Board of Education Interviews – March 26, 2019
March 26, 2019 at 11:00 AM
- 1 h 53 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
No votes were taken during the interview session itself. The Chair stated that the City Council would vote on the appointments that evening, on March 26, 2019. The Chair explained that the voting process would involve two separate votes: one to fill two four-year terms and a second to fill the remaining two-year term associated with Dr. James Lee’s term. The transcript ends with the adjournment of the interview session, so the final vote outcomes and specific appointments are not recorded in this summary.
Discussion Highlights
The meeting consisted of interviews with five candidates for the Asheville City School Board of Education. Council members focused their questions on community engagement, transparency, and the board’s role in governance. A recurring concern was that major district decisions, such as the elimination of Math 1 for 7th graders, the "fence advance" at Vance Elementary, and changes at Hall Fletcher, were being made without sufficient front-end engagement with affected communities.
Candidate Shonda Stanford acknowledged that if parents are reporting they are not receiving enough information, it is the board's responsibility to improve communication. Candidate Scott Powell noted that asking parents to attend work sessions after items are already being discussed is difficult and that engaging them earlier would have prevented some of the current issues. Another candidate emphasized that the board’s role is to act as a check and balance and to provide feedback from the community to the Superintendent, rather than directly dictating personnel decisions.
Council members also inquired about the achievement gap, specifically regarding students of color. Several candidates referred to this as an "opportunity gap" rather than an inherent capability issue. Shonda Stanford stated that the gap has been steadily increasing since 2009 and that the board must address the systematic issues causing it. On the topic of discipline, candidates discussed the disproportionate disciplinary actions against Black and Brown students and the use of law enforcement in schools. Candidate John Moscone argued against charging kids with crimes in the school system, stating it reinforces bad behavior, while Candidate Melissa Cletus highlighted the need to address implicit bias within the school structure.
Follow-ups
Two candidates explicitly agreed to follow up with Council members regarding specific issues. One candidate, identified in the transcript as Martha Gartner, offered to call back a Council member with the outcome of a Math 1 curriculum meeting. Another candidate, Shonda Stanford, stated she would sit down with a Council member to discuss the community engagement plan in more detail. No specific staff members were directed to take action during the interviews.
Impact
This meeting is significant for residents as it determines the composition of the School Board, which oversees local educational policy. The discussions highlight ongoing community concerns regarding how the district communicates major changes and addresses equity and discipline disparities. The candidates' responses indicate a focus on improving transparency, engaging parents earlier in the decision-making process, and addressing systemic inequities if they are appointed.
Meeting Video & Transcript