City Council Meeting, June 10, 2014
June 10, 2014 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 49 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: June 10, 2014
The City Council of Asheville held its regular meeting on June 10, 2014, focusing primarily on the official public hearing for the Fiscal Year 2015 budget, legislative updates from the North Carolina General Assembly, and various board and commission appointments. The session began with proclamations recognizing local achievements, including the “Run for the Wall” motorcyclists, graduates of the City of Asheville Youth Leadership Academy, and a Presidential Scholar, as well as declaring June 13–21 as Pollination Celebration Week.
Key Decisions and Votes The Council took action on several personnel appointments and procedural items. Motions to continue Public Hearing Item A to July 22 and Public Hearing Item C (a Unified Development Ordinance amendment) were made and seconded, but no vote is recorded in the summary. Similarly, a motion was made and seconded to approve the consent agenda, but no vote is recorded. The Council did vote on specific board appointments, all of which passed with all members in favor and none opposed. These included appointing Marv Rosen as Chairman of the Civil Service Board, reappointing Dean Call to the WNC Regional Air Quality Agency, reappointing Anthony Mitchell and Carl Catterjohn to Crime Stoppers, reappointing Brendan Ross and Richard Fast to the Historic Resources Commission, reappointing Bob Ropenack, Barbara Melton, and Elaine Poovey to the Neighborhood Advisory Committee, reappointing Victor Palomino, Gene Ferry, Gwen Ruckenbrod, and Guillermo Rodriguez to the Public Art and Cultural Commission, and reappointing Todd Dunnock and Josh O’Connor while appointing Kimberly Reid and Patrick Dennehy to the Recreation Board. The Council also voted to appoint Council Member Jan Davis as the representative to the Asheville Riverfront Redevelopment Commission, with Gwen Whistler as substitute. No action was taken on the Airport Authority, Citizens Police Advisory Committee, Civic Center Commission, Community Relations Council, or Multimodal Transportation Commission, with several of these items deferred or having application periods extended.
Legislative and Budget Discussions Staff provided an update on the state legislature, highlighting the repeal of the Privileged License Tax (PLT) effective July 1, 2015. Assistant City Manager Paul Featherston stated that the city estimates the actual loss at about $1.4 million, which would require a 1.85% property tax increase to replace. He noted this loss equates to the cost of 20 police officers, 26 firefighters, or 3 miles of street paving. Mayor Esther Manheimer discussed the recent victory in the water lawsuit, stating that the judge’s decision found the legislation unconstitutional and that the taking of the water system was for an improper purpose, emphasizing that the city must be compensated. Council Member Jan Davis praised Barry Summers for his role in keeping citizens informed about legislative developments.
During the budget hearing, staff presented the FY 2015 budget, which includes a new Neighborhood Sidewalk Program and a proposed 8% increase in stormwater utility fees. Council Member Mark Hunt expressed pride in the $132 million capital improvements budget but stated that the current allocation is inadequate for sidewalk needs. Council Member Gwen Whistler described the current process as the most thorough engagement the Council has had with an annual budget cycle in her experience.
Community Input Public commenters raised several concerns regarding the budget. One commenter expressed concern about the 8% stormwater fee increase, arguing it impacts low-income and elderly residents. Council Member Jan Davis responded by noting that the increase does not affect homes under 2,000 square feet and that for a 5,000 square foot home, the increase is approximately $5.50 per month, which he argued is reasonable for flood prevention. Mayor Esther Manheimer added that the city’s rates remain lower than most other cities in the state.
Regarding the Neighborhood Sidewalk Program, a public commenter argued that the $550,000 allocated over five years is insufficient compared to the $3.6 million allocated for Charlotte Street improvements. Another commenter cited recent accidents on Merriman Avenue and argued that local contractors could build sidewalks without lengthy consulting processes. Council Member Mark Hunt agreed that the $550,000 is a start but inadequate for a city with 80–90 miles of needed linkages, quoting Joe Biden to urge the council to better reflect community needs in the budget.
Other public comments included requests for clear allocation of bicycle infrastructure funds, questions about the accounting for the $2 million Pack Place maintenance budget, and a request to prioritize Phase 2 of the Wesley Grant Center with a gymnasium. No members responded directly to these specific comments. A public commenter representing a bus rider thanked the council for adding Sunday service, and another commenter highlighted its importance for low-income residents; the Mayor later acknowledged the helpful input. A public commenter representing his son asked for clarification on legal liens in West Asheville, to which a staff member responded that they had tried to resolve the situation, a statement the commenter disputed. Finally, a public commenter requested a Freedom of Information Act release of employee hours spent on the water lawsuit; no member responded directly.
Follow-ups Council Member Mark Hunt asked the city to explore options for reducing the cost of tax collection services, noting the budget increase from $720,000 to $820,000. Finance Director Barbara Whitehorn agreed to conduct an analysis of what different cities and counties do, as well as internal options, and stated that staff would work with the finance committee to include this in the work plan for the rest of the calendar year. Additionally, staff agreed to make arrangements for interviews for the remaining Neighborhood Advisory Committee seat on June 24. Staff also noted that the implementation of the residential stormwater fee increase will be delayed for 60 days to allow time to amend the stormwater ordinance.
Impact on Residents The decisions and discussions at this meeting have direct implications for residents’ finances and local infrastructure. The proposed 8% increase in stormwater utility fees and the potential 1.85% property tax increase to offset the loss of the Privileged License Tax will affect household budgets. The allocation of funds for the Neighborhood Sidewalk Program and the $132 million capital improvements budget will determine the pace of infrastructure upgrades, including sidewalks and street paving. The appointment of new board and commission members will influence future policy decisions on air quality, public art, recreation, and transportation. The delay in implementing the stormwater fee increase provides a 60-day window for ordinance amendments, which may affect the timing of fee changes for residents.
Meeting Video & Transcript