Skip to main content
  • 1 h 41 minlength

Event Recap

Sunshine AI summary of the meeting video and documents. How we make these pages

City Council Meeting Recap: October 13, 2020

The Asheville City Council held a regular meeting on October 13, 2020, conducted via simultaneous communication. The agenda included the approval of minutes from the September 22, 2020 meeting, several resolutions and budget amendments, a manager’s report on the city’s response to the Black Asheville Demands coalition, public hearings on housing and zoning, and a work session on proposed hotel development regulations.

Key Decisions and Votes

The Council voted to approve the consent agenda, which included the minutes from the September 22, 2020 meeting, and several resolutions and budget amendments. All consent items passed unanimously (7-0). These actions included:

  • Climate Justice Initiative: Authorization to accept $15,000 in grant funds from the Urban Sustainability Directors Network (USDN) and a corresponding budget amendment.
  • Verizon Wireless: Authorization to sign an amendment extending the license agreement for the Royal Pines cell tower at 57 Crestwood Drive until September 30, 2022.
  • Water Infrastructure: Authorization to execute a change order with Brown & Caldwell for the installation of clearwell baffles at the North Fork Water Treatment Plant.
  • Transit Improvements: A budget amendment of $1,250,000 (including $1.0 million from the Federal Transit Administration) for bus stop improvements.
  • Lead Prevention: Authorization to execute a three-year service contract with 120Water for the Lead Education and Prevention Program.
  • Stormwater Easement: Authorization for the City Attorney’s Office to condemn a stormwater easement over real property at 2 Springdale Road.
  • Parking Data: Authorization to renew the existing contract with Smarking Inc. for real-time and predictive parking data.

In unfinished business, the Council voted on two zoning-related items:

  • Gayle Street: The Council passed a resolution (7-0) to close a portion of an unopened right-of-way known as Gayle Street.
  • Coxe/Asheland/Federal Alley: The Council passed a resolution (6-0, with one abstention by Mayor Esther Manheimer) to consider an amendment to a previously approved conditional zoning for a mixed-use development. Mayor Manheimer recused herself from this vote.

Discussion Highlights

Manager’s Report: 30/60/90 Day Work Plan City Manager Debra Campbell presented an update on the city’s response to the Black Asheville Demands coalition regarding racial justice and economic inclusion. Key updates included:

  • Vance Monument: A joint task force with the County Commission is meeting weekly and hopes to make a recommendation to City Council and the County Commission on November 19.
  • Reimagining Public Safety: Campbell shared survey data indicating that while most respondents felt the Asheville Police Department (APD) has an important role in violent crime, they believed nuisance calls and public health calls should be handled through partnerships with other city departments and community organizations.
  • Restorative Justice: The City Attorney’s Office is meeting with the District Attorney’s Office and community groups to provide feedback on the probation decision for Mr. Hickman.
  • Harm-Free Zones: The legal department is working with local police-affiliated organizations and the civil service board. Campbell noted that final approval for these zones must come from the state.
  • Recruitment and Retention: Human Resources is working on strategies to recruit people of color and prioritize retention.
  • Race and Gender Conscious Policy: A policy responding to the disparity study in city contracting was approved by the Planning and Economic Development Committee and is scheduled for full Council consideration on October 27.

Guest Presentation: Learning Pods and Internet Access Shonda Sanford (Director of Resident Services, Housing Authority; Board Chair, Asheville City Schools) and Kadada Winn (Executive Director of Student Support Services, Asheville City Schools) presented on "PODs" (Positive Opportunities to Develop Success).

  • PODs: These are learning environments with no more than 10 students per pod. Currently, 11 sites are open, serving over 200 students, primarily Black and Brown children. The pods provide remote learning support, enrichment activities, and free after-school care until 6:00 PM.
  • Challenges: The primary barrier to expanding the pods is staffing, not space. There is a waitlist of approximately 200 students.
  • Internet Access: A representative from the Housing Authority discussed efforts to provide internet access to all households in public housing. He noted that while the city and county are involved, the cost is estimated at $8 per household per month. The Housing Authority is working with the school system and other groups to raise funds for the first year of service.

Public Hearings

  • HUD Five-Year Consolidated Action Plan: The hearing was continued to November 10, 2020.
  • Hildy’s House (JCC) Zoning Amendment: City Planner Shannon Tuck presented an amendment to the 2017 conditional zoning for the Asheville Jewish Community Center (JCC). The changes include closing a right-of-way (Lenox Court) to match current conditions and renovating Hildy’s House (the infant care facility) to improve accessibility, safety, and licensing compliance. The hearing was recessed to October 27, 2020, for a final vote.
  • Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) Amendments: Two amendments were presented to align the city’s development code with new state legislation (160D). One amendment relates to historic preservation (changing appeals from the Board of Adjustment to Superior Court), and the other relates to enforcement and definitions. Both hearings were recessed to October 27, 2020.
  • 2020-2021 Action Plan Update: The hearing was continued to October 27, 2020, to update the plan with CDBG contingency funds and CDBG-CB funds for coronavirus response.

Hotel Development Regulations Work Session Director of Planning & Urban Design Todd Okolichany presented key takeaways from the hotel development study. Staff proposed three key regulatory elements: a Hotel Overlay District, a Public Benefits points-based system, and updated Design Review guidelines. Due to time constraints, Council agreed to continue the worksession on October 27, 2020, at 2:30 p.m. No public comment was accepted at this session.

Community Input

Three residents signed up to speak during the informal discussion and public comment period.

Commenter 1 (from Montfort):

  • Reimagining Public Safety Survey: The commenter criticized the survey data, noting it received input from 3,231 white people and only 221 Black people, arguing the process failed to engage the Black community.
  • Equity Department: The commenter expressed concern that the Director of Equity and Inclusion resigned two months after the Council passed a reparations resolution, and there was no plan for replacement.
  • Public Comment Process: The commenter criticized the requirement to pre-register 29 hours in advance to speak, arguing it is not reasonable or equitable and excludes those without flexible time.
  • Requests: The commenter asked the Council to change the public comment rules back to open dial-in, direct the City Manager to start replacing the Equity Director, and admit the survey failed to engage the Black community.
  • Member Reply: Council member Julie Mayfield asked the City Manager to confirm the demographic statistics. City Manager Debra Campbell responded, "What I do know is that the number of respondents was significantly different for Blacks in the questionnaire that actually filled out the demographics... I will definitely confirm that and email you all." Campbell also noted, "I would like to say also, though, that we did have a significant number of blacks who participated in the virtual conversation." Mayor Manheimer added, "Well, I mean, that is a problem you pointed out. If folks don't fill out the demographics... it's just a little hard to track when you're trying to get community input."

Commenter 2 (from East Asheville):

  • Voter Registration: The commenter congratulated Councilwoman Mosley and discussed the importance of registering to vote. They noted that the outgoing Equity and Inclusion Director, Kimberly Archie, never registered to vote in Asheville despite serving for three years.
  • Electoral System: The commenter argued that the at-large voting system is a "throwback to Jim Crow oppression" and asked that the next Equity Director prioritize evaluating the electoral system.
  • Member Reply: Members did not respond.

Commenter 3 (from East End Valley area):

  • Reparations and Property: The commenter discussed a property on Curve Street where an 88-year-old former slave, W.L. Boss, was interviewed. They suggested that in considering reparations, the city should consider leaving that specific property in Black hands.
  • Public Comment Process: The commenter agreed with the first commenter that the pre-registration requirement is difficult and suggested returning to the previous open dial-in system.
  • Member Reply: Members did not respond.

Follow-Ups

  • City Manager Debra Campbell agreed to confirm the demographic data from the Reimagining Public Safety survey and email the Council.
  • City Manager Debra Campbell stated that the process for hiring a new Director of Equity and Inclusion is underway, with the job description expected to be completed in the next two to three weeks. She confirmed the position is not subject to the hiring freeze.
  • City Manager Debra Campbell stated that a review of the Equity and Inclusion Department’s accomplishments and challenges (referred to as an "audit" by the Mayor, but clarified by Campbell as a review of accomplishments/challenges) will be completed in early November and presented to the Council.
  • City Attorney Brad Branham stated that the city is reviewing engineering models regarding the Crossroads Project (a development near the Hominy Creek Greenway) and expects results within 24 hours to determine the city’s position.
  • Vice Mayor Gwen Wisler asked the City Manager to work with the finance department to determine how the community can contribute to the internet access initiative for Housing Authority residents.
  • Shonda Sanford stated that the Housing Authority’s RFP process for internet access ends on Monday, after which they will know how to proceed with implementation.

Impact

This meeting addressed several critical areas of city governance, including infrastructure, public safety, and equity. The approval of the $1.25 million Federal Transit Administration grant will fund improvements to bus stops, including map holders, signage, shelters, seating, and trash cans, enhancing transit accessibility. The change order for the North Fork Water Treatment Plant ensures the facility can meet regulatory requirements for water safety. The condemnation of the stormwater easement at 2 Springdale Road is necessary to maintain the schedule for a capital improvement project in the Kenilworth neighborhood.

The public hearings on the HUD Five-Year Consolidated Action Plan, the 2020-21 Action Plan, and the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) amendments were continued to future dates (October 27 and November 10, 2020) to allow for additional public input and written comments. The UDO amendments are required to align the city’s development code with new state legislation (Chapter 160D) by July 1, 2021. The zoning amendment for the Jewish Community Center’s Hilde’s House infant care facility was recessed to October 27, 2020, for a final vote.

The Manager’s Report provided updates on the city’s response to the Black Asheville Demands coalition, highlighting ongoing efforts to address racial justice and economic inclusion, including the Vance Monument task force, reimagining public safety, and restorative justice initiatives. The presentation on Learning PODS highlighted the city’s partnership with schools and the Housing Authority to support student engagement and equity, with a focus on addressing the opportunity gap for Black and Brown children. The work session on hotel development regulations began the process of creating new zoning tools to manage hotel impacts, with further discussion scheduled for October 27, 2020.

Loading what was decided…

Meeting Video & Transcript

Loading video…
Loading the agenda…

Get More From Sunshine Meetings

Bookmarks Notifications Saved Searches