board chair appointment allows for further review of candidates, and the continued negotiation on the Azalea Park lease aims to balance agricultural interests with city land management.
Meeting Video & Transcript