City Council Retreat – Day 2 Afternoon
April 1, 2021 at 12:56 PM
- 3 h 54 minlength
Event Recap
Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages
Meeting Overview
On April 1, 2021, the Asheville City Council held the afternoon session of its strategic planning retreat. The primary focus of this closed-door session was to refine the Council’s strategic priorities for 2021 and establish behavioral agreements to improve team health and communication. The Council worked to consolidate a broad list of potential strategic areas into a manageable set of top priorities, ensuring that new goals were layered onto existing city operations rather than starting from scratch.
Key Decisions
The Council engaged in a ranking exercise to identify its top strategic priorities for the year, resulting in the selection of four primary areas:
- Reparations (7 votes)
- Implementing COVID-19 Relief Spending (7 votes)
- Reimagining Public Safety (6 votes)
- Implementing Employee Compensation Study (5 votes)
Several other items were reclassified or removed from the top-level priority list based on consensus:
- Housing: Received 3 votes but was removed as a standalone top priority; its components (such as shelter and wraparound services) were integrated into the other selected categories.
- Climate Emergency: Removed from the top-level "Critical Few" list because staff confirmed these areas are already operationalized through existing plans, such as the Food Action Plan and Tree Ordinance.
- City Cleanup: Placed under the COVID Relief/Federal Dollars category, acknowledging that federal funds may be the mechanism for addressing the issue.
- NLC Economic Mobility Report: Removed from the active priority list as it is no longer considered a value-add for staff resources.
- Participatory Budgeting/Engagement Ambassadors: Moved under the "Reimagining Public Safety" or "Connected and Engaged Community" categories to reduce competition for resources.
- County and Community Partnerships: Removed as a standalone priority, as partnering is viewed as a tactic used across multiple strategies rather than a strategy itself.
- Land Use and Partnership with Asheville City Schools: Received zero votes for top priority status.
Additionally, the Council verbally affirmed its commitment to moving forward with the Employee Compensation Study and adopted several team health agreements, including honoring one’s word, avoiding triangulation, providing feedback early and privately, and avoiding surprises for staff.
Discussion Highlights
A central theme of the discussion was the relationship between new strategic priorities and existing city operations. One Council member used the metaphor of a "battleship," noting that with 1,250 staff members already moving in a specific direction, new priorities must be layered onto existing efforts, such as the 2036 vision, rather than ignoring current work.
The Council debated the placement of various initiatives. For instance, while "Housing" was initially considered, staff and Council agreed that many housing-related bullet points were already being addressed under other categories like Reimagining Public Safety and Reparations. Regarding public safety, the group discussed reimagining safety measures, 911 consolidation, and crisis low-barrier shelter.
Communication strategy was a significant point of discussion. Facilitators emphasized the importance of language and distinguishing between "new" strategic priorities and ongoing operational work to avoid the public perception that only new items are being addressed. One facilitator noted, "Language is really important... What you call things really does shape reality." Another facilitator urged the Council to focus on the "Law of Focus," asking them to identify the three areas they would direct staff to advance daily.
During the team health segment, the Council discussed the difficulty of managing public criticism and internal dynamics. One Council member shared that being surprised by documents before meetings was upsetting, and another advised giving staff time to react to difficult questions respectfully. The Mayor closed the session by stating, "I think this has been one of our best retreats ever... it came, I should have trusted more, and it happened, and that was great."
Follow-ups
Staff members agreed to several specific actions to support the newly identified priorities:
- Staff agreed to develop a communication strategy to clearly distinguish between "New Strategic Priorities" and "Operationalized/Ongoing Work" for public reporting.
- Staff agreed to locate the Climate Emergency Resolution and confirm the status of the 17 items within it to help the Council decide on the climate priority.
- Public Works staff agreed to pull a team together to address city cleanup and trash issues, potentially utilizing federal COVID funds.
- Staff agreed to provide a report on the status of the Transit Master Plan implementation.
- Staff agreed to return with a detailed work plan, including timelines and cost estimates, for the selected priorities, which will be presented through the budget process.
- Staff proposed to include a summary of the retreat’s outcomes in the City Manager’s report at the next regular Council meeting on April 13.
- Staff and Council agreed to schedule a specific work session in April to flesh out the details of the COVID-19 relief spending.
- Staff noted that the partnership with Asheville City Schools, which did not make the top four, will be revisited on April 13 to determine if the Council wishes to proceed with it as an ongoing item.
Impact
This retreat establishes the strategic direction for the City of Asheville for the upcoming year. By narrowing the focus to four primary areas—Reparations, COVID-19 Relief, Public Safety, and Employee Compensation—the Council aims to ensure that staff resources are concentrated on high-impact initiatives. The decision to integrate housing and climate goals into existing operational frameworks rather than creating new standalone priorities reflects a commitment to leveraging current city operations. The adoption of team health agreements is intended to improve internal collaboration and communication between the Council and staff, which is expected to streamline the implementation of these new priorities.
Meeting Video & Transcript