Planning Board Meeting
September 15, 2025 at 9:32 AM
- 50 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Buncombe County Planning Board Meeting Recap: September 15, 2025
The Buncombe County Planning Board held a meeting on September 15, 2025, which proceeded as a discussion session rather than a formal decision-making body due to a lack of quorum. Consequently, no official votes were taken, and no formal decisions or approvals were made during the session. The primary focus of the meeting was an informational presentation on proposed changes to the county’s lighting ordinance, alongside a brief update on a pending map amendment.
The central topic of the meeting was the introduction of ZPH2025-00024, a proposed text amendment to the Zoning Ordinance regarding Exterior Commercial Lighting Standards. Staff presented the purpose of the amendments, which aim to minimize light pollution, reduce glare and light trespass, and promote energy efficiency. The presentation included an overview of basic lighting concepts, such as cutoff types, Kelvin ratings, and footcandles, and highlighted an equity analysis noting that light pollution disproportionately affects non-white communities and renters. Staff also discussed how the proposed changes align with the Buncombe County 2043 Comprehensive Plan, specifically regarding growth, equity, conservation, and infrastructure goals.
During the presentation, Bernie Argier, a lighting expert and former contributor to the original ordinance, provided extensive feedback. He advocated for adopting a 3,000 Kelvin limit for all outdoor lights to align with best practices from organizations like the American Medical Association and Dark Sky International. Argier also emphasized the importance of considering the impact on observatories, including UNCA’s, and suggested dimming parking lot lights after business hours to reduce pollution and save energy. The discussion further touched upon Duke Energy’s recent streetlight upgrades, noting their compliance with current regulations, and addressed how the proposed amendments would affect existing non-conforming uses.
Regarding the public hearing for ZPH2025-00022, the Ramsey Map Amendment, the applicant requested that the case be withdrawn. The request to rezone one parcel from R-3 Residential to CS-Commercial Service was pulled from the agenda after the applicant aligned with PODER Emma on long-term community strategy and agreed to wait for the County to introduce a Small Area Plan for the community before proceeding.
Staff outlined several next steps for the lighting amendment process. A work session is scheduled for October to delve deeper into the proposed text amendments and address questions, with staff planning to further explore the equity lens and review feedback regarding non-conformities and impacts on Duke Energy’s operations. Additionally, a public hearing is scheduled for November to allow residents and stakeholders to provide formal input before a final decision is made.
This meeting serves as a preliminary step in updating Buncombe County’s lighting ordinance. The proposed changes include new definitions for accent lighting, electronic message displays, and façade lighting, as well as specific limits on footcandles, Kelvin ratings, and mounting heights. The amendments also propose prohibitions on animated or flashing lights and outward-facing lights that are not fully shielded. While no decisions were made at this meeting, the board and staff have set a timeline for further review and public input in the coming months.
Meeting Video & Transcript