Skip to main content
  • 2 h 7 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

The City of Asheville City Council held a formal meeting on October 27, 2020, which was conducted via simultaneous communication. The agenda included a worksession on proposed hotel development regulations, a consent agenda, public hearings on federal funding and zoning, votes on unfinished business, and new business items including several new city policies.

Key Decisions The Council voted on a resolution to suspend the sale or change in zoning use of any City property acquired through urban renewal until further policy direction is reviewed, with specific exemptions for properties under contract with White Labs, Inc. and Haywood Street Congregation. This resolution passed 6-1, with Councilman Brian Haynes voting no. The Council also voted to adopt the Haywood & Page Concept Plan, the City of Asheville Business Inclusion Policy, and a zero-net loss urban tree canopy policy, all of which passed unanimously (7-0).

In the consent agenda, the Council unanimously (7-0) approved the minutes from the October 13, 2020 meeting and authorized the City Manager to execute a 90-day extension of contracts with Homeward Bound of Western North Carolina, Red Roof Inn Inc., and Axis Security to sustain a non-congregate shelter for persons experiencing homelessness. This was accompanied by a budget amendment of $680,664 in the Special Revenue Fund, funded by expected Federal Emergency Management Agency reimbursement. The Council also unanimously approved a resolution to sign a U.S. Geological Survey form to name two tributaries as Masters Branch and Haith Branch, a design services contract amendment with Clark Nexsen for the aquatic facility at the Dr. Wesley Grant Sr. Southside Center, a sole source contract with Solutionz Inc. for City Hall audiovisual upgrades, a technical budget amendment of $15,000 for a TV broadcast server, and a contract with Moore and Son Site Contractors, Inc. for The District Sidewalk Project. Additionally, the Council unanimously amended the 2020 Meeting Schedule to delete the formal meeting on November 24, 2020, and authorized the City Manager to apply for a grant from the N.C. Dept. of Environmental Quality for backyard composting.

For unfinished business, the Council unanimously (7-0) approved an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning approval for property at 236 Charlotte Street and 336 Hillside Street. The Council also unanimously approved two sets of amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) to align with recent state legislation: one for Articles II, III, V, VIII, and VIX related to Historic Preservation, and another for Articles II, XII, and XVIII.

Regarding public hearings, the Council unanimously (7-0) recessed the hearing on the 2020-21 Action Plan update (involving $154,711 in CDBG contingency funds and approximately $1.1 million in HOME funds) until November 10, 2020. The Council also unanimously recessed the hearing on the 2019-20 Action Plan update (involving $889,456 in CDBG-CV funds) until November 10, 2020. Finally, the Council unanimously continued the public hearing on the UDO amendment to update open space requirements to November 10, 2020.

Discussion Highlights During the consent agenda, Mayor Esther Manheimer provided context regarding the urban renewal resolution, explaining that proceeds from the portion of the White Labs property acquired with federal funds are restricted by HUD guidelines to be used for low- and moderate-income community benefits. She noted that Council had already voted in closed session to earmark some proceeds for the transit station expansion and suggested that the unrestricted portion of the funds could be discussed for future allocation, potentially including a reparations fund. Councilman Brian Haynes asked what would prevent the council from committing general fund money to a reparations fund instead. Assistant City Manager Kathy Ball responded that CDBG funds are restricted to low- and moderate-income populations based on income, not race, and cannot be specifically earmarked for Black community members. Councilwoman Julie Mayfield noted that the Housing Trust Fund is nearly depleted and that there are immediate needs for affordable housing, suggesting a conversation about how to allocate the unrestricted funds between immediate housing needs and a reparations commitment.

Regarding the Business Inclusion Policy, Councilwoman Mayfield commented on the expiration of the race/gender-conscious provisions in 2023 unless a new disparity study is conducted, noting the cost of such studies and that it would be a decision for future councils.

In informal discussion, Councilman Haynes discussed record-high national and worldwide COVID-19 cases, suggesting the city and county consider reimposing stricter guidelines than current statewide requirements, specifically regarding hotel occupancy and restaurant/bar restrictions. He stated, "I really feel like we've reached that point and that we need to seriously have that discussion," and noted, "It is within our power to have further restrictions beyond what the state is recommending." Mayor Manheimer responded, "I will be glad to connect back and see if considering the numbers that we are seeing in the state of North Carolina, whether they're making recommendations to do that." She added, "Unless we're preempted, we can do that."

Community Input Multiple public commenters urged the council to redirect the proceeds from the White Labs property sale into a reparations fund rather than the general fund, arguing that the land was acquired through urban renewal and redlining. In response, Mayor Manheimer explained the complex title history and HUD restrictions, while Councilman Haynes voted "No" on the resolution, citing his agreement with the callers' concerns.

A public commenter representing the Vision Implementation Committee urged the council to vote "yes" on the Haywood and Page Concept Plan, highlighting the success of the collaborative process. Another resident celebrated the plan but urged the council to ensure the community garden space is adequately valued. Councilwoman Mayfield thanked the design team, and Councilman Haynes reiterated the importance of supporting the Elder and Sage community garden, noting that staff would work with garden leaders during detailed design.

Public commenters on the Business Inclusion Policy urged the council to create separate metrics for women-owned and Black/Brown-owned businesses and to consider LGBTQ+ certification. Councilwoman Mayfield responded by noting the 2023 expiration of race/gender-conscious provisions.

Other public comments included concerns that CDBG funds are disproportionately going to white-led nonprofits, criticism of the requirement to pre-register to speak, and a local clergy member highlighting the epidemic of gun and gang violence in Asheville. A public commenter discussed the lack of community engagement regarding equity in the city’s charter changes, calling it a "huge mistake." Another public commenter expressed gratitude for virtual meeting accessibility but raised concerns about commenters being cut off and requested live public comment. No member responded to the specific comments on equity/charter or virtual meetings.

Follow-ups Mayor Manheimer explicitly agreed to connect with the Department of Health and Human Services to check for recommendations regarding stricter COVID-19 guidelines.

Impact The adoption of the Business Inclusion Policy and the zero-net loss urban tree canopy policy establishes new frameworks for equitable contracting and environmental stewardship, with the tree canopy policy setting a goal of 50% coverage by 2040. The suspension of urban renewal property sales allows the City to develop a policy aligned with its reparations resolution before further transactions occur. The continuation of the homeless shelter contracts ensures ongoing support for persons experiencing homelessness during the pandemic. The recessing of the CDBG and HOME fund hearings to November 10, 2020, allows for further written comments before final approval of these federal fund allocations.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches