Planning & Zoning Commission 7/16/26 Part 1
July 16, 2026 at 6:00 PM
- 2 h 19 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The Planning and Zoning Commission of the Town of Montreat held a public hearing on July 16, 2026, regarding a Planned Unit Development (PUD) zoning request for the property at 309 Collegiate Circle. The Commission unanimously voted (7-0) to adopt a Special Order for the hearing, which established a five-minute time limit per speaker. Additionally, the Commission unanimously voted (7-0) to amend the Rules of Procedure by deleting Rule 24 in its entirety and replacing it with updated language to eliminate redundant requirements for future public hearings. The Commission also unanimously voted (7-0) to adopt the minutes from the April 16, 2026, meeting as amended, which included correcting a statistic and fixing a spelling error in the Chair’s name.
During the meeting, the Commission unanimously voted (7-0) to excuse Commission Member Allen Crawford from the remainder of the proceedings and to seat Alternate Member Gayle Sawyer as a voting member. Following extensive discussion and public comment, the Commission unanimously voted (7-0) to continue the public hearing and discussion on the PUD application to Thursday, August 6, 2026, at 10:30 AM. The Commission also unanimously voted (7-0) to open the public hearing for the PUD rezoning application.
Discussion Highlights
The primary focus of the meeting was the PUD application submitted by Richard DuBose on behalf of the Mountain Retreat Association (MRA), which seeks to rezone the 2.17-acre property from the Institutional/Residential (IR) district to a PUD district. Staff and the applicant presented a plan that includes a new 24-room lodge, two new eight-bedroom cottages, and the retention of three existing lodges, with a total capacity capped at 70 rooms (140 beds) and a minimum of 20% open space. Staff clarified that the application is a legislative hearing rather than a quasi-judicial special use permit.
Commissioners raised several technical and procedural concerns. Questions were directed at the applicant regarding the use of a "basket" calculation for parking (one space per 1,000 square feet) rather than standard net-increase calculations, and how building height is measured on sloped terrain. A significant portion of the discussion addressed confusion over why the application lists "permitted uses by right" from the underlying IR district (such as swimming pools and care homes) when these are not depicted on the site plan. Staff and the applicant clarified that while these uses remain permitted in the new zoning district, they cannot be executed without amending the specific PUD site plan, thereby maintaining town control over future changes. The applicant also clarified that the facility operates as a conference center/lodge serving groups, not as a commercial hotel.
Community Input
Numerous members of the public provided comments during the hearing. A representative of the Montreat Stewards stated that while the organization does not oppose the project, they have specific environmental concerns and requested that the Commission ensure the final product conforms to presented renderings. Several residents expressed concern about tree protection, requesting that the Commission require MRA to mark "saved trees" with flagging tape, consult with an arborist, and protect critical root zones with fencing and mulch. Other residents raised concerns about stormwater management, citing Hurricane Helene, and requested that the stormwater system be strengthened to handle a two-year, 24-hour storm event rather than the minimum one-year event.
Residents also voiced concerns about the visual impact of the main building, which is 159 feet wide, and requested design suggestions to soften its appearance. One resident, speaking on behalf of her parents, raised concerns about excavation and blasting potentially damaging their 110-year-old home and stone retaining wall, requesting written assurance regarding liability for construction damage. In response to these concerns, a staff member noted that construction techniques causing vibration would be regulated under grading and building permits, which is outside the Commission's purview. A Commission member stated they did not feel comfortable giving flexibility on the landscape plan without seeing specific details, noting the area was "too vague." Other public comments included support for the application, with one commenter noting that additional guest housing is essential for the community’s programs and economic health.
Follow-ups
Staff agreed to draft the recommendation for the governing body and ensure the final ordinance language clearly reflects that while certain uses are permitted in the new PUD district, they cannot be built without amending the specific site plan. MRA representatives agreed to work with town staff to update the application to clarify the uses allowed in the PUD, specifically addressing the conflict between the site plan and the master plan regarding reserved uses. The applicant indicated they were amenable to adding clarifying language stating that uses not depicted on the plan require a PUD amendment.
Impact
This meeting is significant for residents as it addresses the long-term zoning and development standards for a prominent property in Montreat. The decision to continue the hearing to August 6, 2026, allows for further clarification on seven specific areas identified by the Commission, including tree protection, stormwater management, and construction impacts. The Commission’s focus on distinguishing between "permitted uses" and "approved uses" aims to prevent misinterpretation by future property owners and developers. The Zoning Administrator also provided an update on recent activity, noting the approval of five exempt zoning compliance applications and one variance application scheduled for the Board of Adjustment on August 27, 2026.
Meeting Video & Transcript