Skip to main content

Planning & Zoning Commission Part 2 - 8/6/26

August 6, 2026 at 6:00 PM

Recap readyAdd to calendar
Previous: Jul 16 meetingNext: Oct 15 meeting
  • 1 h 5 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

Meeting Overview

On August 6, 2026, the Town of Montreat Planning and Zoning Commission convened a special meeting to continue the public hearing for the Planned Unit Development (PUD) zoning request for 309 Collegiate Circle, submitted by the Mountain Retreat Association (MRA). The agenda also included the adoption of the July 16, 2026, meeting minutes, updates from the Stormwater Subcommittee, and updates from the Zoning Administrator.

Key Decisions

The Commission adopted the July 16, 2026, meeting minutes as amended, with corrections to member titles and the time of the call to order. Following extensive deliberation, the Commission voted unanimously to approve the PUD application with specific conditions. These conditions include retaining all uses permitted in the previous Institutional/Residential (IR) district for existing buildings, granting the Zoning Administrator authority to approve minor modifications (defined as up to 10% size increase or 10-foot location change), and noting the applicant’s commitments regarding stormwater management and neighbor communication. The Commission also unanimously found the proposed plan consistent with the Town’s Comprehensive Plan. Finally, the Commission unanimously authorized the Chair to execute the written recommendation and consistency statement on behalf of the body to expedite the submission to the Board of Commissioners.

Discussion Highlights

A significant portion of the discussion focused on the administrative flexibility requested by the applicant. The applicant proposed language allowing the Zoning Administrator to approve minor changes to building location or size without returning to the Commission. Commission members debated whether a 10% size increase threshold was appropriate for large structures, noting that such an increase could result in significant physical changes. In response to concerns, staff recommended adding the clarification that "in no event may an administrative change allow encroachment into a setback" and striking the word "character" from the minor changes clause, as staff cannot make subjective design determinations. The applicant agreed to both modifications.

Regarding stormwater management, the applicant committed to voluntarily designing for a 2-year storm standard, exceeding the town’s current 1-year ordinance requirement, as part of an agreement with neighbors. While some members expressed a desire to future-proof the town’s standards following Hurricane Helene, the Commission did not explicitly mandate the higher standard in the approval, emphasizing instead that the design process should reflect current best practices. On tree protection, the applicant presented a draft plan committing to protect trees where practical, though engineering requirements take precedence. The applicant acknowledged that up to 50% of the roots of trees within a 10-foot "no-go" zone could be affected by construction disturbance.

Community Input

Several members of the public provided comment during the hearing. A representative from the Montreat Stewards expressed concern that the site plan might inadvertently include town-owned right-of-way or green space; staff clarified that the PUD master plan is strictly within property lines, though utility trenching beyond the line will be reviewed during the building permit phase. A resident urged the MRA to meet the 2-year storm standard and opposed the proposed language allowing buildings to move or grow without Commission approval, arguing such changes require public review. Another resident commended the collaborative approach between the Commission and MRA over the last six years, highlighting MRA’s role in providing trails and parks, and urged support for the lodge expansion to ensure financial stability and accessibility. A resident also inquired about the contractor’s budget and value engineering priorities if funds became tight; the Chair stated that no budget had been received and that it is not part of a typical application submission.

Follow-ups

Staff agreed to ensure the PUD recommendation to the Board of Commissioners reflects the retained uses and the clarified administrative change language. Staff also agreed to review utility connections beyond the property line during the building permit and zoning compliance phase. The Commission established a Stormwater Subcommittee, with members Bill Tucker, Eleanor James, and Sally Jenkins agreeing to schedule a meeting to review current regulations, including Buncombe County’s standards. Additionally, staff agreed to ensure the incoming Zoning Administrator is fully briefed on the project’s history and nuances, as the current Interim Zoning Administrator is leaving.

Impact

This decision allows the Mountain Retreat Association to proceed with the rezoning of 309 Collegiate Circle to a PUD district, facilitating the construction of a new 24-room commercial lodge and two new 8-bedroom cottages. The approval includes specific safeguards for neighboring properties, such as voluntary adherence to a higher stormwater standard, vibration monitoring, and strict tree protection protocols. The written recommendation and consistency statement will be sent to the Board of Commissioners for their final review.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches