The applicant, Josh Scala, is requesting variances to the standards in Section 7-12-1(e)(2)(b) Flood Hazard Reduction, of the UDO. The purpose of the request is to allow for the repair of a historic structure without fully complying with the flood protection standards in order to preserve its historic character. The property is known as 5 All Souls Crescent. and PIN 9647-79-2712. For further information please contact Sam Starr-Baum, Urban Planner III, City of Asheville, PO Box 7148, Asheville, NC, 28802 or 828-259-5609.
Board of Adjustment (In-Person) (Mar 23, 2026) · March 23, 2026 at 2:00 PM
The applicant, Josh Scala, is requesting variances to the standards in Section 7-12-1(e)(2)(b) Flood Hazard Reduction, of the UDO. The purpose of the request is to allow for the repair of a historic structure without fully complying with the flood protection standards in order to preserve its historic character. The property is known as 5 All Souls Crescent. and PIN 9647-79-2712. For further information please contact Sam Starr-Baum, Urban Planner III, City of Asheville, PO Box 7148, Asheville, NC, 28802 or 828-259-5609.
What was said
Great. The property is known as 5 All Souls Crescent and the PIN number is 9647792712. Sam Starbaum, Urban Planner 3, will be presenting the case this afternoon. Yes, thank you, Madam Chairwoman and members of the Commission. I'd like to extend a welcome to our newest member, Mr. Johnson. It's good to have you here for this meeting. Unfortunately, we were having some technical difficulties the the presentation computer has died right before the meeting, of course. So there is in your folders, the same presentation that should be accessible to you all. What I will do is I will talk about the slide I am on. I will also show that to you visually. If you have any questions as we go through this, please let me know. For those of you that have been part of this flood variance process, this should seem remarkably familiar because this is the exact same presentation. I think it is important both for our newest member, for our board secretary, and for all the sports fans at home to follow this process because it talks about what we do, why we do it this way, and why we are still working towards Helene recovery in the Biltmore Village Historic District. So as the chairwoman had said, this is at Five All Souls Crescent, the applicant is Josh Scala. This is generally known as an area that is known for its historicity historic structures. This is a recognized historic district, so this is why this qualifies for a flood variance. You have to be a contributing historic structure, be in a historic district for these types of things. Now, your building has to be substantially damaged. What does this mean? If you go to that next slide, slide two, outside of the title presentation, you should see some math there, and flood variance 101 would be in the corner. the top numerator is repair cost. So this is the cost it takes to repair your historic building to the day prior to the storm. This is not any new additions. This is not changing the use. This is not changing anything about the building. This is only to repair it to the day prior to the storm. The bottom number is your total building value. This is either through what Buncombe County tax records has or through a mark. based assessment. And then what happens is you do a little bit of math here and you find out that if that number is greater than 50 percent, so for example, let's say that you have $100,000 of repair cost and your building is only worth $150,000, then your building is substantially damaged. This is important for repair and hole in recovery because if you are greater than 50% you then have to restore that building in a way that meets the new floodplain standards and in most cases that is elevating to two feet above the base flood elevation. This is what we're dealing with with this building, right? So the applicant, Josh Scala, has presented his permit with the total cost for this. This will cost $194,666 to restore this to the day before the flood.