Receive an executive summary presentation of Miller 3 Consulting’s Disparity Study for the City of Asheville and adopt a resolution to (1) accept the report of Miller 3’s disparity study; and (2) extend the race and gender conscious measures of the Asheville-Business Inclusion Policy, that are set to expire on November, 1, 2023, for an additional five-year period.
City Council Meeting (Oct 24, 2023) · October 24, 2023 at 12:00 PM
Documents
- New A - Disparity Study Presentation.pdfPresentation · PDF · 28 pages
- New A - Disparity Study (2).pdfStaff report · PDF · 4 pages
What was said
I guess just in this thread, my understanding is that this missing middle study and this displacement element, is this the first time that we've studied the impacts of our efforts towards supply on displacement of people? our legacy community do we do we have any other research that we can cross reference it to in this consideration my understanding is that the Missy middle study is kind of our first foray to hopefully get some principles some grounding some concepts at a technical locally applicable level Yeah. At a coordinated, you know, a comprehensive level, yes. And I, there's been a lot of studies done, I couldn't tell you for sure if anything's ever touched that, but nothing at a citywide level. Which is great. So it won't necessarily, it won't necessarily address specific legacy neighborhoods necessarily. We don't know. And you know what else I would love to see presented to us if we decide to have this come back? Thrive did a great presentation for HCD regarding affordable housing and who is primarily served by that. I think the missing middle study and their data would be great hand in hand so we could see because I don't know yet that there's a requirement for affordability when it comes to these cottages and this does not propose a requirement for affordability of the housing units. It's just zoning right now. So I have four things. A couple of things I have to carry forward just from advisory boards. Do you, for staff? Well, yeah, I do have a question. I'll try it fast because it's at the end. One, I just want to say thanks to Barry. I know he's in the room probably somewhere. I think folks bringing creative solutions to our affordable housing crisis is appreciated. But I also understand that our new timeline for the housing trust fund created some of this urgency for these parts to skip the line and not be in the missing middle. So we are trying to do the housing trust fund applications all at once instead of rolling. And that's what I understood is like, if we don't do it now, we could see affordability options for this not happen for a whole nother year. year. So that said, it bothers me too that the missing middle study has the displacement element consideration, our equity goals, and the engagement that's missing from this. Number two, I did send this to council, but on October 3rd, the Urban Forestry Commission recommendation was to postpone flag lots, which we did until the missing middle study, but they didn't take a position on cottage cluster. Though they did express concern that tree canopy protection isn't yet known for this change. Because it's kind of skipping the missing middle process. Number three, last night's neighborhood advisory committee recommendation was based on an understanding that flag lots was going to be continued. So they recommended that we also delay this. But not with the missing middle study just until January when we're supposed to reconsider the flag lots.