Skip to main content

City Council Reparations Commission Interviews

February 15, 2022 at 1:15 PM

  • 4 h 7 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: February 15, 2022

Meeting Overview On February 15, 2022, the Asheville City Council held a virtual session to conduct informational interviews with candidates for the newly established Reparations Commission. Mayor Esther Manheimer opened the session by explaining that the full commission will consist of 25 members: five appointed by the City Council, five by the County Commissioners, and 15 selected by neighborhoods in areas with significant impact. The council interviewed candidates who discussed their backgrounds and proposed approaches to addressing systemic racism across five designated impact areas: criminal justice, economic development, education, healthcare, and housing.

Key Decisions No formal votes or motions were taken during the interview sessions, as the agenda consisted entirely of informational interviews. However, Mayor Manheimer confirmed that the council will make the final appointments to the Reparations Commission at the next City Council meeting on February 22, 2022, at 5:00 PM at Harris Cherokee. Additionally, staff member Brenda Mills reported that neighborhood representatives for the commission were due that evening or the next day, noting that Project Housing had already submitted three representatives while other neighborhoods were expected to submit their two representatives shortly.

Discussion Highlights The council interviewed a diverse group of candidates, each highlighting specific aspects of systemic inequity. Dr. Dwight Mullen, a retired UNCA professor, connected urban renewal directly to the current housing crisis, stating, "It’s a direct line, not just here in Asheville, but from every area that was affected by urban renewal we can find the same... Direct line between the destruction of the communities and the unrecordability of communities today." He also expressed skepticism regarding recent increases in reported Black median income, noting that he and the city’s IT department were "stunned" by the numbers and "refused to use them" due to a lack of faith in their accuracy.

Other candidates focused on specific sectors. Chantel Simpson, CEO of Appalachian Mountain Community Health Centers, emphasized the bidirectional relationship between health and wealth, stating, "I think by improving the health of Asheville residents, we’re definitely going to improve their whole life." a public commenter, a realtor, discussed the importance of educating residents on leveraging home equity to build generational wealth. Jackie Latek from the Spark Foundation highlighted the "catch-22" of criminal justice and employment, explaining, "You come out and, you know, you probably don’t have a driver’s license. You can’t get your driver’s license until you pay off your court fees, but you can’t pay off your court fees until you get a job, but you can’t get a job because you don’t have a driver’s license."

Dr. Tamari Macon, a faculty member at UNC Chapel Hill, discussed the ARC framework (Acknowledgement, Redress, Closure), arguing that solutions must be "perpetual and unending" to counteract intergenerational trauma. He suggested models where each commission member maintains direct communication with at least 10 community members to ensure accountability. Dee Williams, President/CEO of Eagles Wings Community Development Corporation, argued that the city lacks the "bandwidth" to implement full reparations and that the term may be legally vulnerable. She advocated for rebranding the effort as reinvestment in previously disinvested communities to avoid legal challenges under the Equal Protection Clause, stating, "Black folks need money. That is all this process is all about. It is about a wealth gap... The city does not have the bandwidth to do proper reparations. The only thing that it can do is reinvest in our community that’s been previously disinvested."

Community Input A public commenter shared the history of his grandparents’ grocery store, which was displaced by urban renewal in 1974. He noted that the city claimed the property was vital for redevelopment, yet the lot at Pfeiffer and Blanton streets remains undeveloped decades later. He argued that reparations must be intellectually and economically based rather than purely emotional, stating, "My grandfather... told me in 1974... 'There will never be anything built upon this land. This is just their way of removing the final Black business from the Black community.'... I have seen exactly what urban renewal did to the black community."

Follow-ups The Chair directed staff to strategize with county counterparts regarding the selection of alternates for each impact area, considering the logistical challenges of a large commission and the budget implications for paying alternates. Staff were also asked to coordinate with the Buncombe County Commission to ensure the combined team covers all necessary impact areas and to align on the use of alternates.

Impact This session serves as the primary mechanism for the City Council to select its five representatives to the Reparations Commission, a body Mayor Manheimer described as being "empowered to make short, medium, and long-term recommendations that will make significant progress toward repairing the damage caused by public and private systemic racism." The interviews provided insight into the specific challenges residents face, ranging from housing displacement and healthcare disparities to barriers in accessing capital for minority-owned businesses. The final appointments will be made at the February 22 meeting, determining the composition of the council's portion of the commission.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches