City Council Meeting
October 12, 2021 at 12:00 PM
- 3 h 2 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: October 12, 2021
The Asheville City Council held a formal meeting on October 12, 2021, conducted via simultaneous remote communication. The session addressed a consolidated consent agenda, received reports on equity initiatives, held public hearings on corridor studies and a major development project, and made appointments to several advisory boards.
Key Decisions
The Council unanimously (7-0) ratified the consent agenda items from the September 28, 2021 meeting and approved the current consent agenda for October 12. This included authorizing a contract with SEPI Engineering & Construction for the French Broad River Greenway West Project, a change order with WxProofing LLC for Harrah’s Cherokee Center Asheville, a Memorandum of Understanding with Duke-Progress Energy, and a change order with WK Dickson for the Neighborhood Enhancement Project Area 5. The Council also unanimously approved a contract with Appalachian Paving and Concrete, Inc. for Fiscal Year 2022 utility cut concrete repairs, the sale of a surplus 2006 Freightliner Knuckleboom, and an application for the NCDOT Apprenticeship Grant Program. Additionally, a $5,000 budget amendment was approved to accept donations for a bus shelter at Merrimon Avenue and Durwood Drive, and the Council ratified an amendment to the Transit Operations and Maintenance Contract with Asheville Transit Management, LLC, increasing the total contract value to $9,153,487.
In public hearings, the Council continued the adoption of Corridor Studies for Tunnel Road, Hendersonville Road, and Biltmore Avenue and McDowell Street to November 9, 2021, with each motion passing 7-0. For the development at 130 Charlotte Street (the former Fuddruckers site), the Council unanimously (7-0) approved a Land Use Incentive Grant (LUIG) for Kassinger Development Group. The Council also approved the conditional rezoning of the property from Community Business I District to Commercial Expansion - Conditional Zone; the recorded vote for this item was 7-0, though the motion included an amendment to extend the affordability period from 20 to 30 years.
Regarding Boards and Commissions, the Council unanimously (7-0) appointed David Bartholomew to the Homeless Initiative Advisory Committee. No applicants were received for the Board of Adjustment alternate seat, and the Clerk’s Office will readvertise the position.
Discussion Highlights
During the Manager’s Report on the Reparations Process, City Manager Deborah Campbell and Deborah Clark-Jones of TEQuity, LLC outlined the formation of a 25-member Community Reparations Commission. Council members discussed the nomination process, with Sandra Kilgore expressing concern that the timeline might be rushed. Sheneika Smith suggested creating a public list of contacts per neighborhood to ensure broader participation, and Kim Roney requested that Montford and Stumptown be explicitly named as impacted by urban renewal and redlining.
In the public hearing for 130 Charlotte Street, staff presented a project for 186 residential units, with 37 units (20%) designated as affordable for 30 years. Council members questioned the impact on traffic, buffering, and the relationship between the proposed building and the Charlotte Street Transition Overlay. Sage Turner noted the developer is a repeat partner and clarified rent figures, while Kim Roney asked for a commitment to review the effectiveness of the LUIG process. City Attorney Brad Branham explained that the grant is based on final taxable value, keeping the net fiscal impact neutral.
The Asheville City Schools Foundation provided a six-month update on the use of $474,592.56 in donated funds. Dr. Darius Stanley reported on the Black Educator Excellence Cohort and a perpetual scholarship for Black students pursuing education careers. Council members commented positively on the program’s execution, with Antanette Mosley noting it matched the Council’s hopes for the funds.
Community Input
During the public hearing for 130 Charlotte Street, several members of the public spoke. One commenter argued that the project does not conform to the Charlotte Street overlay and requested it be denied or put on hold until residents are engaged. Another public commenter expressed opposition to the project as it stands, urging the Council to vote no. A third commenter discussed concerns regarding traffic noise, wildlife communication interference, and pedestrian safety. Gary Davis, the applicant’s attorney, also spoke, arguing that conditional zoning cannot override overlay district standards under the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) and that the proposed building would be significantly larger and taller than permitted in the transition overlay.
Follow-ups
Deborah Clark-Jones of TEQuity, LLC agreed to include a list of individuals to contact per neighborhood in the public announcement for the Community Reparations Commission on October 18, 2021, and to share it during information sessions. She also stated that TEQuity will make necessary timeline adjustments if neighborhood groups indicate they need more time. The Clerk’s Office agreed to readvertise the Board of Adjustment alternate seat.
Impact
These decisions impact residents through continued infrastructure maintenance, transit service stability, and the development of affordable housing. The approval of the 130 Charlotte Street project will result in 186 new housing units, including 37 affordable units, on a 2.34-acre site, with an estimated tax value of nearly $27 million upon completion. The continuation of the corridor studies to November 9, 2021, allows for further planning on major transportation routes. The reparations process update marks a significant step in the City’s equity initiatives, with the commission formation process beginning in late October.
Meeting Video & Transcript