City Council Budget Work Session – April 12, 2022
April 12, 2022 at 2:24 PM
- 2 h 4 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Key Decisions
The City Council held an informational budget work session on April 12, 2022, during which no final budget decisions were made and no votes were taken on substantive agenda items. The only recorded votes were procedural: Councilwoman Roney moved to allow Councilwoman Wisler to participate remotely due to illness, a motion seconded by Councilwoman Mosley that passed unanimously. Additionally, Councilwoman Kilgore moved for the adoption of the Consent Agenda, seconded by Vice-Mayor Smith, which also passed unanimously. At the request of the petitioner, Councilwoman Turner moved to continue a public hearing until May 24, 2022; this motion was seconded by Councilwoman Kilgore and passed.
Discussion Highlights
Staff presented a detailed analysis of the city’s unassigned fund balance, comparing Asheville’s 10-year history with other North Carolina cities. Director of Finance Tony McDowell explained that while the state requires a minimum 8% fund balance, Asheville maintains an internal policy of 15%, noting that other cities vary their balances based on specific risks such as hurricanes. The session also examined staffing and personnel costs, with McDowell noting that the general fund budget is approximately 61% personnel costs. He explained that the city typically budgets salaries at 98.5% to account for a 1.5% vacancy rate, but increased this assumption to 1.75% for the current year due to higher turnover. A Fire Department representative clarified that firefighters are scheduled for 56 hours a week in a three-shift system, resulting in automatic overtime pay for three hours weekly.
Regarding proposed fees and charges, staff reviewed changes previously recommended by the Finance Committee for water, stormwater, solid waste, and event/rental fees. These items are scheduled for a final vote by the full Council on April 26. The discussion also covered revenue shortfalls in the parking fund due to equipment issues and reduced usage, as well as challenges in the transit fund driven by labor shortages. Taylor Floyd, Budget Manager, noted that the transit service provider is using supervisors and maintenance staff to drive buses due to a driver shortage, which prevented the implementation of extended evening hours in October 2021.
A significant portion of the meeting focused on the funding strategy for the next phase of the Memorial Stadium project, estimated at approximately $4.4 million for a new running track and field upgrades. Staff recommended using $2.5 million in American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds, alongside $944,000 from the 2016 GO bond, $750,000 from CIP contingency, and $148,345 from unspent fleet replacement funds. McDowell stated that financial advisors indicated the city lacks the capacity to take on additional debt beyond the five-year Capital Improvement Plan. Mayor Esther Manheimer expressed the belief that Congress intended ARPA funds to scale up long-overdue infrastructure projects. Other council members questioned whether other projects were more important than the needs of a historic neighborhood that has waited over 30 years for this improvement, and requested a comparison of alternative funding options.
Follow-ups
Several staff members committed to providing additional information and analysis in the coming weeks. Tony McDowell agreed to provide a breakdown of the $1.125 million increase in APD costs, split between reduced overtime and increased hiring/personnel costs, as well as historical contribution amounts from the parking fund to the transit fund. He also agreed to provide a comparison of capital projects that would be displaced if the Memorial Stadium project were funded through debt or general fund balance instead of ARPA. Taylor Floyd agreed to provide an analysis of lost revenue and an "after-action" report regarding the failure to produce monthly transit passes in January, along with a monthly breakdown of missed bus trips. Ken, a parking and transit staff member, committed to determining if the transit contractor is a "second chance employer" and to providing data on the ratio of hourly parking spaces to monthly leased spaces. Jade Dundas, Capital Projects Director, stated that staff will bring a design contract and a budget amendment to the next council meeting to authorize the Memorial Stadium project scope and funding, and agreed to bring back recommendations for the TPDF grant process in priority order. The City Manager’s Office acknowledged responsibility for delayed communication regarding the parking equipment failure and stated that internal changes have been made to ensure such issues are communicated to the Council immediately in the future. Additionally, the City Attorney’s Office has been asked to review the parking and transit contracts for recourse regarding service failures.
Impact
This work session provided the Council with critical data on the city’s financial health, specifically regarding fund balance policies, personnel costs, and operational challenges in parking and transit. The detailed review of the Memorial Stadium funding strategy highlights the tension between utilizing one-time federal ARPA funds and the city’s limited capacity for additional debt. The upcoming schedule includes a budget work session and vote on fees on April 26, a public hearing on May 14, a proposed budget presentation on May 24, and budget adoption on May 28, with the budget required to be in place by July 1.
Meeting Video & Transcript