Skip to main content
  • 2 h 42 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: February 22, 2022

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on February 22, 2022, at the Harrah’s Cherokee Center - Asheville. The session included a budget worksession in the afternoon and a formal meeting in the evening. The council addressed a range of items, including routine administrative approvals, significant funding for affordable housing, zoning changes, and public comment on local issues.

Key Decisions and Votes

The council approved a series of routine items on the consent agenda, all passing with a 7-0 vote. These approvals included the minutes from the February 8, 2022, meeting; a resolution authorizing a five-year ground lease with Buncombe County for the continued operation of the Oakley Library at 749 Fairview Road; and a technical budget amendment of $40,431,180 in the Water Resources Operating Fund to account for the refunding of the 2018 Water Revenue Bond Anticipation Notes. The council also adopted ordinances and resolutions to incorporate the City’s Standard Specifications & Details Manual into the Code of Ordinances and the Unified Development Ordinance, and to authorize the City Engineer to make future revisions to the manual. Additionally, the council approved a $30,000 budget amendment from Brad Stanback for the purchase of 112 bear-resistant trash carts, amended the 2022 meeting schedule to add a worksession on open space standards on March 8 and an annual retreat on March 17–18, and authorized a new services contract with FusionSite Asheville, LLC, d/a/a Griffin Waste Services for portable toilets and handwashing stations.

One item was removed from the consent agenda for individual consideration: a budget amendment to transfer $1,000,000 from the Affordable Housing Capital Improvement Program to the Special Revenue Fund to fully fund the previously approved agreement with Step Up on Second Street Inc. This item passed with a 6-1 vote, with Councilwoman Antanette Mosley voting no.

In new business, the council considered a request from Haywood Street Community Development for $1.3 million in funding to purchase land and a $904,000 Housing Trust Fund loan to construct 45 permanently affordable rental homes at 343 and 357 West Haywood Street. The funding request passed with a 7-0 vote. However, the subsequent public hearing to conditionally zone the property from Community Business I to Community Business II/Conditional Zone failed with a 3-4 vote; Councilmembers Sandra Kilgore, Esther Manheimer, Antanette Mosley, and Sage Turner voted no.

The council also held a public hearing to consider conditionally zoning multiple properties at 363 Clingman Avenue, 32 Clingman Avenue, 99999 Clingman Avenue, 9999 Hilliard Avenue, and 9999 Pearl Street from the Central Business District to the Central Business Expansion District/Conditional Zone. This motion failed with a 2-5 vote; Councilmembers Kim Roney, Sheneika Smith, Esther Manheimer, Sage Turner, and Gwen Wisler voted no.

Finally, the council approved Ordinance No. 4929 on a 6-1 vote, allowing Blue Ridge Rickshaw to operate a pedi-cab transportation service in various areas within the City limits. Councilwoman Antanette Mosley was the sole vote against.

Discussion Highlights

During the budget worksession, staff provided updates on the Fiscal Year 2023 budget process, noting that while the city’s financial position is strong, maintaining existing service levels will require fee increases in water, stormwater, and sanitation due to inflation and compensation costs. Staff also outlined the Capital Improvement Plan, noting the city is 65% through its 2016 General Obligation bond work and that capital needs are increasing due to aging infrastructure.

In the formal meeting, Mayor Esther Manheimer announced that appointments to the reparations commission were moved to the next council meeting due to pending neighborhood nominations. She also recognized Councilwoman Antanette Mosley as a recipient of the annual Rosa Parks Award.

Regarding the Haywood Street affordable housing project, staff presented a total project budget of $10 million, which includes a $749,000 grant from Buncombe County and a $2 million grant from the Dogwood Health Trust. Councilmember Kim Roney expressed support for the project, sharing an anecdote about a young worker who cannot afford an apartment. Councilmember Sandra Kilgore asked how the project differs from public housing models, expressing concern that it might become a permanent housing situation rather than transitional. Mayor Manheimer responded that the analogy to public housing was incorrect, noting the project is more similar to nonprofit affordable housing builders.

Community Input

A public commenter spoke regarding the Oakley Library ground lease, noting it was a testament to the community that rallied to save the library from consolidation. The commenter urged the City to require outside consultants to contact community organizations for input before making recommendations.

Another public commenter criticized the police for enforcing a changed camp removal policy (immediate to 24 hours) before it was enacted, alleging the release of false data to justify crackdowns on unhoused individuals and activists. A third public commenter urged the council to adopt hybrid meeting technology to allow for spontaneous and remote participation, arguing that current sign-up requirements hinder democratic legitimacy.

Follow-ups

No specific follow-up actions were explicitly agreed to by members or staff during the recorded portions of the meeting. The reparations commission appointments were scheduled for the next council meeting.

Impact

These decisions impact residents in several ways. The approval of the Oakley Library lease ensures the continued operation of a key community resource. The incorporation of the Standard Specifications & Details Manual into the Code of Ordinances streamlines the process for future infrastructure projects. The funding for the Haywood Street affordable housing project represents a significant investment in permanent affordable housing, though the failure of the zoning vote means the project cannot proceed as planned until the zoning issue is resolved. The failure of the Clingman Avenue zoning change means the proposed development there will not move forward, and the developer must wait one year to reapply unless a substantial change is made. The approval of the pedi-cab service adds a new transportation option for residents and visitors.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches