HCCBG Advisory Committee Meeting | Nov. 19, 2025
November 19, 2025 at 3:30 PM
- 1 h 29 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The HCCBG Advisory Committee held its regular meeting on November 19, 2025. The committee approved the agenda and the meeting minutes without revisions. The committee also voted to amend the bylaws to add a new "Purpose" section, which passed with a vote of 6-0. This amendment establishes the committee's mission to support the quality of life of older adults and their caregivers, allowing them to live safely in the least restrictive environment and providing transportation and social opportunities to reduce isolation.
Discussion Highlights
The primary focus of the meeting was the review and potential revision of the funding application process and scoring tools. Suzanne Booth presented a revised version of the application, aiming to improve clarity for both applicants and reviewers. The draft scoring tool proposes a significant shift from a numerical 1–5 scale to a binary (Yes/No) or categorical (High/Moderate/Low) evaluation method. This change includes specific Yes/No questions regarding community need, program plan clarity, coordination with other agencies, and budget reasonableness. The committee discussed the logic of the previous numerical system, noting that no algorithm is used to automate allocation and that decisions rely on the committee's subjective interpretation of agency plans.
During the discussion on the application, Zack Schmitt suggested requiring applicants to attach their most recent monitor report, citing that Henderson County requires this documentation. Melissa Harmon suggested tying the scoring tool directly to the purpose statement recently added to the bylaws to ensure evaluations align with the core goals of the Home and Community Care Block Grant (HCCBG). The committee also debated the "Client Service Experience" section, raising concerns about how agencies support clients who do not have caregiver advocates and the potential for subjective bias in scoring.
The committee reviewed expenditure reports for Units of Service and Buncombe County Supplemental Aging Funds (BCSAF). Providers were generally tracking well, though the committee emphasized the importance of timely invoicing for BCSAF to prevent funds from reverting to Buncombe County. Mountain Aging Partners reported adding 44 additional transportation trips under supplemental aging funding, bringing their total to approximately 64 filled trips, with expectations to add more in the coming weeks. The Land of Sky Senior Companion Program noted that they have not yet used HCCBG funds because they utilize other funding sources first. Additionally, the committee discussed an elder club that had not launched as planned, noting that no updates had been received from the responsible parties.
Follow-ups
Susan Schiemer agreed to send a copy of the purpose statement from the previous month's meeting to all committee members. The committee scheduled a follow-up meeting for December 17, 2025, to further discuss the application process and scoring tool, specifically focusing on aligning the tool with the HCCBG purpose. Committee members will continue to review and provide feedback on the revised application process in preparation for that meeting.
Impact
These discussions are significant for residents because they directly affect how funding is distributed to the agencies that provide essential services to older adults, such as transportation, home-delivered meals, and in-home aide services. By moving toward a more objective, categorical scoring system and refining the application to better capture how clients navigate services, the committee aims to ensure that limited federal and county funds are allocated to programs that effectively meet community needs and build capacity, particularly in the face of potential funding reductions.
Meeting Video & Transcript