Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting
September 3, 2025 at 3:00 PMIn personHarrah's Cherokee Center - Asheville, 87 Haywood St, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Banquet Hall
- 8 h 53 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Recap: September 3, 2025
The City of Asheville Planning and Zoning Commission held an in-person meeting on September 3, 2025, which was relocated to an alternate location due to high public interest. The agenda included the approval of previous minutes, updates from committee workgroups, and public hearings regarding three major land use requests: a conditional zoning amendment for the Deerfield Episcopal Retirement Community, a special use permit for a telecommunications tower, and a conditional zoning amendment for a residential development on New Haw Creek Road.
Key Decisions The commission took the following votes during the meeting:
- Minutes Approval: The minutes from the August 6, 2025 meeting were approved by a vote of 5-0.
- Deerfield Episcopal Retirement Community (1617 Hendersonville Rd): The commission voted 4-1 to approve the conditional zoning amendment with specific conditions. The conditions include the incorporation of amended "E1 conditions" (with clarification that funds for buffer landscaping on the Ramble HOA property will be transferred to the HOA or its designee), a maximum total new building square footage of 822,300 sq. ft., a maximum total new unit count of 261, and a sidewalk connection along Salisbury Drive.
- Concealed Telecommunications Tower (3 S. Tunnel Rd): The commission voted 5-0 to approve the special use permit. This approval includes a technical modification allowing the tower to reach a height of 135 feet, exceeding the standard 100-foot limit.
- Meadows at New Haw Creek (767 New Haw Creek Rd): The commission voted 5-0 to approve the conditional zoning amendment with the condition that the crest of the new bridge must be designed to a standard that matches the 100-year base flood elevation.
Discussion Highlights Will Palmquist, Principal Planner, presented the Deerfield application, noting that the proposal moves the grounds maintenance building off-site and removes a water feature. The discussion focused on the use of the parking area, which is limited to personal vehicles and prohibits construction staging or trash storage, as well as landscaping buffers.
Regarding the telecommunications tower, the commission held a quasi-judicial public hearing for the request by Asheville Mall Capital Holding LLC. The project involves a 135-foot concealed facility intended to improve wireless capacity.
For the New Haw Creek development, Sam Starr-Baum, Planner III, presented a request to amend the site plan to change the main access point to a new bridge over New Haw Creek. The unit count remains at 84 units. The commission clarified that its role is to make a land-use recommendation to the City Council, with mandatory flood studies and permitting occurring after this step.
Community Input A significant number of residents signed up to speak during the public comment period.
- Regarding the Deerfield expansion, several speakers raised concerns about the adequacy of the detailed plans, specifically questioning if the city had the authority to review conditional zonings as conceptual master plans. Other comments cited discrepancies between submitted plans and communicated details, questioned the compatibility of the large-scale development with the area’s "residential neighborhood" designation, and asked about the impact of the 10% variance allowed in project size.
- Regarding the New Haw Creek development, public comment expressed strong opposition to the bridge and development in the flood plain, citing past flooding and potential downstream impacts.
Follow-ups The City Attorney will review the appeal regarding the city's authority to review conditional zonings as conceptual master plans. The applicant for the New Haw Creek Road development must complete an H&H (Hydrologic & Hydraulic) flood study and obtain necessary permits before construction can begin. The Anti-Displacement Work Group will continue to reflect on the suggested definition of displacement and likely revisit it in a future agenda item.
Impact These decisions represent recommendations to the City Council, which will make the final determinations on the zoning amendments. For residents, the approval of the Deerfield expansion includes specific requirements for parking usage and landscaping buffers to mitigate impacts on neighboring communities. The approval of the telecommunications tower allows for improved wireless service capacity in the area, subject to the approved height modification. The New Haw Creek approval allows for a change in vehicular access via a new bridge, contingent on the bridge design meeting flood elevation standards and the completion of required flood studies.
Meeting Video & Transcript