City Council Meeting
January 24, 2023 at 12:00 PM
- 2 h 20 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: January 24, 2023
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on January 24, 2023, addressing a range of administrative, public safety, and community development items. The session began with proclamations designating February 2023 as “Black History and Legacy Month” and February 4, 2023, as “Rosa Parks/Transit Equity Day.” The Council also approved the minutes from the previous formal meeting held on January 10, 2023.
Key Decisions and Votes
The Council adopted several items from the consent agenda unanimously, including an ordinance updating Appendix G of the Code of Ordinances to identify recreational facilities where concealed handguns are prohibited, a resolution authorizing the sale of one 2012 Autocar Garbage Truck deemed surplus, and a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Perses Consulting LLC for the Citywide Emergency Operations and the Continuity of Operations Plans. Additionally, the Council unanimously adopted a resolution authorizing the City Manager to enter into a contract with Walker Consultants for facility assessment and pre-design services for the Parking Garage Capital Repairs Project.
Following a public hearing, the Council unanimously approved a resolution to amend a previously approved conditional zoning approval (Ordinance No. 4853) for property located at 264 Enka Heritage Parkway. This amendment allows for site plan and layout changes for a light industrial/distribution development. The Council also unanimously adopted a resolution authorizing the City Manager to develop a scope of work for an official audit in response to the Community Reparations Commission’s recommendation to cease harm impacting the African American community.
In a 4-1 vote, with Council Member Kim Roney voting no, the Council passed a resolution authorizing the City Manager to execute an interlocal agreement with the Buncombe County Sheriff’s Office for the use of the FUSUS real-time criminal intelligence camera system. The agreement requires the City to pay $30,000 annually to the Sheriff’s Office, which will install three cameras on City properties. Finally, the Council unanimously affirmed the membership of the independent review committee established to analyze the recent water outage, appointing seven members including residential and commercial water customers, communications professionals, and public water systems subject matter experts. The purchase of four new 30-foot diesel buses for the Asheville Rides Transit System was tabled and rescheduled for the February 14, 2023, meeting.
Discussion Highlights
The FUSUS camera system agreement generated significant debate. Council Member Kim Roney expressed concern that the full agreement was provided late in the day, leaving insufficient time for review, and questioned why the item was not sent back to the Environment and Safety Committee for deeper discussion regarding internal policy for police access. Council Member Sage Turner emphasized the perspective of vulnerable community members who feel under-policed, while Council Member Sandra Kilgore highlighted the utility of the cameras for officers responding to 911 calls. Assistant City Manager Ben Woody clarified that the agreement is annual in nature and can be canceled with 30 days' written notice by either party.
Regarding the Community Reparations Commission audit, Council Member Antanette Mosley asked to ensure that the scope of work specifically includes race and gender, particularly regarding Black women. Presenter Brenda Mills noted that she had contacted every Commission member for feedback and that no major concerns were raised. On the water outage independent review committee, Council Member Kim Roney noted that one appointed member is a renter, which is important for communication concerns, and Council Member Sheneika Smith added that the Environment and Safety Committee is also moving forward on emergency management plans.
Community Input
Public commenters raised various concerns during the meeting. Regarding the FUSUS system, one commenter argued that the system opens a "Pandora's box" of AI surveillance and requested the Council vote "no" to allow for policy development. Another commenter expressed concern about the "slavery fingerprint" of electric bus batteries, suggesting biodiesel as an alternative, which contributed to the decision to table the bus purchase. During the zoning hearing for the Enka Commerce Park, a public commenter in support of the project noted that dense building construction attracts higher-wage jobs.
On the water outage committee, a public commenter expressed concern about the demographic makeup of the board, noting that only two women were nominated for customer seats while the rest were men with professional titles, and raised concerns about power dynamics. A representative from the Montford neighborhood spoke on behalf of residents regarding amplified musical events at the Hazel Robinson Amphitheater, citing concerns about noise, physical damage, and the precedent of commercial exploitation of city property; members did not respond to this comment. Additionally, a public commenter presented historical data showing that since 1931, African Americans have served only 8.6% of the total years of City Council service, and another commenter presented data from the book Homelessness is a Housing Problem, arguing that homelessness is primarily a housing supply issue.
Follow-ups
Assistant City Manager Ben Woody stated that the Sheriff’s Office policies regarding the FUSUS system are public records and can be provided to the public. Staff member Emily Ball stated that volunteers can sign up for the upcoming Point-in-Time Count by contacting her directly via the Homeless Strategy Division pages on the city website. The working group for Boards and Commissions stated that the survey regarding past service will close at the end of the month and that preliminary analysis will be brought to city staff and the public in February. The County Commission is scheduled to appoint the final two members of the water outage independent review committee at their first meeting in February and to adopt the reparations audit resolution on February 7.
Impact
These decisions impact residents through updated public safety measures, infrastructure maintenance, and community governance. The FUSUS agreement provides the Asheville Police Department with limited access to real-time camera footage, which staff indicated may aid in emergency response, though it remains a point of civic debate regarding privacy. The zoning approval for the Enka Commerce Park facilitates new industrial development, which staff stated is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan and supports economic growth. The reparations audit and the water outage review committee represent ongoing efforts to address historical inequities and improve utility reliability, with the audit funded by previously budgeted reparations funds and the review committee tasked with assessing the City’s response to the December 2022 water outages.
Meeting Video & Transcript