Skip to main content

City Council ARPA Work Session

April 25, 2022 at 12:00 PM

  • 1 h 17 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council ARPA Work Session Recap: April 25, 2022

On April 25, 2022, the City Council held a work session to review staff recommendations for allocating remaining American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds. The meeting focused on the evaluation of 71 eligible applications received in response to a September 2021 Request for Proposals. Staff presented a draft list of 17 recommended subrecipients totaling approximately $9.8 million, a reduction from a previous shortlist of 19 due to new federal regulations and risk assessments. No formal votes were taken during this session, but the Council established consensus on several funding adjustments and directed staff to prepare final recommendations for a formal vote at the May 10, 2022, meeting.

Staff explained that the evaluation process utilized a robust scoring system weighted 40% for equitable community impact, 40% for project plan and evaluation, and 20% for organizational qualifications. ARPA Project Manager Kim Marmon-Sacks noted that the quality of submissions was unusually high, with many applicants scoring over 70 points. However, staff highlighted that recent Treasury rule amendments, particularly those released in April, introduced mandatory risk assessments focusing on fiscal and organizational capability. This regulatory change posed a challenge for newer or grassroots organizations that might lack the financial history required to pass the audit-based assessment, potentially disqualifying them despite high evaluation scores.

The Council discussed specific adjustments to the draft recommendations. Council members expressed majority support for increasing funding for HelpMate, a domestic violence shelter, from $1.5 million to the full $2 million request, as it met the new capital threshold justification requirements. Similarly, the Council supported increasing funding for the Mediation Center to the maximum allowable $750,000. Staff confirmed that $6 million of the remaining ARPA funds is being held back for projects outside the RFP process, such as Memorial Stadium and a low-barrier shelter, leaving approximately $2 million in the current allocation pool to be decided upon.

Regarding the "Modernization and Upgrade of Downtown Restrooms" item, which refers to the Portland Loo application, Council members debated whether to keep or remove the funding. Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith signaled support for removing the partial support to instead fund eviction legal aid, stating, "I would appeal to my colleagues to support application 44 for a fiscal legal [aid] to address eviction." Other members expressed a desire to seek alternative funding sources, such as from the Tourism Development Authority (TDA). No final decision was made to remove or keep the restroom item; it remains under consideration pending further research. In response to this discussion, Mayor Esther Manheimer stated she would meet later that day to explore other funding options for the downtown restrooms project.

Council members also examined the Pisgah Legal Services application, specifically for eviction legal aid. The Council signaled support for staff to review this application to determine its eligibility and potential funding level. Additionally, Council members expressed concern about the scale of the ABCCM Transformation Village project, noting a disparity between the 400 proposed beds and the local need of approximately 70 families. Mayor Manheimer questioned the local impact, asking, "if it's 400 beds you know that might you know I don't know what kind of impact that would have as opposed to, say, 50... So then what?" There was no motion to remove the project, but a request was made for further investigation into its local impact and exit strategy.

Staff and Council agreed to several follow-up actions prior to the May 10, 2022, meeting. The City Attorney’s office agreed to legally vet the Pisgah Legal Services application and any other items the Council wishes to add to ensure compliance with new Treasury rules. Staff will adjust the draft recommendations to reflect the increased funding for HelpMate and the Mediation Center. Furthermore, staff will continue to investigate the ABCCM Transformation Village project regarding its local versus regional service impact and the exit strategy for residents. Staff will incorporate this feedback to prepare final recommendations for a vote at the May 10, 2022, Council meeting.

This work session is significant for residents as it determines how federal pandemic recovery funds will be distributed to local organizations addressing housing, legal aid, and community services. The shift in federal rules has introduced new risks for smaller, grassroots organizations, potentially limiting their access to funds despite strong project plans. The Council’s focus on eviction legal aid and the scrutiny of large-scale housing projects reflect an effort to align funding with immediate local needs and ensure accountability in the use of federal resources.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches