Board of Adjustment
March 23, 2026 at 2:00 PMIn person70 Court Plaza, Asheville, NC 28801, USA - First Floor Conference Room
- 14 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
The City of Asheville Board of Adjustment held its regular meeting on March 23, 2026. The agenda included administrative matters, the appointment of a new board secretary, and a public hearing on a flood variance request for a historic property in the Biltmore Village Historic District.
The board began by approving the minutes, findings of fact, and conclusions of law from its February 23, 2026 meeting. This motion passed with a vote of 4-0. Following this, the board formally appointed Phoebe Probst as the new Secretary for the Board of Adjustment.
The primary focus of the meeting was an evidentiary hearing regarding a variance request from applicant Josh Scala for the property at 5 All Souls Crescent. Urban Planner Sam Starbaum presented the case, explaining that the property, a contributing structure within the Biltmore Village Historic District, sustained substantial damage from flooding. The repairs are estimated at $194,666, which exceeds 50% of the building’s $308,000 value, triggering the requirement to bring the structure into compliance with current flood standards. Starbaum noted that elevating the building by six and a half feet to meet these standards would significantly alter its appearance and historical integrity. The variance allows the property to comply with Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) flood standards to the maximum extent practicable without compromising its historic character. The applicant intends to restore the property to its pre-flood use as a retail cannabis/CBD dispensary.
Chair Suzanne Godsey outlined the board’s quasi-judicial role and the legal standards required for granting a variance, including whether the hardship is peculiar to the property and consistent with the spirit of the law. Starbaum emphasized that granting the variance is consistent with the area's zoning and architectural style. The board voted to approve the variance in accordance with the staff conditions outlined in the presentation. This motion passed with a vote of 6-0.
No public comments or expert testimony were offered during the hearing. The applicant is required to work with city staff, including urban planners and the floodplain administrator, to ensure compliance with the seven staff conditions attached to the approval. These conditions relate to ongoing coordination and adherence to city regulations during the restoration process.
This decision allows for the restoration of a historic building in the Biltmore Village neighborhood while balancing flood mitigation requirements with the preservation of the district’s architectural character. The approval ensures that the property can be repaired and returned to its intended retail use without undergoing structural changes that would diminish its historic status.
Meeting Video & Transcript