Skip to main content
  • 4 h 9 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: March 28, 2023

The City of Asheville City Council held a formal meeting on March 28, 2023, following a budget worksession earlier that day. The council addressed a wide range of items, including public safety updates, zoning changes, neighborhood planning, and the adoption of the Fiscal Year 2024 Fees & Charges Manual. The meeting concluded with the approval of several contracts, the adoption of a Municipal Climate Action Plan, and the deferral of the South Slope Neighborhood Vision Plan.

Key Decisions and Votes The council voted on numerous resolutions and ordinances. Most items passed unanimously (7-0), including:

  • Conditional Zoning: Approval of conditional zoning for 283 Merrimon Avenue, changing part of the parcel from Residential Multi-Family Medium Density to Institutional Conditional Zone.
  • HOME-ARP Allocation Plan: Authorization to submit the plan to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
  • Municipal Climate Action Plan: Adoption of the plan for municipal sustainability goals.
  • Fiscal Year 2024 Fees & Charges Manual: Adoption of the manual, excluding the recommended residential water rate increases.
  • Contracts and Grants: Authorization for contracts with French Broad Paving, Inc. (Walton Street Park), Mountain Goatscapes (invasive plant maintenance), Design Workshop Inc. (Parks & Recreation Master Plan), Cherry Bekaert, LLP (auditing), NEOGOV (HR System), Responder Support Services LLC (behavioral health), J. Bartholomew Construction LLC (Stephens-Lee Recreation Center), and Legerton Architecture, P.A. (Stephens-Lee architecture).
  • Speed Limits: An ordinance changing speed limits on U.S. 25 (Biltmore Avenue), Lee Garden Lane, John Walker Avenue, Pruitt Street, and Deaverview Road.
  • Transit Funding: Resolutions to apply for Section 5307, Section 5303, and Expanding Digital Opportunities grants.
  • Alcohol Permits: Authorization for alcohol consumption at Downtown After Five events, The Block Party, and GrindFest.

One item received a non-unanimous vote:

  • DNA Analyzer System: The resolution to purchase a DNA Analyzer System bundle from Life Technologies Corporation passed 6-1, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no.

The council also voted unanimously to continue the South Slope: A Southside Neighborhood Vision Plan to the April 1, 2023, meeting, rather than adopting it at this session.

Discussion Highlights The City Manager’s report included updates on public safety and water infrastructure. The Police Chief reported a 17.5% increase in aggravated assaults in 2022, noting that officer presence correlates with lower assault rates. The Fire Chief introduced a new Community Responder Pilot Program aimed at supporting the unsheltered community through a multidisciplinary approach. The council also received a status update from the Independent Review Committee, which is investigating the late 2022/early 2023 water system events; the committee is on track to deliver its final report by May 30, 2023.

Regarding the 283 Merrimon Avenue zoning request, council members debated the necessity of the rezoning, which was intended to clarify parking rights for the former Brookstone Baptist Church site. After public comment raised concerns about preserving residential potential, the council amended the motion to limit the rezoning to the eastern portion of the property, require the preservation of existing trees along Henrietta Street, and allow residential use on the parking lot area. The amended motion passed unanimously.

The South Slope Vision Plan was tabled due to concerns from the Southside United community regarding inadequate engagement and the plan’s boundaries. Mayor Esther Manheimer stated that the council needed to honor the community’s history and allow for further engagement before adoption.

The most significant debate occurred over the Fiscal Year 2024 Fees & Charges Manual. Staff proposed a 17.7% average increase in residential water base fees and a ~9% increase in consumption charges. Council members expressed concern about the impact on residents, particularly in light of the recent water interruption. The council decided not to adopt the recommended residential water rate increases. Instead, they directed staff to freeze the proposed residential water rate increase and return with a revised recommendation after the completion of a 90-day study on the water interruption. The council did adopt the recommended fee changes for all other utilities, including a 15% increase in stormwater fees and a $1/month increase in solid waste fees.

Community Input Public comment was received on several items. A public commenter argued that lowering speed limits only increases driver impatience and called for roadway redesign; no member or staff responded. Another commenter asked if contracts for the Stephens-Lee Recreation Center went to black-owned contractors; staff stated that no minority or women-owned businesses submitted bids as subcontractors. A representative for the Southside United community stated that members were "overwhelmed" by the information and felt their concerns about commercial impacts were not fully addressed, requesting the plan be tabled. Mayor Esther Manheimer agreed to table the item. On the Municipal Climate Action Plan, a public commenter suggested the plan explicitly consider microgrids for critical services; Council Member Kim Roney acknowledged the potential. Regarding water rates, a public commenter advocated for a flat rate system to incentivize conservation and noted that Asheville charges residential customers more than commercial users; council members discussed creating separate customer classes for multifamily versus single-family housing.

Follow-ups The council and staff agreed to the following next steps:

  • Water Rates: Staff will freeze the proposed residential water rate increase, complete the 90-day water interruption study (results expected late summer/early fall), and return with a revised recommendation that minimizes impact on residential rate payers while increasing rates for other categories to meet revenue needs.
  • South Slope Vision Plan: Staff will engage further with the Southside United community to address their concerns before the plan is brought back for a vote on April 1, 2023.
  • Crime Data: The Police Chief stated that demographic data for victims of violence is being added to the transparency dashboard.
  • Public Safety Plan: The Mayor stated that staff will present a 12-month plan and strategies for addressing crime trends to the Environment and Safety Committee next month.
  • Merrimon Avenue Zoning: Staff will incorporate the amended conditions (residential use on parking lot, tree preservation) into the final ordinance.
  • Stormwater Fees: Staff will complete a consultant review of the stormwater system, including fee structure comparisons, later in the summer.
  • Work Sessions: Council members agreed to find a solution to ensure all members can attend work sessions to provide better preview and input before full Council meetings.

Impact on Residents This meeting resulted in immediate changes to utility bills and speed limits. Residents can expect a 15% increase in stormwater fees and a $1/month increase in solid waste fees starting July 1, 2023. However, the proposed residential water rate increases were not adopted, and residents will not see those specific increases until staff returns with a revised recommendation after the water interruption study is complete. Speed limits on several local streets, including Biltmore Avenue, will be reduced to 15 or 20 mph. The deferral of the South Slope Vision Plan means that long-term development guidelines for the Southside area will not be finalized until at least April 1, 2023, allowing for additional community engagement.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches