Skip to main content

City Council Budget Work Session – March 28, 2023

March 28, 2023 at 2:53 PM

  • 1 h 13 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Budget Work Session Recap: March 28, 2023

On March 28, 2023, the Asheville City Council held a budget work session to review compensation strategies, benefits, and capital planning updates. As a work session, no formal votes were taken on any motions. Instead, the meeting focused on dialogue between Council members and staff regarding the city’s financial outlook and personnel needs.

A primary focus of the discussion was the city’s approach to employee compensation and retention. Staff presented recommendations to address recruitment and retention challenges, particularly within the Asheville Police Department (APD), Fire Department, and Public Works. The initial proposals included a 6% base pay increase for sworn APD officers and a 5% increase for all other regular permanent employees, which meets the "Just Economics" pledged living wage. Additionally, staff proposed doubling the shift differential from $0.75 to $1.50 per hour for night and weekend shifts, increasing on-call standby pay from $20 to $30 per day, and raising the city’s 401(k) employer match from 5% to 8% over three years to align with Buncombe County.

While Council members expressed strong support for the general direction of the compensation strategy, they debated specific figures. Regarding the shift differential, the Mayor and Council members indicated a preference for a higher rate of $3.00 per hour rather than the proposed $1.50. Similarly, the group discussed increasing on-call pay to $40 per day, up from the proposed $30. In response to these preferences, the City Manager confirmed that staff would re-run the financial models to determine if these higher rates could be funded within available resources.

City Manager Deborah Campbell emphasized the importance of retention over recruitment, stating, "The best recruitment strategy is a good retention strategy. A lot of what is recommended is around retention, not recruitment... We definitely need to keep the ones that we have." Finance Director Tony McDowell noted the constraints on resources, explaining, "The more of the resources that we use up for compensation, the less that would be available for other things." Council Member Kim Roney raised concerns about the long-term viability of the living wage pledge, noting that the "Just Economics" calculation relies on four-year-old housing cost data. She stated, "We're gonna be behind again next year... if we don't have a five-year projection and we're only going year by year, our pledge is going to be behind."

Staff also presented high-level results from the recent budget survey, which received approximately 2,200 valid responses. Key community interests identified in the survey included investment in community safety (specifically police recruitment), downtown development, water production and maintenance, and core infrastructure such as roads, sidewalks, and housing. Staff noted that while outreach was broad, the demographic data was less representative of the city’s population, with fewer respondents from Black, Hispanic, and Asian communities.

In the realm of capital planning, staff provided an update on the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP), highlighting three significant additions: McCormick Field, I-26 betterments, and critical repairs to the Municipal Building. A separate presentation covered the progress of a comprehensive facility study designed to assess the condition of city buildings, measure maintenance costs, and develop a 10-year capital forecasting tool. Capital Projects Director Jade Dundas explained that the seventh floor of City Hall was used as a "lay down area" for the elevator project and that while environmental abatement has been completed, the space is currently unfinished. Staff also noted that a General Obligation Bond referendum could potentially be held in the 2024 primary or general election, depending on the ballot.

Several follow-up actions were agreed upon during the session. The City Manager and Finance Director agreed to provide updated financial figures reflecting the Council’s interest in the $3.00 shift differential and $40 on-call pay at the next work session. Staff also agreed to provide a follow-up showing the specific impact on the city’s fund balance after accounting for the proposed compensation increases and other budget items. Additionally, the Capital Projects Director agreed to provide documentation and potentially schedule a tour regarding the status of the City Hall renovations, specifically the unfinished seventh floor. The next budget work session is scheduled for April 11, 2023, where operational needs and final compensation numbers will be discussed.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches