Skip to main content

Asheville City Board of Education Work Session Monday, November 2, 2026

November 2, 2026 at 4:45 PM

  • 3 h 59 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Asheville City Board of Education Work Session Recap: November 2, 2026

The Asheville City Board of Education held a work session on November 2, 2026, to review financial audits, student performance data, capital projects, and a series of policy updates. The meeting focused heavily on the district’s fiscal health and academic outcomes, with the board approving the agenda and placing several items on future consent agendas for final votes. No public comments were recorded during the session.

Financial Audit and Food Service Funding The board reviewed the draft audit for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2026, which received an unmodified opinion, the best possible result, with no federal or state findings. The auditor stated, "I am pleased to report that the district received an unmodified opinion on the June 30th, 2026 financial statements. This is the best audit opinion that the district can receive." While the total governmental fund balance decreased by approximately $531,000, a board member noted that the decrease was less than in earlier years. Significant discussion centered on the School Food Service Fund, which continues to see cash declines despite a $575,000 transfer from the general fund. Staff clarified that this decline is linked to the adoption of the Community Eligibility Provision (CEP), with the goal of increasing participation to reverse the trend. The board placed the 2026 Audit Report on the consent agenda for the meeting two weeks from now, agreeing to vote to accept the report in draft form contingent on any significant revisions from the federal government.

Student Data and Literacy Gaps Staff presented monthly Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) and detailed reading data using the "Scarborough’s Rope" model. The data highlighted a divergence in student performance: while the district is closing the gap in word recognition, a significant and widening achievement gap remains in language comprehension for Black students. End-of-Grade (EOG) proficiency data showed a downward trend for Black students in third grade, with proficiency rates cited as low as 8-9%. A board member stated, "The idea that our students are learning how to recognize words and repeat words but they don't have the more higher level understanding concepts of applying English and language arts is devastating... I would say that eight or 9% of our black students on the EOG is inexcusable." In response, staff explained that the district is overhauling its instructional core to focus on high-quality teaching, learning targets, and engagement protocols, supplemented by small-group instruction and tutors. A staff member added, "We have to have a high quality foundational core of what we offer... If we don't have high quality instruction generally in a classroom based on the standards... then the intervention group can only make so much difference."

Capital Projects and School Improvement The board reviewed a contract with TP Howards for a $299,000+ project to repair stormwater and sewer infrastructure issues at a hillside near the stadium, which had caused damage to the track. This contract was placed on the consent agenda for the next week. Additionally, the principal of Hall Fletcher School presented an improvement plan to address the school’s low performance rating, focusing on behavior and academic achievement. The principal reported a significant reduction in major referrals, stating, "We have 14 major referrals this year... Last year we had about 120, so that would be half." When asked about ensuring the reduction is due to positive reinforcement, the principal replied, "We're in the classrooms... making sure that those teachers are supported." The improvement plan was placed on the consent agenda for the meeting two weeks from now.

Program Updates Staff provided updates on several district programs. For the Pre-K program, staff noted a cost of just over $16,000 per child per year, stating that breaking even would require a 63% tuition increase, which they deemed unlikely for families to pay. The EPIC internship program, a partnership with the Dogwood Grant and Christina Avery Foundation, expanded from a 6-student pilot to a 12-student fall cohort, with evaluation data from the summer pilot described as "off the charts positive." The program will include students from the William Randolph campus in the spring. A brief update on the Strings program indicated that interviews for a part-time strings teacher are underway, with the program expected to resume in January.

Policy Review and Legal Counsel The board reviewed numerous policies, many mandated by recent state legislation. Legal counsel presented an overview of state laws regarding the "FF" grade, noting that it is an optional alternative grade. On Policy 3510 (Religious Release Time), the board agreed to remove contentious preamble language regarding the "free exercise of religion" and replace it with a neutral statement before second read. For procurement policies (6420, 6430, 6442), the board acknowledged the legal requirement to remove provisions related to "historically underutilized businesses" but moved them forward to second read, with staff directed to explore ways to maintain engagement with these businesses within legal limits. Policies regarding Paid Parental Leave (7510, 7525) and Educator Evaluation (7811) also moved forward to second read. A board member expressed concern that the growth plan requirement in the educator evaluation policy could be "code for we're going to set up this... for termination," to which staff replied, "The policy does state that it is made in conjunction with the educator, in collaboration with the educator. So, I mean, the educator does have a voice in this." Several other policies regarding instructional materials, school safety, and student wellness moved forward to second read with minor corrections.

Follow-Ups and Next Steps Staff agreed to provide definitive numbers comparing Asheville City Schools’ food and nutrition spending to similar-sized districts, a breakdown of students released to Buncombe County Schools, and data on the distribution of Black students' scores relative to the proficiency threshold. Staff also agreed to look into the cost-effectiveness of the Chartwells contract versus direct employment for food service staff, explore legal ways to encourage participation from small and historically underutilized businesses in procurement, and provide further input on the implementation and financial impact of the Paid Parental Leave policies. Legal staff were asked to consider language regarding students who unenroll and re-enroll within the same semester to prevent circumvention of attendance policies. The board entered a closed session to discuss personnel matters and attorney-client privileged information, and the Chair declared a five-minute break following a final vote.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches