Historic Resources Commission Regular Meeting
June 11, 2025 at 4:00 PMIn personAsheville City Hall, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 2 h 40 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Historic Resources Commission Meeting Recap: June 11, 2025
The Historic Resources Commission (HRC) of the City of Asheville held its regular in-person meeting on June 11, 2025, to review applications for Certificates of Appropriateness and preliminary subdivision approvals within the city’s historic districts. As a quasi-judicial body, the commission evaluated these requests against established preservation guidelines to determine if proposed alterations, demolitions, or new constructions were appropriate for their respective historic contexts.
The commission began by approving the minutes from its May 14, 2025 meeting, along with the associated Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. This motion passed by a vote of 7-0. Following the approval of the minutes, the commission proceeded to public hearings on several properties, including requests for fencing, demolition, and new construction in the Montford, Biltmore Village, and St. Dunstan’s neighborhoods.
In the Montford Historic District, the commission addressed after-the-fact requests to install wood picket and wood post-and-wire fencing at 46 Pearson Drive and 42 Pearson Drive. After debate regarding compliance with district standards, the commission approved a modified plan with specific conditions. Applicants must remove the top and bottom rails from the post-and-wire fencing, ensure the front yard fence does not exceed four feet in height and is no more than 65% solid, and set the side yard fence back at least one foot from the front building facade. These adjustments must be completed by December 11, 2025.
The commission also reviewed a request from Darcy Ballard to tint the existing brick masonry siding at 112 Pearson Drive. Staff had recommended against approval, citing standards that prohibit altering historically unpainted masonry surfaces. The commission voted to deny this request, with the motion failing by a tally of 6-1.
In the Biltmore Village Historic District, the commission considered a request from 63 Brook Street, LLC to demolish an existing one-story structure at 19 Brook Street. The structure was identified as non-contributing to the historic district and had sustained damage from Hurricane Helene. The commission approved the demolition request, noting that the removal aligns with redevelopment goals for the area. The vote to pass this request was recorded, though the specific tally was not detailed in the provided records beyond the outcome.
Regarding new construction, the commission reviewed a proposal for a two-story addition to the rear elevation of an existing primary structure at 133 Montford Avenue. The application was approved with conditions requiring staff review of the brick sample to ensure it matches existing materials. Additionally, the chimney design was approved with a modification allowing for flexibility in placement, provided the chimney is smaller than originally proposed. Applicants must submit the chimney and window/door specifications for final approval.
During the public hearings, several residents spoke regarding the Pearson Drive fencing cases, expressing concerns about adherence to historic guidelines and the potential impact on neighborhood character. A representative for the property owner at 56 Pearson Drive also spoke about the need for demolition and future redevelopment plans. The commission emphasized the importance of balancing preservation efforts with property owner needs while strictly applying established guidelines.
In other business, the commission discussed ongoing efforts to update the National Register nomination for Biltmore Village, a process that could provide tax credits for property owners. The commission also addressed potential cuts to federal funding for historic preservation, which may impact state and local preservation efforts. Staff indicated they will review the deck materials, counter design, and chimney design for the 56 Pearson Drive project as part of the ongoing approval process.
Meeting Video & Transcript