Skip to main content
  • 3 h 4 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: September 28, 2021

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on September 28, 2021, conducted via simultaneous communication. The agenda included the approval of minutes from the previous meeting, several contract resolutions, a report on the Climate Justice Initiative, and multiple public hearings regarding land use and zoning changes.

Key Decisions The Council unanimously approved the minutes from the formal meeting held on September 14, 2021. The Council also unanimously adopted four resolutions authorizing the City Manager to enter into or modify contracts:

  • A contract with SEPI Engineering & Construction for the French Broad River Greenway West Project.
  • A change order with WxProofing LLC for the Harrah’s Cherokee Center Asheville - Window Replacement & Concrete Repairs project.
  • A Memorandum of Understanding and Right of Entry agreement with Duke-Progress Energy to explore a property exchange for the downtown electrical substation.
  • A Change Order with WK Dickson for the Neighborhood Enhancement Project Area 5 professional services contract.

In land use matters, the Council voted on several public hearings:

  • Urban Place Form District (UDO Amendment): The motion to amend the Unified Development Ordinance to establish a new Urban Place Form District passed 4-2. Councilwomen Sandra Kilgore and Antanette Mosley voted no. Mayor Esther Manheimer recused herself from this vote.
  • Urban Place Form District (Rezoning): The motion to rezone approximately 122 acres of property to the new Urban Place Form District passed 4-2. Councilwomen Sandra Kilgore and Antanette Mosley voted no. Mayor Esther Manheimer recused herself from this vote.
  • 70 Mills Gap Road: The motion to conditionally rezone the property from Industrial and RS-2 zones to Residential Expansion/Conditional Zone passed 6-1. Councilwoman Gwen Wisler voted no.
  • Homestays (UDO Amendment): The Council unanimously voted to continue the public hearing on amendments to Articles II and XVI of the UDO regarding homestays until December 14, 2021.
  • 101 Charlotte Street: The applicant withdrew the request for a land use incentive grant.
  • Charlotte Street/East Chestnut Street/Baird Street/Furman Avenue: The applicant withdrew the request for conditional rezoning of multiple properties to the Commercial Expansion/Conditional Zone.

Discussion Highlights City staff presented an update on the Climate Justice Initiative, which is transitioning from Phase 1 to Phase 2. Phase 1 included listening sessions with BIPOC leaders and story circles in four neighborhoods. Staff presented a "Climate Justice Data Map" and a working definition of climate equity. The goal of Phase 2 is to develop a "Climate Justice Screening Tool" for use in city planning and policy implementation.

Regarding the Urban Place Form District, staff explained that the new zoning tool aims to implement the Living Asheville Comprehensive Plan by encouraging higher-density, mixed-use, walkable development aligned with transit investments. Key code elements include build-to zones, reduced setbacks, and height bonuses for affordable housing. Councilwoman Sage Turner expressed support for the urban centers concept but acknowledged concerns about impacts on legacy neighborhoods, suggesting the city could implement the code and revisit it in six months. Councilwoman Sandra Kilgore asked if the word "accessible" should be added to the purpose statement regarding streets; staff agreed it was a word choice issue. Councilwoman Antanette Mosley asked about gentrification impacts on the East End, and staff noted the city is working on anti-displacement strategies.

For the 70 Mills Gap Road project, a 73-unit residential development on a steep site, discussion focused on environmental mitigation and private infrastructure. Staff explained that while sewer and water will connect to City systems, internal roads, stormwater management, and water distribution will be privately owned and maintained by the homeowners association due to the site’s topography. Councilwoman Gwen Wisler expressed concern that if the homeowners association fails to maintain these utilities, property owners would be stuck with significant costs. Staff responded that the City cannot maintain private roads or non-standard water distribution systems but expressed confidence that a 73-owner HOA could manage the maintenance.

Community Input Public comment was accepted via voicemail, email, and advanced live sign-ins.

  • Urban Place Form District: Several public commenters opposed the amendment and the rezoning. A representative for Ingalls Markets argued the code is not ready and fails to account for physical constraints. A planner argued the draft ordinance ignores market forces and site constraints. A real estate appraiser stated the district would negatively affect property values. A lawyer for American Finance Trust argued the proposal is a "down zoning" that takes away vested rights. In support, a resident from West Asheville cited the severe affordable housing crisis, and a representative for the Coalition of Asheville Neighborhoods thanked staff for negotiating changes to mitigate impacts on adjacent residential neighborhoods.
  • 70 Mills Gap Road: Public commenters raised concerns about the privately owned infrastructure.
  • Informal Discussion: A resident spoke to defend Councilwoman Antanette Mosley against a recent Asheville Blade article criticizing her statements regarding police defunding. Mayor Esther Manheimer responded, stating, "There should be no controversy concerning the appointment of Ms. Mosley. It was on point. We fill the vacancies on council with the same level of specificity that we elect our council members. It's codified in our charter." Another public commenter, Pastor Hardaway of Rockett Mission Baptist Church, urged the Council to move quickly on the implementation of reparations, citing the risk of political changes. Members did not respond to this comment.

Follow-ups

  • Climate Justice Initiative: Staff stated they will return to Council in January 2022 to present the Final Report and the Climate Justice Screening Tool.
  • Homestay Ordinance: The public hearing on the UDO amendment regarding homestays will resume on December 14, 2021.
  • Affordable Housing Unit Type: The applicant’s attorney for the 70 Mills Gap Road project stated that the type of the five affordable units (single-family vs. townhome) would be determined as the project proceeds, provided the 80% Area Median Income restriction is met, as the Council did not specify a preference during the vote.
  • Transit Service: Mayor Esther Manheimer noted that the City is working on increasing transit service frequency and hours to South Asheville, specifically mentioning the S3 and S6 routes that serve the newly approved development area.

Impact The adoption of the Urban Place Form District and the rezoning of approximately 122 acres to this district marks a significant shift in the city’s zoning approach, aiming to create denser, walkable urban centers along transit corridors. This change may influence future development patterns and housing availability in the affected areas, including the Merriman Avenue, Tunnel Road, Bleachery Boulevard, and former SEER site nodes. The approval of the 70 Mills Gap Road project adds 73 new housing units, including five affordable units, to the South Asheville area. The contract resolutions ensure the continuation of infrastructure projects, including the French Broad River Greenway extension and repairs to the Harrah’s Cherokee Center, while the Duke Energy agreement facilitates the potential reconstruction of the downtown electrical substation, which may impact parking and property use near the Civic Center.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches