Next Steps
Special Meeting: Historic Resources Commission (Virtual) (Apr 28, 2026) · April 28, 2026 at 9:00 AM
What was said
but we had planned to put this on the regular May agenda for public comment and hopefully for the Commission to vote and move this forward. And that's in part because we have to move on. We have other things in our work plan that we've got to start picking back up, and this has been taking of quite a bit of bandwidth in the past two years. So, and I know that, like I said, I know the neighborhood is, you know, ready for this to get done. And my suggestion would be is, and I understand, I think there's always going to be two sides of this fence, haha, just disagreement on exactly how the standards should be worded, or what the process should be. I don't know that everyone's going to coalesce around that. That was certainly the goal is to get consensus to the extent we can, but it may just need to go to a vote. And I would say break up the two topics. Like don't, like, fences needs to be its own thing if it's clearly, you know, going to be on an agenda and you all don't necessarily agree on the proposed changes or the lack of proposed changes either way. And so it's not really for me to like necessarily make a recommendation at this point. I do think we are pretty close though to being ready and I part of me thinks we'll just you know edit this language out that seems to have caused a wrinkle here and then proceed forward with May in May but I will defer to folks on the executive committee. Are we meeting as an executive committee or is we meeting is the do we have a quorum where we can have motions and such? - You mean at the May meeting? - I mean today. - No today we're not making any decisions today. This is just for discussion and then at the May regular meeting will be an opportunity for public comment and then for the commission to make decision or decisions. Yeah well go ahead sorry. Yeah I'm just I'm actually not in favor of taking out the language. I think the sentence is fine. I just I was commenting that that Leslie is absolutely right that it does leave it does make us feel more subjective but I actually don't mind that. I'd rather show people that there is opportunity rather than make them feel like there is an opportunity for us to consider things. And as you know, Alex stated, yeah, it's there no matter what. We're always going to consider things on a case-by-case basis because that's just the nature of it. But I prefer to leave the language as the red line has it. Thank you very much. Okay, so, oh, I'm sorry, Amy. I just want to convey that I have no problem with the current language, and case by case, I think, yeah, I have no problem with it whatsoever. Okay. Gracias. Bill? De nada. My problem with the phrasing of case-by-case basis is, are we awarding it to the neighbor that everybody likes, but the neighbor that no one likes? Are we... you're opening yourself up to potential criticism based on having to turn down someone with language such as case-by-case basis. I would like to see it fully and actually defined so that when people look at this process they can figure out what they can and can't do and then if they come to the committee it's almost as an appeal basis not as a case-by-case basis. Maybe we should add to the wording some of those specific circumstances like after the word case by case basis period for example comma extreme cases where you know there's a bus stop in someone's yard yada yada yada maybe they need a few examples but it's got to be you know extreme cases. Janice? I'm sorry I can wait to the rest of the commissioner's weigh in but as I'm reading case by case from a legal perspective it does give me a little heartburn too even though that is the way that you do read things there is i think a difference when you say non-traditional materials on a case-by-case basis that's such a narrow uh field that it's easier to say oh well you know does this non-traditional material does it change the historic character but in this one it's a broader case by case so i don't know if you need to get at and i understand the executive committee was trying to not trying to recognize that that there is wiggle room that this is not shall not be any fences now the big change really i thought it's it's up further where it used to say are not are are generally discouraged that was language i think you've cut now that used to really become problematic because commissioners were like what is generally discouraged me