Asheville City Board of Education Regular Session May 11, 2026
May 11, 2026 at 4:57 PM
- 2 h 48 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On May 11, 2026, the Asheville City Board of Education held its regular session. The meeting covered legislative updates from Raleigh, the adoption of the district’s Strategic Plan recommendations, the approval of the Fiscal Year 2027 budget memo to the County Commissioners, and the renewal of two significant vendor contracts: the Chartwells food service agreement and the EL Education program.
Key Decisions
The Board approved the agenda and consent agenda unanimously. The consent agenda included a minor edit to the April 13 work session minutes to clarify that no board action was taken on a bus stop arm letter during that session. The Board voted unanimously to adopt the memorandum containing the updated Vision, Mission, Core Values, and Strategic Plan Objectives. Additionally, the Board unanimously approved the Fiscal Year 2027 Budget Memo to be sent to the County Commissioners and the local budget message letter, with the understanding that the Superintendent would make modest revisions to the letter based on board discussion.
Two vendor contracts were voted on with mixed results. The motion to approve the Chartwells Dining Contract passed 6-1, with one member voting "Nay." The motion to approve the EL Education Contract passed 5-2, with two members voting "Nay." The meeting concluded with a unanimous vote to adjourn.
Discussion Highlights
Superintendent Dr. Kim Deccant provided a legislative update, noting the General Assembly’s urgency to pass a budget before Memorial Day. Key items included a proposed 11% teacher pay raise, free breakfast for all K-12 students, and Senate Bill 943, which proposes keeping the corporate income tax at 5% rather than phasing it out.
During the review of the Strategic Plan, the Board debated the language used to describe educational disparities. Jesse Warren stated, "The achievement gap is there for a reason. Because the problem that we have in Asheville City School is the biggest achievement gap in North Carolina... what is important is what we’re trying to fix here in Asheville City School is the achievement gap." Vice Chair Rebecca Strimer emphasized the integrity of language, stating, "I don’t think we can get wedded to any particular word over another necessarily as long as we work with integrity about not losing our focus on what will be the experience of students in our schools." George Sieburg expressed a desire to understand the gaps in the bottom quintile or quartile better.
Regarding the Fiscal Year 2027 Budget Memo, discussion focused on the language used to describe staffing reductions. One board member suggested striking the terms "strict" and "right-sizing" and instead acknowledging that most changes were made through attrition and transfers, noting that this process is "painful for students and staff."
For the Chartwells contract, one board member stated, "I don't feel like I have enough information to vote on this... The sticking point for me is the, the saving money by paying staff less with our lowest paid staff... I don't know if that's real because they have the additional benefit of the summertime unemployment." For the EL Education contract, another board member said, "I'm not willing to abandon this journey yet because I do know that it's been powerfully successful some schools and I think it requires a longer-term commitment for it to become successful... I would like to see that manifested more, but I will support it."
Community Input
Public comment was extended to accommodate all sign-ups. Multiple commenters, including staff, parents, and alumni, spoke against cutting the visual arts teaching position at Asheville High. A ceramic arts teacher argued that cutting the position would mean 150 students would lose access to art classes. A social studies teacher with 30+ years of experience called the forced choice between cutting arts or media positions "unconscionable." A professional artist and parent shared that her daughter’s access to multiple art classes led to a National Scholastic Art Gold Medal. A recent graduate stated that having three visual arts teachers allowed her to take art from level 1 to AP. An alumnus noted that art is foundational to the city’s identity. A parent of a student at SILSA described art as her daughter’s "safe haven." Members did not respond directly to these specific comments during the public comment period. However, later in the meeting, during the budget memo discussion, one member stated, "I would almost suggest that... these represent lost positions... and that has resulted in larger class sizes... and the loss of certain programming... I just feel like this sort of glosses over how painful our decisions have been to our teachers and our staff and our students." Another member added, "I think for purposes of our students, they haven't been good."
Regarding the Chartwells contract, a third-grade student spoke about declining food quality, citing spoiled cream cheese and processed foods. The student’s mother stated that the issues reflect broad systemic problems with the food service contractor, including poor working conditions for staff. A public commenter raised concerns about staff abuses and food quality, suggesting the Board reject the contract. In response, a board member stated that they had not heard those specific assertions about staff abuse before. Another board member expressed concern that the contract did not offer new employees the choice between direct employment with the district or employment by Chartwells, noting the difference in benefits.
A parent and community member asked how the Board is sequencing decisions given that the strategic plan action plans and facility needs assessment are not yet complete. A parent of students at Jones Elementary asked for "clarity, transparency, and honesty" in the budget process, urging the Board to use the current fund balance and new county funding to build back programs rather than cut them. Members did not respond to these comments.
A public commenter, identified as a student, stated that students felt like "passengers" rather than "crew" in an elementary school. In response, a board member asked staff how the district was increasing buy-in. Superintendent Maggie Furman responded that they were sharing student results with teachers to show positive impact and conducting student focus groups, noting that students from her advisory team supported the investment in professional learning.
Follow-ups
Superintendent Dr. Kim Deccant and Business Manager Heidi Kearns agreed to fact-check a specific dollar figure of $2.6 million cited in the Fiscal Year 2027 Budget Memo and revise it if necessary before the May 15 deadline. The Superintendent also agreed to make modest revisions to the third paragraph of the budget letter, remove the "budget enhancement request" paragraph, add a qualifier to the revenue-neutral rate, and add a sentence acknowledging the request for a rate revision absent a moratorium.
The Chair asked staff to look into the concerns raised regarding food quality and to speak with the new local Chartwells lead, stating the Board needs to be ready to discuss other options when the current five-year term expires. The Superintendent committed to taking the Board’s concerns about EL Education implementation pace and buy-in into consideration. Additionally, the Superintendent agreed to check if the district can opt-in to administering the Teacher Working Conditions Survey annually rather than bi-annually. One Board member stated they would like to revisit the district’s remote learning policy in a future meeting, and the Chair agreed to have the calendar committee track this.
Impact
This meeting marks a significant step in the district's long-term planning, as the Board formally adopted the updated Strategic Plan and approved the budget request to the County Commissioners. The approval of the budget memo, which requests a 10-cent supplemental tax rate, will determine the district's funding capacity for the coming year. The mixed votes on the Chartwells and EL Education contracts reflect ongoing community and board concerns regarding food service quality, staff benefits, and the effectiveness of instructional programs. The follow-up actions, including the fact-checking of budget figures and the investigation into food quality concerns, will shape the district's operational decisions in the near term.
Meeting Video & Transcript