City Council Meeting
April 13, 2021 at 12:00 PM
- 1 h 47 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
City Council Meeting Recap: April 13, 2021
The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on April 13, 2021, via simultaneous communication. The agenda included the approval of prior minutes, a series of consent items, financial reports, strategic updates, and votes on new business items including affordable housing loan modifications and board appointments.
Key Decisions The Council approved the minutes from the March 23, 2021 meeting. By motion, the Council adopted the consent agenda, which included ordinances amending Section 16-39 of the Code of Ordinances and the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Fees & Charges Manual to exempt City capital projects from public right-of-way cut permit fees. The Council also adopted resolutions authorizing the City Manager to enter into an interlocal agreement with Buncombe County for renewable energy feasibility assessments, a technical budget amendment appropriating $11,923,074.25 from restricted and assigned fund balances for carry-over appropriations, and to apply for Federal Transit Administration (FTA) CRRSAA grant funds. A budget amendment of $60,153 was adopted to budget the FTA CRRSAA Grant Funds. Additionally, the Council adopted a resolution approving donations of unused and unclaimed settlement funds to the Asheville City Schools Foundation and CoThinkk in equal amounts, a resolution for a Memorandum of Understanding with Buncombe County for COVID-19 vaccination assistance, a motion to revise the Fiscal Year 2021-22 Budget Calendar to include a worksession on April 27, 2021, and a resolution to accept funding from Dogwood Health Trust for the Code Purple Emergency Shelter.
On new business, the Council passed a resolution to amend the City’s 2020-21 Annual Action Plan to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development by a vote of 6 ayes and 0 nays. The Council also passed a budget amendment to increase the Fiscal Year 2020-21 Community Development Block Grant Fund budget by $1.6 million from the sale of city-owned land, with all seven voting members voting aye. A resolution approving a loan modification requested by Mountain Housing Opportunities was passed unanimously (7 ayes). For board appointments, the Council reappointed Amy Kemp and appointed Andrew Emory to the Audit Committee by a vote of 6-1 (Gwen Wisler voted no). The Council unanimously appointed Wendy Tabb to the Board of Adjustment (Alternate), reappointed Dee Williams and Lynn Smith to the Mountain Community Capital Fund Committee, and appointed Shirley Whitesides to the Public Art & Cultural Commission.
Discussion Highlights During the Financial Audit Presentation, staff reported that the City received an unmodified, "clean" audit opinion for Fiscal Year 2020. However, a material weakness was identified in internal controls related to year-end closeout procedures, exacerbated by staff turnover in the Finance Department. The Director of Finance noted that key positions, including Controller, Financial Reporting Manager, and Finance Director, have been filled, and the City is developing checklists and guidelines to improve the closeout process.
In the Manager’s Report, the City Manager presented updates on the City’s strategic priorities, including a 25 percent increase in transit services and the upcoming opening of the 360 Hill Yard affordable housing development. Assistant City Manager Kathy Ball provided an update on homelessness, noting that while shelter capacity exists, many individuals choose not to use it. She outlined short-term solutions using American Recovery Plan funds, including the operation of the Code Purple shelter and partnerships for encampment removal.
Regarding the HUD Annual Action Plan amendment, Council Member Kim Roney stated she had difficulty voting yes but chose to do so, citing obligations to address the harms of urban renewal and redlining while avoiding displacement. Vice Mayor Sheneika Smith cited the need to meet the HUD timeliness test as a reason for voting aye.
Community Input During the informal discussion and public comment period, several members of the public spoke regarding homelessness and encampment removals. Commenters from West Asheville, North Asheville, and downtown expressed concern over the removal of encampments, describing them as violent and destabilizing. They argued that shelters are at capacity or have barriers to entry, such as ID requirements or pet surrender, and called for an eviction moratorium and increased investment in housing and healthcare rather than police enforcement. One commenter from downtown urged Council members to visit encampments to understand residents and asked if the City had consulted Deaverville residents regarding the Ford Street property. No Council members responded directly to these comments during the recorded portion of the meeting.
Follow-ups The Director of Finance stated that the City is working to develop checklists and guidelines for the year-end closeout process to ensure timely and accurate data submission to the Public Works Department, and is exploring the possibility of contracting with an outside firm to help develop those guidelines. He also stated the City is evaluating remaining vacancies in the finance department to potentially bolster staff in the financial reporting area.
Impact These decisions impact residents through changes in how City capital projects are funded, the allocation of federal and state grant funds for transit and affordable housing, and the management of the City’s financial reserves. The loan modification for Mountain Housing Opportunities ensures the continued affordability of 22 units by extending the affordability period by 20 years, though it results in an estimated $25,000 annual loss in interest income for the City. The appointment of new members to the Audit Committee, Board of Adjustment, and other boards will shape future oversight and planning decisions. The revision of the budget calendar to include a worksession on April 27, 2021, indicates that further discussion on the Fiscal Year 2021-22 budget, including priorities for reparations, public safety, and compensation, will occur at that time.
Meeting Video & Transcript