Public Hearings - Swearing in of Audience Members and Staff
Historic Resources Commission (In-Person) (Mar 11, 2026) · March 11, 2026 at 4:00 PM
Vice-Chair Oliva explained the public hearing rules, all those present in the audience and staff who anticipated speaking were sworn in.
What was said
Are there any corrections? So, we want to make a motion? I'll make a motion to approve the meeting minutes of last month. I second. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? Motion carries. We will now begin the evidentiary hearings for the items listed on the agenda. As a quasi-judicial proceeding, the HRC is not setting policy nor are we soliciting public opinion on the desirability of an application. The HRC hears and considers evidence presented and applies the standard set forth in the guidelines and standards of the specific historic district for that application. The HRC must make its decision upon competent, material, and substantial evidence to determine the facts of the hearing. The HRC will use judgment and discretion to apply the standards contained in the relevant guidelines to the facts. The commissioners in voting for an item will not have a fixed opinion not susceptible to change, have a conflict of interest, have engaged in ex parte communication regarding the application. The first one, or the first two I'm gonna go through together like I did the first iteration of these two projects for 53 Birch Street, which is for a retaining wall, replacement repair at the Riverside Cemetery, and then we're gonna talk a little bit more about the damaged wall at Montford Park. So just as a reminder, the section of wall in question is about 80 feet-ish long. It's on the east side of the cemetery along the property boundary and was damaged from Helene. So this is a FEMA repair project. We looked at some samples last time around and it was the feedback from the Commission and staff that needed to try to find a sample that maybe matched a stone that matched what was out there a little more closely. The standards require that walls be repaired, replaced as needed with materials matching the existing as closely as possible. The tricky thing with this wall is that the new wall will need to be a structural wall. And there are grave sites in very close proximity on the backside of the wall, so the project team is limited in terms of the extent that they can excavate. And so the wall needs to be constructed to have a stone veneer. So the applicant has submitted the revised plans with a section drawing of the wall on the left. And then the material is proposed to be hipstone. And we've got a wagon full of rocks back here that Mr. Jaramillo is gonna share with you all so you can see the materials in person this time around. So hopefully that will help with this wall. And then we also talked through the damaged wall, also a Helene project, recovery project in Montford Park. This is on the, I think the west side of the tennis courts at the park. There was some question I think about materials for this wall. It can be, it's my understanding at least, at least from the last hearing that it can be rebuilt to be considered