Old Business Public Hearings
Historic Resources Commission (In-Person) (May 13, 2026) · May 13, 2026 at 4:00 PM
Documents
- Accessible HRC Agenda May 2026.pdfOther · PDF · 3 pages · auto-matched
What was said
The HRC hears and considers evidence presented and applies the standards set forth therein in the historic, specific historic district or landmark for that application. The HRC must make its decision upon competent, material and substantial evidence to determine the facts of the hearing. The HRC will use judgment and discretion to apply the standards contained in the relevant standards to the facts. The commissioners in voting for an item will not have a fixed opinion, not susceptible to change, have a conflict of interest, have engaged in ex parte communications regarding the application. The rules for speaking. The rules for speaking. This is open to the public, but participation is limited to interested parties who wish to provide testimony, comments, or comments regarding the proposal. If you're going to be speaking as a witness, please focus on the facts and how they relate to the historic relevant district standard, not personal preference or opinion. Witnesses must swear or affirm their testimony. At this time we're going to administer the oath for all individuals who intend to provide witness testimony. So if you're going to talk or present, time to stand up and raise your right hand. Alright. Do you all solemnly swear or affirm that the information you present during the certificate of appropriateness, or preliminary subdivision approval for the Historic Resources Commission shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. Alright. Thank you very much. You have to sit down. And now I think we're going to vote to move Walton Poole to June. I actually don't need a motion because there wasn't a motion last meeting, which is why we're having to move it to June, because we have to re-notice for the public hearing. So Walton Poole is not going to be on the agenda. Correct. All right. Okay. And thank you Commissioner Hornaday members of the commission. I'll just introduce myself since I didn't know the top for anybody who's watching at home. My name is Alex Cole and I work with the planning department and I'm the liaison to the commission. So we're going to jump in with an old business item for 265 Cumberland Avenue. It's been a few months since you all had this application before you. The applicant had to continue a couple of times. So they are with us today and hopefully you had a chance to look at the revised plans, but they've submitted. Just to recap some basic information about the property. It is located on Cumberland Avenue. And they are requesting to modify the retaining wall on the right side of the driveway. If you were here for the last time, you can see the property. If you were here for the last time, you would have to be able to see the property. And I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. But I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, I'm sure you had to look at the revised plans. So, there's some concerns noted in terms of modifying the wall since the standards say that the configuration of historic walls is important to retain. They did submit some alternatives. So, this is what was initially submitted the first go around. And then there's four different alternatives that are included in your packet. So, the first one is basically just taking two to three feet out of the wall and moving it backward but not altering the wall entirely at the street. So, I guess one question I have is it seems like the way that the information was shared in the front end that the issue was the interior part of the wall once you entered the driveway. not necessarily the curved piece of it. And so, to me, what's visual from the street, if anything, is the most important to maintain. So, I guess I, you know, potentially could get behind the, our staff would potentially support maintaining that, the curvilinear shape as it comes from the street. And then potentially moving the wall back if that was something that the commission thought was practical to solve their problem. So, that's my, those are my thoughts on this. I'm still kind of, you know, landing where I was before about maintaining configurations of historic walls I think is important. And this one, like I think I said this last time is actually fairly wide for some of the driveways in the district. There's a house next door to this and I didn't measure it, but it's got walls that go into a garage that are probably, I don't know, eight feet high. And you basically there's space to drive one car in there. So, there's definitely other, narrower driveways were more common back then, I guess is my point. But this one, especially at the opening to the street is pretty wide. So, any questions for me?