City Council - Asheville City Schools Board of Education Interviews
January 10, 2023 at 1:45 PM
- 56 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: January 10, 2023
The Asheville City Council convened on January 10, 2023, to conduct interviews for four candidates seeking a vacancy on the Asheville City Schools Board of Education. Mayor Esther Manheimer opened the session by clarifying the legal basis for the Council’s involvement, noting that while the body had previously passed legislation to transition the school board to an elected model, it was required to fill a vacancy created by a previously appointed member. Consequently, the Council interviewed the four individuals who ran for the board in the recent election but were not elected. No votes were taken during this portion of the meeting, as the interviews served as an informational step prior to the formal appointments.
During the interviews, Council members focused on several key themes, including strategies to close the achievement gap between African American and white students, as well as between male and female students. The discussion also centered on staff retention and pay, with members asking how the Board could advocate for higher wages for teachers, bus drivers, custodians, and cooks to address high cost-of-living and housing issues. Additionally, the Council inquired about the timeline and criteria for hiring a permanent superintendent, specifically whether to prioritize local candidates or conduct a national search, and emphasized the importance of listening to students, parents, and teachers in decision-making processes.
Candidate Jesse Warren, who highlighted his 25 years of military service and 15 years as a ROTC instructor at Asheville High, advocated for one-on-one tutoring to help students who fall behind. He argued that all education staff should receive higher pay to ensure retention, stating, "Our teachers should be one of the highest paying jobs around... We can get with the city representative and ask them for a bigger budget to pay and to keep the teachers." Warren suggested a timeline of 3–4 months to hire a new superintendent, ideally before the summer ends, and stated he would support any candidate appointed to the board.
Candidate William Young, a teacher and social worker, argued that the achievement gap starts at home and that the Board’s role is to encourage the Superintendent to engage families. He suggested adding teacher assistants to high schools to manage class sizes and support students who fall through the cracks. On the role of the Board, Young stated, "The school board per se, just like the city council, are not doing the hard work. They have to encourage the superintendent to encourage his teachers to encourage the families to do it." He also suggested looking at local educators in addition to a national search for the superintendent position. Council Member Kim Roney thanked Mr. Young for his years of service to the community in health and education.
A public commenter with 28 years of experience working with children, including in the Israeli Scouts and as an educational officer in the IDF, defined a "perfect school system" as one where kids feel heard, known, and seen. She prioritized investing in preschool, kindergarten, and summer camps to close early achievement gaps, stating, "I feel like it's not heard enough, and I would love to change that... I want them to be part of the process and not only always be the receivers of decisions." Another public commenter, who discussed eight years of advocacy beginning with concerns about special education treatment, expressed skepticism about rushing to hire a new superintendent, noting that the current interim superintendent provides stability. He detailed funding issues, pointing out that 53,000 of Asheville’s 93,000 residents live outside the legacy school district boundaries, and argued for legislative changes to expand the tax district to include commercial areas like the Asheville Mall. He described the district map as "like a moth-eaten doily... How homes are left out." Council Member Maggie Ullman thanked this public commenter for his well-known school advocacy and attendance at board meetings.
The Mayor noted that two Councilwomen were absent due to conflicts but confirmed the Council would proceed with the interviews. The appointments to the School Board were scheduled to be made at the regular City Council meeting held that same evening at 5:00 PM. This process is significant for residents as it determines the composition of the board responsible for overseeing local education policy, staff compensation, and district funding structures during the transition to an elected model.
Meeting Video & Transcript